English Composition › Section O · The case study profile › Topic O.1

Case studies: observation, description, analysis

A case study looks closely at one person or a small group to learn something larger about how people think, act and use language. Knowing what the genre can claim, and how it is built, lets you read case studies critically and write one of your own.

One person, larger questions

Some research questions are hidden inside people: how a child learns to read, how a nurse calms a frightened patient, how a bilingual student moves between languages. A case study is the genre researchers use to explore such questions up close. It is a piece of academic writing that reports firsthand observation of one participant or a small group, usually in their everyday setting, and draws careful conclusions from it. Education, psychology, sociology, linguistics, medicine and business all rely on case studies.

What a case study can claim

Because a case study examines a limited sample in a limited setting, its authors rarely claim universal laws. Instead they interpret what they saw, propose hypotheses and point to questions that need wider study. Many studies name the blind spots that current research has missed and invite other researchers to fill them. The genre's strength is depth: rich detail lets readers picture themselves in the situation, which is why trainee teachers and doctors study cases. Its limit is breadth, so careful writers say "in this case" or "suggests" rather than "proves".

From one case to a theory

A well-known case shows both sides. In 1953 a surgeon removed parts of both medial temporal lobes of a 27-year-old man, Henry Molaison, to control severe epilepsy. Afterwards he could not form new lasting memories of facts and events, though his intelligence and many older memories remained. The psychologist Brenda Milner, who studied him for decades, found that he still improved at a mirror-drawing task over several days without remembering having practised it. One patient could not prove how memory works, but his case suggested that the brain has more than one memory system, a hypothesis that later research tested widely. That is the usual path: a single case raises a question that wider research then examines.

Qualitative and quantitative data

Case studies gather two kinds of evidence. Qualitative data is descriptive: what participants say in interviews, what you notice them doing, the tone of a conversation. It is rich but hard to replicate, because it belongs to one place, day and observer. Quantitative data is numerical: counts, measurements, percentages or survey ratings that others could check or repeat under similar conditions. Most case studies are mainly qualitative, but many add numbers to make a pattern visible. Noting that a participant switched from English to Tagalog 12 times in a 20-minute phone call is quantitative; noting when and why she switched is qualitative.

Natural settings

Case study researchers try to observe participants in their natural environment, the places where the behaviour normally happens: a workplace, a classroom, a kitchen table, a team practice. Observations made there are called field observations. The observation environment is the location and conditions in which they take place, and the write-up must describe it. A natural setting gives more realistic evidence than a staged one, but watching still changes things: people may speak more formally when they know someone is taking notes. Good researchers record what they saw, when and where, and note how their presence might have shaped it.

The ethics of studying people

Research on human participants carries obligations. Participants must give informed consent: they learn the study's purpose and what will be shared, give their permission (in writing, for a class study) and may withdraw. Researchers must avoid physical or psychological harm, protect privacy, often with pseudonyms, and report data honestly, without bias. Debates over past studies shaped these rules. In the US Public Health Service's Tuskegee study (1932-1972), researchers observed hundreds of Black men with syphilis without telling them their diagnosis, and withheld penicillin even after it became the standard cure in the 1940s. Outrage after the study was exposed in 1972 led to the National Research Act of 1974. Today, in the US, most university research with people needs approval from an institutional review board (IRB). For an informal class study, follow your instructor's and college's policy.

The five parts of a case study

Most case studies follow a standard structure. 1. Background, or literature review: what earlier studies found, so readers see where this one fits. 2. Participants and observation environment: who was studied, and in what conditions. 3. Methods: how the data was collected, such as interviews, surveys, observation or document analysis. 4. Findings, or results: the data, presented in an organised way. 5. Analysis: the author's interpretation of the data, including the study's limitations and gaps. The voice is formal and objective, sections usually carry headings, and sources are documented, most often in APA style.

Key terms

A few terms recur. The research question is the focused question the study sets out to answer, and everything else is planned around it. Data is any information gathered, from observation notes to interview answers. Participants are the people (or, in some fields, animals) being observed. Results and analysis are easy to confuse. Results state what the data shows, such as "the participant used formal greetings in all six work calls"; analysis explains what that may mean and why. Keeping them in separate sections lets readers judge your evidence before your interpretation.

Worked example: a participants and methods passage

Model passage: "The participant, called R. in this report, is a 19-year-old nursing student who speaks Vietnamese at home and English at college. Over two weeks, I observed her in two settings: a study group in the campus library and a family dinner, attended with her consent. I also conducted a 30-minute interview of 12 open-ended questions and counted her uses of each language during both observations." Analysis: 1. A pseudonym protects her privacy. 2. Relevant background is given, without unneeded personal detail. 3. Both observation environments are named. 4. The time frame is stated. 5. The methods are specific enough to judge: interview length, question type and a counting procedure, which supplies quantitative data.

Worked example: observation versus interpretation

Field note: "In the library group, R. spoke English throughout, but she twice sent Vietnamese voice messages to her sister during breaks." Draft analysis: "R. is embarrassed by Vietnamese." Revised analysis: "R. appears to reserve Vietnamese for family contact, even on campus; whether this reflects audience, privacy or habit would need further interviews." Analysis: 1. The field note is description: it reports what happened, with a count. 2. The draft leaps to a feeling the evidence cannot show. 3. The revision makes a claim the data supports, hedged with "appears". 4. It names other possible explanations. 5. It identifies a gap, turning a limitation into an opportunity for further research.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, claiming that one participant proves a rule about everyone. Second, mixing interpretation into the results, so readers cannot tell what was seen from what was guessed. Third, skipping consent, or using a participant's real name without permission. Fourth, describing methods vaguely ("I talked to her a few times"), so readers cannot judge the evidence. Fifth, observing in an artificial setting when a natural one was available. Sixth, leaving out limitations, which makes a study look more certain than it is.

Key takeaways

A case study reports firsthand observation of one participant or a small group, usually in a natural setting, and offers interpretations and hypotheses rather than universal laws. Its data is mainly qualitative, often supported by quantitative counts. Ethical research requires informed consent, no harm, privacy and honest reporting, with IRB approval for most formal studies. The standard parts are background, participants and setting, methods, findings, and analysis with limitations, written in a formal, objective voice.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Case study

Academic writing reporting firsthand observation of one participant or a small group

Depth, not breadth.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A student observes one bilingual classmate for two weeks. Which conclusion best fits the genre of the case study?

Question 2 of 5

Which observation note records quantitative data?

Question 3 of 5

In which part of a case study does the author explain the study's limitations and gaps?

Question 4 of 5

A student wants to observe a coworker for a class case study. What must come first?

Question 5 of 5

Which sentence belongs in the results section rather than the analysis?

← Previous topicNext topic →