English Composition › Section F · The proposal › Topic F.2

Writing a proposal

Writing a proposal means moving from a vague worry to a focused problem, from scattered facts to organised evidence, and from a first draft to a recommendation that readers can act on.

Starting with the rhetorical situation

Most writers plan, draft, seek review and revise, looping back as their ideas sharpen. Planning starts with the rhetorical situation, the circumstances in which you address your readers. Consider your topic: is it set, or free, and does it need research? Your purpose: to examine a problem and explain options, or to recommend one solution? Your audience: the instructor, classmates, campus administrators, local residents, plus any secondary readers? Your presentation: a written paper, or slides and a talk for decision-makers? Your context: what current events touch the problem? And culture and community: what assumptions do you and your readers bring?

Choosing a problem

A typical assignment sets three conditions. The problem must be current, even if it is long-standing. It must affect many people, not only you. And research must be able to show real solutions, not ones you merely imagine. Instructors often require several credible sources, such as reputable newspapers and journals, government reports and well-established websites; persuasive pieces make weak evidence. To find a problem, follow a quality news source for a week and notice what people argue about, or start from your own life: rent, debt, transport.

Exploring a problem

Brainstorm with a set of exploring questions and write a quick answer to each. What problem do I want to learn about? How do I know it is a problem? What are some examples? What causes it? Who is affected? What harm does it do? Why should it be solved? What will happen if nothing is done? What realistic solutions exist? Honest answers often reveal gaps, such as "I need to learn more about the costs", and those gaps become your research plan. They also test whether the problem is real: if you cannot name anyone affected, choose another.

Worked example: narrowing a topic

Broad topic: plastic waste. 1. Exploring shows the topic is real but enormous: oceans, packaging, recycling systems, laws. A short proposal on all of it would be general and thin. 2. Split it into narrower problems: plastic in local rivers; recycling contamination in student housing; single-use cups in campus cafés. 3. Ask focusing questions about the most promising: How many cups do the three campus cafés use each week? What happens to them? Have reusable-cup discounts worked elsewhere? Who sets café policy? 4. The cafés' manager can act, and data can be gathered on campus, so this problem is focused enough. 5. The proposal now has a clear audience and a measurable goal.

Gathering evidence

Proposals rest on evidence, so most require formal research: finding sources, judging their reliability, taking careful notes and citing every borrowed word and idea. Local problems may also need primary research, such as a survey or interviews. Record where every piece of information came from. Kinds of evidence include a definition of a key term; an example that illustrates a point; expert opinion from a respected professional; facts that can be verified; an interview; a quotation, the exact words of a source; statistics, facts in numbers; a survey, in which every respondent answers the same questions; and visuals such as graphs, tables and maps.

Drafting a thesis

The thesis is the main idea that every paragraph supports. In a proposal it usually takes one or two sentences near the end of the introduction, identifying the problem and previewing the solution or solutions. For example: "Single-use cups make up most of the waste from the campus's three cafés, a problem that a deposit scheme for reusable cups, backed by a price discount, could cut within a year." Test your draft thesis. Is it engaging, giving readers a reason to care? Is it precise, naming the place, the group affected and the kind of solution? Revise until the answer to both is yes.

Organising the proposal

Proposals have a recognisable shape. The introduction, usually one or two paragraphs, draws readers in with an overview, gives needed background and states the thesis. The problem section then establishes, with evidence, that it needs solving. The possible solutions follow, one at a time, often under headings; this is usually the longest section. Objections, the doubts readers may raise about your solutions, come next, with evidence-based replies; they can be brief if few readers would object. The conclusion and recommendation summarises the main points and recommends a specific course of action.

Point, evidence, analysis

Body paragraphs work well with a three-part pattern. The point is the paragraph's central idea, stated in your own words in a topic sentence near the start. The evidence develops that point with material drawn from sources, quoted, paraphrased or summarised, and it synthesises that material by showing how the sources connect rather than listing them one by one. The analysis comes at the end: in your own words, explain what the evidence shows and how it supports the point. Without analysis, a paragraph is a pile of facts; without evidence, it is only an opinion.

Worked example: a solution paragraph

Model paragraph, with hypothetical figures: "A deposit scheme would give students a simple reason to reuse cups. Under such a scheme, customers pay a small deposit for a durable cup and get it back when they return it. In a survey of 212 students that I ran in March, 68 percent said they would use a reusable cup if they saved money each time. Café staff I interviewed added that returned cups could be washed in the dishwashers they already own. Together, these findings suggest the scheme would be both popular and practical." Analysis: 1. The first sentence is the point. 2. A definition, a statistic and an interview supply evidence. 3. The last sentence analyses, linking both sources back to the point.

Abstract, citations, review and revision

An abstract or executive summary opens a formal proposal, but write it last, once your main points are settled; include those points, not the evidence. Cite every source in the text and list it in full at the end, in the required style, including your own surveys and interviews. Then seek review from classmates, a writing-centre tutor or a trusted friend, giving them questions: Can you find the thesis? Does each paragraph have a point, evidence and analysis? Where did you get lost? To revise on your own, read aloud, number your paragraphs and note each one's focus to check the organisation, test each piece of evidence, save each version as a new file, and be willing to cut.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, picking a problem too broad to treat in depth. Second, proposing a solution you invented without checking whether it is realistic or has been tried. Third, writing evidence-only paragraphs with no analysis, or analysis-only paragraphs with no evidence. Fourth, listing sources one after another instead of synthesising them. Fifth, writing the abstract first and then drafting a proposal that no longer matches it. Sixth, ignoring the obvious objection a decision-maker will raise, usually cost.

Key takeaways

Plan by analysing the rhetorical situation: topic, purpose, audience, presentation, context and culture. Choose a current problem that affects many people and has real solutions, explore it with questions, and narrow it until it can be treated in depth. Gather varied, credible evidence and record its sources. State the problem and preview the solution in a thesis near the end of the introduction. Organise into problem, solutions, objections and recommendation, build paragraphs from point, evidence and analysis, and write the abstract last.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Rhetorical situation

Topic, purpose, audience, presentation, context, culture and community

Analyse it before drafting.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which piece of evidence is a statistic?

Question 2 of 5

Which is the strongest thesis for a proposal?

Question 3 of 5

In the point-evidence-analysis pattern, what belongs at the end of a body paragraph?

Question 4 of 5

When is it best to write a proposal's abstract or executive summary?

Question 5 of 5

Which topic is focused enough for a short proposal?

← Previous topicNext topic →