English Composition › Section F · The proposal › Topic F.1
Proposals and professional writing
A proposal persuades readers that a problem is real and that a particular solution will work. The same skills, clear purpose, reliable facts and an objective voice, run through most writing at work.
What a proposal is
You already know everyday proposals: an electrician quotes for rewiring a kitchen, a caterer offers a menu and a price. In those, the problem is simple and often unstated, since the client already knows what they need. The proposal you write in a composition course tackles a problem whose solution is not obvious, such as food waste in a campus cafeteria. It must first show readers that the problem is real and worth solving, then present one or more solutions with evidence that they are workable, and finally recommend a course of action. Because such problems are complex, honest proposals often weigh several solutions before choosing.
Proposals at work
Professional writing serves busy readers who must act: approve, fund, decide or reply. It is concise, organised so key points can be found quickly, and accurate, because errors cost money, time and credibility. Its everyday forms share these habits: an email puts its purpose in a specific subject line and its opening lines, and technical instructions give one action per numbered step, with any warning before the step it concerns. Proposals are among its most important forms. A business proposal offers a client deliverables, a schedule, costs and payment terms. A grant proposal asks a funder to pay for a project, explaining the problem, method, timeline, budget and benefits. A solicited proposal answers a request, such as a call for bids; an unsolicited one is sent on the writer's own initiative and must work harder to prove the problem exists.
A problem-solving mindset
Before researching, question the problem and the solutions. About the problem: What causes it? What are its effects? What makes it a problem rather than an inconvenience, and for whom? About solutions: What has been tried before? Why did those attempts succeed or fail? Who has the power to put a solution into action? Rough written answers show what you still need to learn. Suppose your campus shuttle is always late. The questions turn a complaint into an inquiry: is the cause traffic, too few drivers or a poor timetable, and who controls each?
Fact and opinion
A proposal needs both. Facts are statements that can be checked against evidence, such as records, measurements or data. Facts expressed in numbers are statistics. Opinions are statements of belief or value; they cannot be proved true, but they can be well or badly supported. Proposal writers use facts to show that the problem exists and that a solution can work, and they offer evidence-based opinions when they recommend action. Fact: "The library closed at 9 p.m. on every night of last term's exam fortnight." Opinion: "The library should stay open until midnight during exams." A good proposal makes clear which statements are which.
Bias in sources
Bias is a preconceived opinion about a subject, idea, person or group. Some writing is openly persuasive, such as editorials and opinion columns, or op-eds, named for their traditional place opposite the editorial page. These rarely make good evidence for a proposal; look instead for informative sources that consider several sides. Even neutral-looking sources can tilt. To check, ask whether a source aims to inform or persuade, separate its facts from its opinions, notice loaded words and what the headings emphasise, research the author, compare several sources for omissions, and look at how images frame the subject.
Bias in yourself
Writers are not neutral either. Cognitive bias is the name psychologists give to patterns in human thinking that shape how we take in new information. The one that most threatens a proposal writer is confirmation bias: the tendency to seek and accept information that supports what you already believe and to dismiss what challenges it. If you are sure a shortage of grants causes students to drop out, you may skim past evidence that tutoring matters more. The defence is deliberate: admit you have beliefs, search for evidence against them, and let the strongest evidence, not your first hunch, choose the solution.
Purpose and audience
Your purpose is to recommend how a problem should be solved. Topics can be local, such as quiet study rooms, or large-scale, such as broadband access nationwide. Your audience is whoever will or could read the proposal, and they expect certain things. Define a specific problem and show why it matters. Judge what they already know, adding background for newcomers and moving quickly for experts. Give reliable facts, statistics and examples. Structure the proposal logically. Adopt an objective stance, free of emotional language, which builds ethos, your credibility. And tell them exactly what you want them to do.
Key features of the genre
A formal proposal may open with an abstract or executive summary, a brief overview giving the problem and recommended solution. The introduction presents the problem and usually ends with the thesis. The body discusses the problem, then the solution or solutions, and often objections, also called counterclaims, that readers might raise. The conclusion and recommendation restates the problem, recommends a solution and often issues a call to action. Throughout, evidence, meaning facts, statistics, examples and expert opinion, is cited in the text and listed in full at the end. Each paragraph has a topic sentence relating to the thesis.
Worked example: reading a source critically
Model source passage, from an imagined campus blog: "Our library's shameful 9 p.m. closing is driving students to despair. Last term, 340 students signed a petition for longer hours. Any administrator who cares about learning would act tonight." 1. Purpose: persuasion, not information. 2. Loaded language: shameful and despair aim to stir emotion. 3. Fact: the petition and its 340 signatures can be checked. 4. Opinion: the claim about caring administrators is a judgement presented as obvious. 5. Use: cite the petition figure after verifying it, but find neutral evidence, such as library usage data, for the problem itself.
Worked example: one problem, two audiences
Problem: the library closes too early during exams. 1. Audience A, fellow students: they know the problem first-hand, so background can be brief. They cannot change the hours, so the action is to sign a petition and attend a student council meeting. 2. Audience B, library administrators: they know the budget and staffing better than students, so the proposal must give usage figures and costs. The action is a specific change: open until midnight for the two exam weeks, staffed by trained student workers. 3. Both versions keep an objective stance, but each asks for the action its readers can actually take.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, presenting an opinion as if it were a fact, or the reverse. Second, relying on op-eds and other persuasive pieces as evidence. Third, collecting only the sources that agree with you, which is confirmation bias at work. Fourth, using emotional language that undermines an objective stance and your ethos. Fifth, ending without a clear request, so readers who agree still do nothing. Sixth, choosing a problem so broad, such as "climate change", that a short proposal can only skim it.
Key takeaways
A proposal shows that a problem is real, presents workable solutions with evidence, and recommends action. At work, business and grant proposals add deliverables, schedules and budgets, and may be solicited or unsolicited. Question causes, effects, past solutions and who can act. Use facts to establish the problem and evidence-based opinions to recommend. Guard against bias in sources and in yourself, especially confirmation bias. Meet readers' expectations with a defined problem, reliable evidence, logical structure, an objective stance and a clear call to action.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Writing that shows a problem is real and recommends a workable solution
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement is an opinion rather than a fact?
Question 2 of 5
What is confirmation bias?
Question 3 of 5
Which source would make the strongest evidence that a city's bus delays are a real problem?
Question 4 of 5
A student writes a proposal on late-night library hours for library administrators. What should it ask them to do?
Question 5 of 5
Which of these is an unsolicited proposal?
