Electrical Engineering › Section M · Transformers and polyphase systems › Topic M.9
Three-phase power and wattmeter methods
Three-phase power is three single-phase powers added together, and for balanced loads one tidy formula, √3 V_L I_L cos θ, covers both Y and Δ. Measuring it takes three wattmeters, or, on a three-wire system, cleverly just two.
Power in each phase
Each phase of a three-phase load is an ordinary ac load, so the ideas of "The power triangle and total P, Q, and S" apply phase by phase. With phase voltage \(V_\phi\), phase current \(I_\phi\) and \(\theta\) the angle of the phase impedance, which is the angle between \(V_\phi\) and \(I_\phi\):
As in the earlier power topics, Q is signed: positive for an inductive load, negative for a capacitive one. The totals are the sums over the three phases. For a balanced load all three phases are identical, so \(P_T = 3P_\phi\), \(Q_T = 3Q_\phi\) and \(S_T = 3S_\phi\). Phase sequence ABC is assumed throughout, as in the earlier three-phase topics.
Totals from line quantities
Line values are easier to measure than phase values, especially inside a closed Δ. In a balanced Y, \(V_\phi = V_L/\sqrt{3}\) and \(I_\phi = I_L\); in a balanced Δ, \(V_\phi = V_L\) and \(I_\phi = I_L/\sqrt{3}\). Either way, \(3V_\phi I_\phi = \sqrt{3}V_LI_L\), so for any balanced load:
The power factor is \(F_p = P_T/S_T = \cos\theta\), leading or lagging. Note that \(\theta\) is still the phase impedance angle, not the angle between a line voltage and a line current; in a Y those differ by 30°.
Worked example: a balanced Y load
A 277/480 V system feeds a balanced Y load of \(12 + j9\,\Omega\) per phase, in rectangular form. Find \(P_T\), \(Q_T\), \(S_T\) and the power factor. 1. Polar impedance: \(15\angle 36.87^\circ\,\Omega\). 2. Phase current: \(I_\phi = 277.1/15 = 18.48\,\text{A}\), which is also the line current. 3. Per phase: \(P_\phi = 18.48^2 \times 12 = 4.10\,\text{kW}\) and \(Q_\phi = 18.48^2 \times 9 = 3.07\,\text{kVAR}\). 4. Totals: \(P_T = 12.3\,\text{kW}\), \(Q_T = +9.22\,\text{kVAR}\) (inductive), \(S_T = 3 \times 277.1 \times 18.48 = 15.4\,\text{kVA}\). 5. Power factor: \(12.29/15.36 = 0.80\) lagging. 6. Check with line values: \(\sqrt{3} \times 480 \times 18.48 \times 0.80 = 12.3\,\text{kW}\).
The three-wattmeter method
A wattmeter, as in "Wattmeters and effective resistance", reads \(VI\cos\) of the angle between the voltage across its potential coil and the current through its current coil. For a four-wire Y load, place one wattmeter in each phase: its current coil in series with the line, and its potential coil from that line to the neutral. Each reads its own phase power, and the total is simply
This works for balanced and unbalanced loads alike. For a Δ load, the same idea applies with each current coil in series with a branch and its potential coil across that branch. If the load is known to be balanced, a single wattmeter reading times three gives the total.
The two-wattmeter method
On a three-wire system, Y or Δ, balanced or not, two wattmeters are enough. Put their current coils in two of the lines, say A and C, and connect each potential coil from its own line to the third line, B. Then
as an algebraic sum: one reading may be negative. The reason is that with only three wires, the line currents must sum to zero, so measuring voltages relative to line B lets the third wattmeter's reading drop out entirely. When a meter deflects below zero, reverse its current-coil leads to get an upscale reading, and then count that reading as negative.
What the two readings reveal
For a balanced load with sequence ABC and the connection above, the line voltage \(\mathbf{V}_{AB}\) leads the phase voltage \(\mathbf{V}_{an}\) by 30°, as in any balanced Y with this sequence. Working through the angles gives
with \(\theta\) positive for a lagging load and negative for a leading one. Their sum is \(\sqrt{3}V_LI_L\cos\theta\), and their difference gives the reactive power: \(Q_T = \sqrt{3}(W_C - W_A)\). So \(\tan\theta = \sqrt{3}(W_C - W_A)/(W_A + W_C)\). At unity power factor the readings are equal; at power factor 0.5 the lower reading is zero; below 0.5 it is negative.
