Electrical Engineering › Section H · Magnetic circuits and inductors › Topic H.2

Reluctance, magnetizing force, and hysteresis

A coil drives flux round an iron core much as a battery drives current round a resistor. This topic builds that analogy, then shows where it breaks down: iron's response depends on how hard it is driven and on its own history.

Borrowing the electric-circuit pattern

Ohm's law can be read as effect equals cause divided by opposition: \(I = E/R\). A magnetic core has the same three roles. The effect is the flux \(\Phi\) set up in the core. The cause is the magnetomotive force, or mmf, supplied by a current-carrying winding. The opposition is the reluctance of the core. Keep one difference in mind from the start: flux is not a flow of anything. No particles travel round the core; the winding sets up a magnetic state in the material, and \(\Phi\) measures how much of it there is.

Reluctance

The reluctance of a uniform section of core, symbol \(\mathcal{R}\), is

\mathcal{R} = \frac{l}{\mu A}

where \(l\) is the mean length of the flux path in metres, \(A\) the cross-sectional area in square metres and \(\mu\) the permeability. Its unit is the ampere-turn per weber, At/Wb. Compare resistance, \(R = \rho l / A\): both grow with length and shrink with area. The difference is that resistance rises with resistivity, while reluctance falls as permeability rises. That is why iron, with its huge \(\mu\), makes such an easy path for flux, and why air is a poor one.

Magnetomotive force and Ohm's law for magnetic circuits

A winding of \(N\) turns carrying current \(I\) supplies an mmf

\mathcal{F} = NI

measured in ampere-turns, At. The turns are a count, so strictly the unit is the ampere, but writing At keeps the meaning clear. Only the product matters: 200 turns carrying 0.5 A and 50 turns carrying 2 A both give 100 At. Ohm's law for a magnetic circuit is then

\Phi = \frac{\mathcal{F}}{\mathcal{R}}

More turns or more current push more flux through the core; more reluctance lets less through.

Worked example: flux in a ring core

A cast-steel ring has a mean path length of 0.20 m and a cross-section of \(4.0 \times 10^{-4}\,\text{m}^2\). A 250-turn winding carries 0.40 A. Assume \(\mu_r = 1500\) at this operating level. Find the flux. 1. Reluctance:

\mathcal{R} = \frac{0.20}{(1500)(4\pi \times 10^{-7})(4.0 \times 10^{-4})}

which is \(2.65 \times 10^5\,\text{At/Wb}\). 2. Mmf: \(\mathcal{F} = 250 \times 0.40 = 100\,\text{At}\). 3. Flux: \(\Phi = 100 / (2.65 \times 10^5)\), which is \(3.77 \times 10^{-4}\,\text{Wb}\). 4. Check: with no steel the reluctance would be 1500 times larger, \(3.98 \times 10^8\,\text{At/Wb}\), and the flux only 0.251 µWb.

Magnetizing force and B = μH

The mmf per metre of flux path is the magnetizing force, also called the magnetic field intensity:

H = \frac{\mathcal{F}}{l} = \frac{NI}{l}

in ampere-turns per metre, At/m. It depends only on the turns, the current and the path length, not on the core material. The material decides how much flux density that drive produces:

B = \mu H

In the ring above, \(H = 100 / 0.20 = 500\,\text{At/m}\), and \(B = 1500\mu_0 \times 500 = 0.942\,\text{T}\), the same as \(\Phi / A\). Note the typography: the italic \(H\) is magnetizing force, while the upright H is the henry, the unit of inductance.

The B-H curve and saturation

For a ferromagnetic material, a graph of \(B\) against \(H\), the magnetisation curve, is not a straight line. It rises steeply at first, bends over at a region called the knee, then flattens: the material saturates, and extra magnetizing force adds very little flux density. Because \(\mu = B/H\) is the slope of a line from the origin to the operating point, permeability is not constant. It climbs to a maximum near the knee and then falls. Typical electrical steels saturate at roughly 1.5 to 2 T, and ferrites at roughly 0.3 to 0.5 T. Manufacturers therefore publish curves, not one value of \(\mu_r\).

