English Composition › Section N · The annotated bibliography › Topic N.3

Writing an annotated bibliography

An annotated bibliography turns a list of sources into a record of thinking. Writing a short paragraph about each source makes you read it closely, judge it fairly and decide what it can do for your argument, long before you start drafting.

Citation plus annotation

A bibliography lists sources; an annotated bibliography adds a paragraph, the annotation, after each citation. The annotation summarises the source, evaluates it and reflects on how it fits your project. Instructors often set one before a research paper, because it moves you from collecting sources to interacting with them: you read more closely, think more critically and see where your claim fits in the conversation. You may not use every source you annotate in the final paper, and that is normal.

What an annotated bibliography is for

Its functions depend on when you write it and why. Written early, it helps you form a thesis, because judging sources shows you what the evidence supports. Written later, it can serve as a review of the research on your question. In either case it shows how much research you have done and how good it is. It also helps other people: a reader working on a similar question can use your annotations to decide which sources are worth reading in full.

Annotations are not abstracts

An abstract, found at the start of a journal article or in a database, is a short, purely descriptive summary of a paper's content, methods and findings, usually written by the paper's own authors. An annotation is written by you, and it usually goes further: it judges the source and explains its use. Annotations come in two broad types. A descriptive, or informative, annotation summarises the source and explains why it is relevant, noting features such as data or graphics, without evaluating its argument. An analytical, or critical, annotation does all that and also assesses strengths, weaknesses and bias, and explains how the source shapes your research. Argumentative projects almost always call for analytical annotations.

The three parts of an annotation

A full annotation has three parts. Summary: usually one to three sentences, in your own words, giving the author, where and when the work appeared, and its main argument or findings. Evaluation: the source's authority and the author's credentials, any agenda or bias, and how valid and reliable its evidence is. Reflection: how the source fits your project, whether it supports your claim, challenges it, fills a gap or changes your thinking. Most annotations run one or two paragraphs, roughly 100 to 200 words. Write objectively: judge the source on its reliability, validity and bias, not on whether you agree with it. Many instructors prefer the third person; follow your assignment.

Gathering sources and a working thesis

Start by listing keywords, known authors, organisations and any sources you have already found. A broad web search can teach you definitions, key terms and the range of opinion, and may suggest better search terms. Then search academic databases for scholarly articles, books and reputable periodicals. Aim for five to seven sources at first, choosing a range of perspectives, and add more as your claims develop. Before selecting, draft a working thesis so you know what the sources must support or test. Frames help: "Because ___, ___ should ___." or "Although ___ looks like ___, the evidence points to ___."

A source evaluation organiser

Before writing paragraphs, fill in a simple organiser for each source, with eight headings: the citation; the intended audience; the main ideas and arguments; the author's point of view, bias and expertise; how it compares with your other sources; its relevance to your topic; its strengths and weaknesses; and the conclusions the author draws. Some boxes will stay thin, especially for short sources you use for one fact, and that is fine. The organiser separates thinking from writing: by the time you draft the annotation, the analysis is already done, and you only have to shape it into paragraphs.

Worked example: filling the organiser

Working thesis: "Because free meals for all students remove stigma, states should fund universal free school lunch." Invented source, offered as an example: Elise Hartmann's 2023 article in Education Policy Quarterly. 1. Audience: education researchers and policymakers; the journal is peer-reviewed. 2. Main ideas: in 40 districts that adopted universal free lunch, participation rose most among students who had qualified before but had not taken meals. 3. Expertise: Hartmann is an education economist. 4. Comparison: other sources stress cost; this one measures uptake. 5. Strengths: clear methods and recent data. Weaknesses: mostly urban districts. 6. Conclusion: removing eligibility forms raises uptake.

Worked example: a finished MLA entry

Hartmann, Elise. "Who Eats Free? Participation after Universal School Lunch." Education Policy Quarterly, vol. 19, no. 2, 2023, pp. 77-95, https://doi.org/10.5555/epq.2023.077. Annotation: Education economist Elise Hartmann compares meal participation in 40 districts before and after they adopted universal free lunch, finding the largest rise among students who were already eligible but had not used free meals. The peer-reviewed study describes its methods clearly and uses recent data, though most of its districts are urban. It supports the claim that removing eligibility forms reduces stigma, and its urban sample shows that rural evidence is still needed. Analysis: 1. Sentence 1 summarises. 2. Sentence 2 evaluates. 3. Sentence 3 reflects and identifies a gap. 4. A real annotation would usually be longer, around 100 to 200 words.

Formatting in MLA 9 and APA 7

Title the page Annotated Bibliography (MLA also accepts Annotated List of Works Cited). List entries alphabetically by their first word, usually the author's surname; for a source with no author, use the title's first word, ignoring A, An and The. In a very long list, you may group entries by subtopic. Double-space throughout, and give each citation a hanging indent of half an inch. MLA 9 indents the annotation as a block one inch from the left margin, half an inch beyond the hanging indent. APA 7 indents the annotation half an inch, in line with the hanging indent. Follow your instructor's style; the citations themselves follow the rules of that style exactly.

Worked example: strengthening a weak annotation

Weak annotation: "This article is about school lunches. It has lots of interesting information and I agreed with it." Revised: "Hartmann tracks meal participation in 40 districts after universal free lunch began, finding the biggest gains among eligible students who had avoided free meals. Her recent, peer-reviewed data are persuasive for cities, but rural districts are barely represented. The study supports the stigma argument and points to the need for rural evidence." Analysis: 1. The weak version names a topic rather than summarising findings. 2. "Interesting" gives no evaluation. 3. Agreement is not a criterion. 4. The revision adds summary, evaluation and reflection, each specific.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, writing summary only, with no evaluation or reflection. Second, copying the source's abstract instead of writing your own annotation. Third, judging a source by whether you agree with it. Fourth, citations that break the required style. Fifth, ordering entries by date found rather than alphabetically. Sixth, choosing only sources that agree with your thesis. Seventh, using MLA's indentation in an APA bibliography, or the reverse.

Key takeaways

An annotated bibliography pairs each citation with an annotation that summarises, evaluates and reflects. Analytical annotations, which judge strengths, weaknesses and bias, suit argumentative work; descriptive ones only summarise. An annotation is your judgement, unlike an author's abstract. Gather five to seven varied sources around a working thesis, fill an organiser for each, then write one or two objective paragraphs of roughly 100 to 200 words. Alphabetise, double-space and use hanging indents; MLA 9 indents annotations one inch, APA 7 half an inch.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Annotated bibliography

A list of citations, each followed by an annotation

Often set before a research paper.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

"It supports the claim that removing eligibility forms reduces stigma, but its urban sample shows that rural evidence is still needed." Which part of an annotation is this?

Question 2 of 5

How does an annotation differ from an abstract?

Question 3 of 5

A student's annotations summarise each source and explain why it is relevant, but never assess strengths, weaknesses or bias. What type are they?

Question 4 of 5

In an MLA 9 annotated bibliography, where does the annotation go?

Question 5 of 5

A source has no author and is titled "The Hidden Cost of Free Lunch." Under which letter is it alphabetised in an MLA list?

← Previous topicNext topic →