English Composition › Section M · The research process › Topic M.2

Creating sources: interviews, surveys, observation

Some research questions cannot be answered from a library shelf. When nobody has yet studied your campus, your town or your question, you create the evidence yourself through fieldwork, and the quality of that evidence depends on how carefully you design it.

When to create your own sources

Published sources rarely answer local or very recent questions. No database will tell you how many students use the new bike racks, or what a town's market traders think of a proposed car park. Fieldwork, the collection of data in the setting where it occurs, fills that gap. As the earlier lesson on types of evidence explained, data you gather yourself is a primary source. The three methods most useful in a writing course are interviews, surveys and observation, and many projects combine two or three of them.

Planning fieldwork

Field information is not catalogued for you, so it takes planning. Start from your research question: which field evidence would strengthen your argument? Choose contacts, sites and methods. Schedule early and build in slack, because interviews get postponed. Do background reading first, so your questions are sharper. Check with your instructor before surveying or observing people, since some projects need approval, as the lesson on ethical research explains. Finally, record every visit, call, question and answer in a research log from the first day, including attempts that led nowhere.

Choosing interviewees and writing a script

Profile research introduced interview requests and open questions; a research interview needs more planning. Decide what you need to learn, why, and which people know it. Most projects benefit from several perspectives: a question about a closing swimming pool might call for a council officer, a lifeguard, a swimming-club parent and a local business owner. Learn what each person has already said publicly. Then write a working script, general questions first and specific ones later. Mix open questions, which invite explanation ("What changed after the budget cut?"), with closed questions, which collect details ("When did the pool reduce its hours?").

During and after the interview

A script is a starting point, not a cage. Ask follow-up questions when an answer is vague or surprising. If a question meets silence, wait: the person is often gathering their thoughts. Watch body language for signs of discomfort or fatigue. Take content notes, the main ideas plus any striking phrases worth quoting, and context notes on the setting and the person's manner. Record audio only with permission. Read important or controversial statements back to check them. Within 24 hours, write your notes out in full while memory is fresh. Phone, email and video interviews work too, and email gives written answers.

Worked example: an interview script

Model script for the pool's manager, Ms Adebayo (an invented interviewee): (1) "How long have you managed the pool, and what does the job involve?" (2) "How has attendance changed over the past five years?" (3) "What reasons did the council give for reducing the hours?" (4) "When exactly did the new hours begin?" (5) "What would it take to restore them?" Analysis: 1. Question 1 is easy and general, which settles the interviewee. 2. Questions 2, 3 and 5 are open and invite explanation. 3. Question 4 is closed and pins down a fact. 4. The order moves from background to the central issue to solutions. 5. None suggests a desired answer.

Designing a survey

A survey asks every respondent the same questions and tabulates the answers, so it suits questions about many people. Respondents are treated as experts on their own behaviour and opinions. Keep surveys short, so more people finish. Mostly use closed questions with clear answer options, since these can be counted and compared; add an open question for insights. What, who and how-often questions tend to get quicker, more accurate answers than why questions. Word every question neutrally, ask one thing at a time, and make answer ranges complete and non-overlapping. For sensitive topics, use anonymous written surveys, and always check with your instructor first.

Worked example: repairing survey questions

Draft items from a student surveying classmates about the library, with revisions. (1) "Don't you agree the library closes too early?" Revised: "Which closing time would suit you best?" with four time options. (2) "How satisfied are you with the library's computers and staff?" Revised as two separate questions, one about computers and one about staff. (3) "Do you visit the library often?" Revised: "How many times did you visit the library last week? 0, 1-2, 3-4, 5 or more." Analysis: 1. Item 1 led respondents to an answer. 2. Item 2 was double-barrelled, asking two things at once. 3. Item 3 used a vague word, so answers could not be compared. 4. The revised ranges do not overlap.

Observation

Observation means taking notes while watching events, places, people or animals, in a single visit or across several. One visit gives only a partial view, so think about whether time of day or day of the week matters. Decide beforehand what role you will take. A participant observer takes part in the activity, such as a member watching her own choir rehearse; she understands it from inside but may get absorbed and forget to take notes. A nonparticipant observer stays apart and tries not to influence what happens. Either way, take precise notes on size, colour, arrangement, timing and anything unusual, and rewrite them soon after each visit.

Worked example: observations and speculations

A student studies queues at the campus printers. Observation column: "Tuesday, 9:50 a.m. Eleven students waiting; two of four printers show 'out of paper'. One student leaves after four minutes without printing." Questions and speculations column: "Are printers restocked before the 10 a.m. classes? Do queues form mainly before lectures? The student who left may have had a class." Analysis: 1. The first column describes only what was seen, with times and counts. 2. The second column interprets and asks questions. 3. Separating them stops guesses from passing as facts. 4. The questions suggest the next steps: visits at other times and a short interview with library staff.

Using field data responsibly

Represent people fairly: quote them exactly, keep remarks in context and watch for your own biases. Thank them afterwards, for example with a short email. Be honest about your data's limits. Twenty survey responses from one class show what that group reported, not what every student thinks, and one observation shows one moment. Sharing your observations with a peer is a useful check, since different observers often interpret the same scene differently. Cite field sources like any other: in MLA an interview is listed in your works cited (APA cites it in the text only, as a personal communication), and survey or observation data is described in your paper.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, skipping background research, which produces vague questions. Second, writing a script of closed questions only, which yields facts but no insight. Third, sticking rigidly to the script and missing a follow-up. Fourth, recording without permission. Fifth, waiting days to write up notes. Sixth, writing leading, double-barrelled or vague survey questions. Seventh, mixing interpretation into observation notes. Eighth, treating a small, unrepresentative survey as proof about everyone.

Key takeaways

Fieldwork creates primary evidence when published sources cannot answer your question. Plan it: choose methods, contacts and sites, schedule with slack, read first and log everything. Interview several people, scripting general questions before specific ones and mixing open and closed questions; follow up, take content and context notes, and write them out within 24 hours. Keep surveys short, neutral and countable, one question at a time. Observe as a participant or nonparticipant, separating observations from speculations. Represent people fairly and state your data's limits.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Fieldwork

Collecting data in the setting where it occurs

A form of primary research.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which interview question is a closed question?

Question 2 of 5

What is the main problem with the survey item "How satisfied are you with the cafeteria's prices and opening hours?"

Question 3 of 5

A student observes rehearsals of the drama club she belongs to, sometimes helping with props. What role is she taking?

Question 4 of 5

What should a researcher do soon after an interview?

Question 5 of 5

Which note belongs in the observation column rather than the speculation column?

← Previous topicNext topic →