Worked example: reading a curve

A datasheet curve for a silicon-steel lamination shows \(H = 300\,\text{At/m}\) at \(B = 1.2\,\text{T}\), and \(H = 2000\,\text{At/m}\) at \(B = 1.6\,\text{T}\). 1. At 1.2 T: \(\mu = 1.2 / 300 = 4.0 \times 10^{-3}\,\text{H/m}\), so \(\mu_r = \mu / \mu_0 \approx 3180\). 2. At 1.6 T: \(\mu = 1.6/2000 = 8.0 \times 10^{-4}\,\text{H/m}\), so \(\mu_r \approx 637\). Pushing a third more flux density cost almost seven times the magnetizing force: the steel is nearing saturation. 3. For a core of mean length 0.25 m with 200 turns at 1.2 T: \(NI = Hl = 300 \times 0.25 = 75\,\text{At}\), so \(I = 75/200 = 0.375\,\text{A}\).

The hysteresis loop

Start with unmagnetised steel and raise \(H\): \(B\) climbs the magnetisation curve to saturation. Now reduce \(H\) to zero. \(B\) does not retrace its path; it falls only to the residual flux density \(B_R\), also called remanence. To bring \(B\) to zero you must reverse the winding current until \(H\) reaches \(-H_c\), the coercive force. Drive on to saturation in the reverse direction, then back through zero to positive saturation, and the path closes into a loop that is symmetric about the origin. The name comes from the Greek for lagging behind: \(B\) always trails the changes in \(H\). So the value of \(B\) at a given \(H\) depends on the material's history.

Why iron behaves this way: domains

Spinning electrons make each iron atom a tiny magnet. In a ferromagnetic material, neighbouring atoms line up in small regions called domains, each fully magnetised in one direction. In an unmagnetised sample the domains point every which way and their fields cancel. An applied \(H\) makes the domains already close to its direction grow at the expense of the others, and eventually swings the rest round. Once all are aligned, the material is saturated. When \(H\) is removed, many domains stay aligned rather than springing back, which is the residual flux density and the reason permanent magnets exist.

Hysteresis loss, soft and hard materials

Driving a core round its loop costs energy, released as heat. The area of the loop equals the energy lost per cubic metre in each cycle, so the loss power is that area times the core volume times the frequency. For a loop of \(200\,\text{J/m}^3\) in a \(5.0 \times 10^{-4}\,\text{m}^3\) core at 60 Hz,

P = 200 \times (5.0 \times 10^{-4}) \times 60 = 6.0\,\text{W}

Soft magnetic materials, such as silicon steel and ferrites, have narrow loops and low coercive force: ideal for transformer and inductor cores, which are cycled continuously. Hard magnetic materials, such as neodymium-iron-boron and alnico, have wide loops, high coercive force and high remanence: ideal for permanent magnets.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, dropping \(\mu_0\) when computing reluctance from \(\mu_r\): use \(\mu = \mu_r\mu_0\). Second, using the outer or inner length of a ring instead of the mean path length. Third, treating \(\mu_r\) as constant up to and beyond the knee of the curve. Fourth, confusing residual flux density, the \(B\) left at zero \(H\), with coercive force, the reverse \(H\) needed to clear it. Fifth, forgetting that hysteresis loss grows in proportion to frequency. Sixth, reading the italic \(H\) as the henry.

Key takeaways

Reluctance \(\mathcal{R} = l/(\mu A)\) opposes flux; mmf \(\mathcal{F} = NI\) drives it; \(\Phi = \mathcal{F}/\mathcal{R}\). Magnetizing force \(H = NI/l\) is mmf per metre and ignores the material; \(B = \mu H\) brings the material in. The B-H curve rises, bends at the knee and saturates, so \(\mu\) changes with operating level. A hysteresis loop shows residual flux density \(B_R\) and coercive force \(H_c\), explained by magnetic domains. Loop area is energy lost per cubic metre per cycle: soft materials suit cores, hard materials suit permanent magnets.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Magnetic Ohm's law

Φ = ℱ / ℛ: flux equals mmf divided by reluctance

Effect = cause / opposition.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A core section has mean length 0.30 m, cross-section 5.0 × 10⁻⁴ m² and relative permeability 1200. What is its reluctance?

Question 2 of 5

A 400-turn winding carries 0.25 A round a core whose mean path length is 0.40 m. What is the magnetizing force?

Question 3 of 5

On a steel sample's hysteresis loop, what is the flux density that remains when the magnetizing force is brought back to zero?

Question 4 of 5

Which kind of material makes the best core for a transformer that is cycled 60 times a second?

Question 5 of 5

A core of volume 2.0 × 10⁻⁴ m³ has a hysteresis loop area of 300 J/m³. What hysteresis loss does it have at 60 Hz?

← Previous topicNext topic →