Worked example: two wattmeters on the same load
Measure the load from the previous example, with \(V_L = 480\,\text{V}\), unrounded \(I_L = 18.475\,\text{A}\) and \(\theta = 36.87^\circ\) lagging. 1. \(W_A = 480 \times 18.475 \times \cos 66.87^\circ\), which is 3483.6 W. 2. \(W_C = 480 \times 18.475 \times \cos(-6.87^\circ)\), which is 8804.4 W. 3. Total power: 12,288 W, matching \(P_T = 12.3\,\text{kW}\). 4. Reactive power: \(\sqrt{3}(8804.4 - 3483.6)\), which is +9216 VAR, matching \(Q_T\). 5. Power factor: \(\tan\theta = 9216/12{,}288 = 0.75\), so \(\theta = 36.87^\circ\) and \(F_p = 0.80\), recovered from the two readings alone.
Unbalanced four-wire Y loads
With a neutral conductor joining the load's star point to the source, each load phase is held at the source phase voltage however unequal the impedances are. Each phase current is then just \(V_\phi/Z_\phi\), and the neutral carries their phasor sum, \(\mathbf{I}_N = \mathbf{I}_a + \mathbf{I}_b + \mathbf{I}_c\). Example: on a 120/208 V supply, resistive phases of 10 Ω, 20 Ω and 15 Ω draw \(12\angle 0^\circ\), \(6\angle -120^\circ\) and \(8\angle 120^\circ\) amperes. In rectangular form these are \(12\), \(-3 - j5.20\) and \(-4 + j6.93\), so \(\mathbf{I}_N = 5 + j1.73\,\text{A}\), or \(5.29\angle 19.1^\circ\,\text{A}\) in polar form. The total power is \(1440 + 720 + 960 = 3120\,\text{W}\). Designers spread single-phase loads across the phases to keep the system as balanced as possible.
Unbalanced three-wire Y loads
Remove the neutral from an unbalanced Y and the load's star point is free to float. The three load currents must now sum to zero, so the phase voltages adjust: the load voltages are no longer equal, and with resistive loads the most lightly loaded phase, the one with the highest impedance, receives more than the normal phase voltage, rising towards the line voltage in extreme cases. Solving such a load needs mesh or nodal analysis, as in "Dependent sources, source conversions, mesh and nodal analysis (ac)". This is why a broken neutral in a building can overvoltage and damage equipment. The same effect has a use: a phase-sequence indicator, a capacitor and two lamps in Y, lights one lamp brightly for ABC and the other for ACB.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, using \(\sqrt{3}V_LI_L\cos\theta\) for an unbalanced load; it holds only when balanced, so sum the phases instead. Second, taking \(\theta\) as the angle between a line voltage and a line current; it is the phase impedance angle. Third, adding the two wattmeter magnitudes when one reading is negative; below power factor 0.5 the total is the difference. Fourth, using the two-wattmeter method on a four-wire system with neutral current; it needs three wires. Fifth, assuming an unbalanced three-wire Y keeps equal phase voltages; without a neutral, they shift.
Key takeaways
Per phase, P = VφIφ cos θ = Iφ²R and Q = VφIφ sin θ = Iφ²X, with θ the phase impedance angle; totals are sums over the phases. For balanced Y or Δ loads, P_T = √3 V_L I_L cos θ, Q_T = √3 V_L I_L sin θ and S_T = √3 V_L I_L. Three wattmeters measure any load, one per phase. Two wattmeters measure any three-wire load: P_T = W_A + W_C, algebraically. For balanced loads the readings are V_L I_L cos(30° ± θ), Q_T = √3(W_C − W_A), signed, and one reading is negative below power factor 0.5. A four-wire unbalanced Y has I_N = Ia + Ib + Ic; a three-wire unbalanced Y has a floating star point.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Real power in one phase; also I_φ² R_φ
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A balanced three-phase load draws 20.0 A from a 208 V line at a power factor of 0.85 lagging. What total real power does it take?
Question 2 of 5
A balanced Δ load has a branch impedance of 8 + j6 Ω, and each branch carries 15 A. What is the total reactive power?
Question 3 of 5
Two wattmeters, connected as in the reading, measure a balanced three-wire load: W_A = 2.0 kW and W_C = 6.0 kW. What are the total power and the reactive power?
Question 4 of 5
In the two-wattmeter method on a balanced lagging load, W_A reads zero. What is the power factor of the load?
Question 5 of 5
A four-wire Y supply with 120 V phases feeds resistive loads drawing 10 A, 10 A and 0 A in phases a, b and c. What is the neutral current?
