Electrical Engineering › Section L · Power (ac) and resonance › Topic L.4

Wattmeters and effective resistance

A voltmeter and an ammeter tell you the apparent power, never the real power. A wattmeter measures what is actually used, and with it you can find a component's true ac resistance, which is often well above what an ohmmeter shows.

Why voltmeters and ammeters are not enough

Multiply an rms voltage reading by an rms current reading and you get \(S = VI\), the apparent power. The real power \(P = VI\cos\theta\) also depends on the phase angle, which neither meter sees. Measuring real power needs an instrument that multiplies the instantaneous voltage and current and averages the result over each cycle. That is a wattmeter. The topic "Power, efficiency, and energy" introduced it for dc circuits; exactly the same instrument and connections work for ac, because averaging \(v\,i\) gives the real power for any periodic waveform.

How an electrodynamometer wattmeter works

The classic analogue wattmeter has two sets of coils. A pair of fixed current coils, of thick wire and low resistance, is connected in series with the load, so it carries the load current. A light moving voltage (or potential) coil, in series with a large resistor, is connected across the load, so its current is proportional to the load voltage. The torque on the moving coil is proportional to the product of the two currents, and so to \(v\,i\) at each instant. The pointer and its movement are far too sluggish to follow the 120 Hz power wave, so they settle at the average: the meter reads \(VI\cos\theta\).

Connections and ratings

Each coil has one terminal marked ±. Connect both marked terminals on the source side, current coil in series and voltage coil across the load, and an absorbing load reads upscale; reverse one coil and the pointer drives below zero. A wattmeter has three separate ratings: current, voltage and power. Any one can be exceeded while the others are fine. On a highly reactive load the current coil can be overloaded while the pointer shows only a small reading. For such loads there are low-power-factor wattmeters, whose full-scale reading is only a fraction of their volt-ampere rating, so small powers at full current read accurately. Work on these connections only with the circuit isolated.

Digital power meters and power-factor meters

Modern power analysers sample the voltage and current thousands of times per cycle, convert the samples to numbers, multiply them sample by sample and average. From the same data they compute \(P\), \(S\), \(Q\) and the power factor, and they stay accurate even when the waveforms are distorted rather than sinusoidal. Many clamp-on instruments sense the current with a clamp-on current transformer around one conductor and take the voltage from two test leads, so the circuit never has to be broken. A power-factor meter does the same job for one number, and site surveys use it to choose correction capacitors, as in the topic "Power-factor correction".

Effective resistance

The dc resistance of a conductor, \(R = \rho\ell/A\), depends only on its material and dimensions. In an ac circuit the resistance that matters is the effective resistance: the resistance that would account for all the real power the component absorbs.

R_{\text{eff}} = \frac{P}{I^2}

It cannot be found from \(V/I\), which gives the magnitude of the impedance, resistance and reactance together. You need a wattmeter for \(P\) and an ammeter for \(I\). At ac, \(R_{\text{eff}}\) is at least the dc value and often much more, because several mechanisms absorb extra real power as frequency rises or when iron is present.

What raises effective resistance

Radiation: some energy leaves as electromagnetic waves; negligible at 60 Hz but important at radio frequencies, and the whole point of an antenna. Skin effect: the changing magnetic field inside a conductor pushes ac current towards its surface, shrinking the area it uses. In copper the current is concentrated within a skin depth of about 8.4 mm at 60 Hz but only about 0.065 mm at 1 MHz, so radio-frequency conductors are often hollow tubes. Eddy currents: voltages induced in an iron core drive circulating currents, with loss roughly proportional to \(f^2B^2\); thin insulated laminations cut it. Hysteresis: the loss in repeatedly magnetising the core grows roughly as \(fB^n\), with \(n\) depending on the material; silicon steel reduces it.

