English Composition › Section O · The case study profile › Topic O.4

Evaluating a case study

A case study is judged on more than correct sentences: readers want to see real data, clear organisation and conclusions that respect the study's limits. Evaluating your draft against those standards shows you what to fix before anyone else reads it.

A final check against the genre

By the time a case study is drafted, you have lived with your notes for weeks, so gaps that a reader would notice are easy to miss. A final evaluation compares the draft with what the genre expects and with the rubric your instructor will use. The rubric is the familiar one from earlier evaluations: three categories, namely rhetorical choices, clarity and coherence, and critical language awareness, each scored from 5 Skillful to 1 Beginning. What changes is what each category asks of a case study. This topic works through those case-study expectations and shows how to act on them.

The genre conventions

Before scoring, confirm the basics. Does the draft contain the core parts of a case study report: background and context (including the participants and observation environment), methods, findings and analysis? Is the language formal and precise, without slang outside quotations? Is the audience clear? A case study is usually written for other professionals in a field, or, for a class study of language use, for the instructors and administrators who could act on it. Are sources documented in the discipline's style, usually APA for case studies, with in-text citations matched to a reference list? A draft missing any of these needs revision before finer judgements make sense.

Critical language awareness

For this genre, critical language awareness focuses on the editing skill you have just practised: words often confused. A Skillful draft always uses words such as their, there and they're, affect and effect, and its and it's correctly; the signal words drop through usually, generally and occasionally to does not at the lower levels. The category also asks whether the writer consciously meets or challenges conventions in effective ways. In a case study that might mean deliberately quoting a participant's nonstandard spelling exactly, with a note explaining why, rather than silently correcting it.

Clarity and coherence

This category asks whether a reader can follow the study and trust its evidence. At the top level, each paragraph is unified under one clear topic, such as one criterion you studied. Background and supporting details are full enough to give a sense of completeness. Evidence of both qualitative and quantitative data collection is clear: quotations and observations, and also counts or measurements. Transitions and subheads connect the sections. Any visuals clarify abstract ideas or data. At the lower levels, details are too thin, data collection is barely visible, subheads are missing, and visuals are absent or irrelevant.

Rhetorical choices: limits and purpose

A strong case study knows what it can claim. The top level describes a writer who consistently stays within what the genre can do and is for: one participant and a few observations support a hypothesis, not a law about everyone. The writer also explains why the research matters, its implications and likely consequences, answering the reader's question "So what?" for the intended audience. A study of how one student switches languages, for example, might matter to instructors who plan group work. At the lower levels, conclusions overreach, or their relevance is explained haphazardly, if at all.

Rhetorical choices: inviting the reader

Because case studies exist to advance knowledge, the rubric rewards a writer who draws readers in by asking them to help extend the research, with ideas for how they might. That might mean naming a question your study raised and the method that could answer it, such as a survey of a larger group. The same category values a mature command of language and consistent objectivity, and it checks that quotations from participants are accurate and relevant. A quotation that is vivid but does not support the point, or that you reconstructed from memory, weakens the study.

Checking objectivity and quotations

Objectivity means reporting what the evidence shows without letting your opinions colour it. Watch for judgement words (terrible, lazy, obviously) and for claims about feelings you could not observe. Attribute statements to their source: "R. said she prefers..." is evidence, while "R. prefers..." may claim more than you know. Check every quotation against your notes or recording, word for word. If your notes are uncertain, paraphrase instead and say so. Finally, confirm that the participant's real name appears nowhere unless they agreed to it.

Worked example: scoring an excerpt

Excerpt: "Findings. R. used Vietnamese a lot at home. She said it was 'more comfy.' Their was also a lot of English with her brother. I think bilingual kids everywhere do this." A pie chart of R.'s favourite foods follows. Evaluation: 1. Critical language awareness: "Their" should be "There", a confused-word error. 2. Clarity and coherence: "a lot" replaces data; there are no counts, so quantitative evidence is missing. 3. The chart is irrelevant to language use. 4. Rhetorical choices: "kids everywhere" ignores the study's limits, and "I think" brings opinion into the findings. 5. Plan: fix the error, add counts from the notes, cut the chart, and move a hedged interpretation to the analysis.

Worked example: revising a conclusion

Draft: "In conclusion, R. switches languages, which is interesting." Revision: "Across four observations, R. kept Vietnamese for family and switched to English whenever a non-Vietnamese speaker joined, even mid-sentence. Because this study followed one student for two weeks, it cannot show how common the pattern is. Instructors who run group work might ask how such switching affects who speaks up, and a short survey of bilingual first-year students could test whether R.'s pattern is typical." Analysis: 1. The pattern is stated with its evidence. 2. The limit is explicit. 3. Relevance to the audience is explained. 4. Readers are invited to extend the research, with a method suggested.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, scoring the draft on effort or length rather than on what the page shows. Second, overlooking a missing section, such as methods, because the findings are interesting. Third, describing data loosely ("a lot", "often") when counts are available. Fourth, adding visuals that look impressive but do not clarify the study. Fifth, ending without implications or any invitation to further research. Sixth, letting judgement words or reconstructed quotations slip into a report that must be objective.

Key takeaways

Check first that the draft has background, methods, findings and analysis, in formal language for a clear audience and documented in APA style. Critical language awareness here means words often confused. Clarity and coherence rewards unified paragraphs, visible qualitative and quantitative data, subheads, transitions and useful visuals. Rhetorical choices rewards staying within the study's limits, explaining its implications, inviting further research, objectivity and accurate, relevant quotations.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Three rubric categories

Rhetorical choices; clarity and coherence; critical language awareness

Scored 5 Skillful to 1 Beginning.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A case study has clear subheads, and each paragraph covers one aspect of the data. Which rubric category does this mainly strengthen?

Question 2 of 5

Which sentence from a conclusion shows that the writer is working within the limits of a case study?

Question 3 of 5

At the Skillful level, what does the rubric expect a case study to do for its audience?

Question 4 of 5

Which revision best restores objectivity to "R.'s family obviously speaks terrible English at home"?

Question 5 of 5

A case study about language use includes a pie chart of the participant's favourite foods. How does the rubric treat it?

← Previous topicNext topic →