Worked example: measuring a coil

An air-core coil on 120 V, 60 Hz draws 2.50 A, and a wattmeter reads 45.0 W. Find its effective resistance and inductance. 1. \(R_{\text{eff}} = P/I^2 = 45.0/2.50^2 = 7.20\,\Omega\). 2. \(|Z| = V/I = 120/2.50 = 48.0\,\Omega\). 3. \(X_L = \sqrt{48.0^2 - 7.20^2} = 47.5\,\Omega\). 4. \(L = X_L/(2\pi f) = 47.5/377 = 126\) mH. 5. Check with the power triangle: \(Q = I^2X_L = 297\) VAR and \(\sqrt{45.0^2 + 297^2} = 300\) VA, which matches \(VI = 300\) VA. The power factor is \(45/300 = 0.15\) lagging.

Worked example: adding an iron core

A solid iron core is pushed into the same coil. Now the current is 1.20 A and the wattmeter reads 30.0 W. 1. \(R_{\text{eff}} = 30.0/1.20^2 = 20.8\,\Omega\). 2. \(|Z| = 120/1.20 = 100\,\Omega\). 3. \(X_L = \sqrt{100^2 - 20.8^2} = 97.8\,\Omega\), so \(L = 97.8/377 = 259\) mH. 4. Interpret: the iron gives far more flux for the same current, so the inductance roughly doubles. The same strong, changing flux drives eddy currents and hysteresis in the solid core, so \(R_{\text{eff}}\) rises by \(13.6\,\Omega\). At 1.20 A that represents \(1.20^2 \times 13.6 = 19.6\) W of core loss, which no ohmmeter reading could ever reveal.

Application: demand charges

Large customers are often billed for demand as well as energy, and the demand charge is where power factor bites. Take a fictional utility, Riverbend Electric, that bills demand at $11.50 per kW on the larger of the measured kW and 0.9 times the measured kVA. A plant with a peak of 300 kW and 400 kVA (power factor 0.75 lagging) is billed for \(0.9 \times 400 = 360\) kW, which is $4140 instead of the $3450 that 300 kW would cost. Correcting it to 0.95 lagging lowers the kVA to 316, and \(0.9 \times 316 = 284\) kW is below the measured 300 kW, so the $690 penalty disappears.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, multiplying voltmeter and ammeter readings and calling it watts: that is \(S\), not \(P\). Second, trusting a small wattmeter reading to mean a safe current: check the current rating separately. Third, connecting the voltage coil on the wrong side or the ± terminals reversed, giving a backwards reading. Fourth, taking \(V/I\) as the resistance of an ac component: it is \(|Z|\); use \(P/I^2\). Fifth, assuming the ohmmeter's dc value holds at ac: skin effect and core losses can raise \(R_{\text{eff}}\) a great deal.

Key takeaways

A wattmeter averages \(v\,i\) and so reads real power \(VI\cos\theta\) on dc, ac or distorted waveforms. Its current coil goes in series with the load and its voltage coil across it, with both ± terminals on the source side, and its current, voltage and power ratings must each be respected. Digital meters and clamp-on power-factor meters give \(P\), \(Q\), \(S\) and \(F_p\) together. Effective resistance is \(R_{\text{eff}} = P/I^2\); radiation, skin effect, eddy currents (about \(f^2B^2\)) and hysteresis (about \(fB^n\)) raise it above the dc value. Demand tariffs make poor power factor costly.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Wattmeter

Instrument that averages v × i to read real power

Works on dc, ac and distorted waveforms.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A motor on 230 V draws 6.0 A, and a wattmeter reads 1.10 kW. What is its power factor?

Question 2 of 5

A coil on 120 V, 60 Hz draws 3.0 A, and a wattmeter reads 72 W. What is its effective resistance?

Question 3 of 5

Why does an electrodynamometer wattmeter read the average power rather than the instantaneous power?

Question 4 of 5

What happens to the effective resistance of a copper conductor as the frequency rises into the megahertz range?

Question 5 of 5

A wattmeter on a highly inductive load reads only 20% of full scale. What should you check before trusting that the meter is safe?

← Previous topicNext topic →