English Composition › Section M · The research process › Topic M.1
Where to look: starting research
Finding information is rarely the hard part of research; finding the right information is. A clear plan, well-chosen search terms and a sense of where each kind of source lives turn hours of scrolling into a short list of sources worth reading.
Start with a plan, not a pile
Once you have a focused, open-ended research question, the topic of the earlier lesson on balancing sources and voice, you are ready to collect sources. The key word at this stage is intentionality. A student who saves everything that mentions the topic soon has dozens of tabs and no idea which ones matter. A student with a plan knows what she is looking for and where it is likely to be. Searching is less about access than about sorting, selecting and judging. Keep a record of every search as you go, including the ones that found nothing, so you never repeat a dead end.
A needs assessment
Before searching, ask what you and your readers need. You, as writer, need two kinds of material. Basic facts and data inform you about the topic and show its scope. Contextual or conceptual sources explain background, history or theory, and help you answer the question "So what?" Your readers need three things: a reason to invest in the topic, intellectually or emotionally; proof that it matters, in the form of convincing arguments or telling examples; and clear explanations of anything complex or technical. Listing these needs turns a vague hunt into a set of specific targets, much like analysing the rhetorical situation before you write.
Generating keywords
Search tools match words, so the words you type decide what you find. Start by stating your topic as one or two questions. Underline the words that carry its meaning. Then add words the question assumes but never says: a question about homework and sleep implies students, school and bedtime. Next, list synonyms, checking that each one really means what you intend: teenagers, adolescents, high school students. Try the terms in different combinations. Library catalogues often use fixed subject headings, such as the Library of Congress Subject Headings, which may differ from everyday words. When a good source appears, note the terms it uses and add them to your list.
Boolean operators and search tricks
Most databases accept Boolean operators, which combine search terms logically. AND narrows a search, because every result must contain all the terms. OR broadens it, because results may contain any of the terms, so it suits synonyms. NOT excludes a term, which removes an unwanted meaning: jaguar NOT car. Quotation marks search for an exact phrase, such as "screen time". In most library databases, an asterisk truncates a word, so adolesc* finds adolescent, adolescents and adolescence. Parentheses group synonyms so the logic stays clear: (teenagers OR adolescents) AND sleep. Many search engines, including Google, treat a space between words as AND.
Worked example: building a search string
Question: "How does the amount of homework affect how long high school students sleep?" 1. Key words: homework, sleep, high school students. 2. Implied words: school nights, bedtime. 3. Synonyms: homework or workload; teenagers or adolescents; sleep or "sleep duration". 4. Group synonyms with OR and join the ideas with AND: (homework OR workload) AND (sleep OR "sleep duration") AND (adolesc* OR teen*). 5. Test the string. Too many results? Add a term, or filter by date. Too few? Remove the narrowest idea or add synonyms. 6. Record the string and the number of results, so you can rerun or adjust it later.
Libraries and librarians
Much research now happens online, but the library, both building and website, remains central. It pays for databases, books, journals and media you could not otherwise reach. Visit early, because a book may be on loan, and browsing the shelf around one useful book often turns up others. Above all, talk to a librarian, a trained information specialist: show the assignment, explain your question and ask where to look. If your library lacks a source, interlibrary loan can usually borrow it from another library.
General reference works
General reference works give background and basic facts. Almanacs and yearbooks collect statistics and recent events; atlases add data on population and climate; biographical dictionaries profile notable people; dictionaries and encyclopedias explain terms and subjects. An hour with them shows a topic's scope and its key names and terms. As the earlier lesson on types of evidence explained, these are tertiary sources: too general to carry an argument, so they are rarely cited in a research paper. Wikipedia works the same way: use it for orientation and follow its references, then cite stronger sources directly.
Databases and search engines
Databases, usually reached through the library website, index articles. General-interest databases, such as Academic Search Complete, cover many subjects and suit early searching. Once your question is focused, move to subject databases: PubMed for medicine, APA PsycInfo for psychology, ERIC for education, JSTOR for many humanities journals. Filters for date, subject and peer review save time. Google finds formal and informal material, while Google Scholar focuses on scholarly work, much of it now open access. Its results can be vast, so add a discipline keyword, and use its "Cited by" link to find newer work that cites a strong article. If an article sits behind a paywall, note its details and check your library or interlibrary loan.
Government documents and archives
Two rich collections are often overlooked. Government documents include reports, statistics and pamphlets on most issues of public concern; in the United States, the Catalog of U.S. Government Publications indexes federal material, and state and city governments publish their own data. Archives and special collections hold donated papers, manuscripts, rare books, photographs, maps and local histories. These are mostly primary materials, so they let you analyse evidence directly rather than through someone else's reading of it. A librarian can tell you what your library holds and how to request access.
Worked example: a search plan
Question: "Has the four-day school week affected achievement in rural districts?" 1. Needs: basic data on which districts use it; context on why they adopted it; for readers, examples from real communities. 2. Background: an encyclopedia entry or a library research report, to learn the key terms. 3. Scholarly evidence: ERIC, with ("four-day school week" OR "four-day week") AND (achievement OR "test scores") AND rural. 4. Data: the state education department's published results. 5. Local examples: newspaper archives from a district that switched. 6. Check: each need now has a likely source, and each search goes into the log.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, searching before you know what you need. Second, typing a whole sentence into a database instead of keywords. Third, giving up after one search, when synonyms or subject headings would have worked. Fourth, using AND between synonyms, which shrinks results, when OR is needed. Fifth, citing an encyclopedia or Wikipedia instead of the sources they point to. Sixth, paying for an article your library can provide free. Seventh, failing to record searches, so you repeat them or lose a source.
Key takeaways
Begin with a plan: a focused question and a needs assessment covering your needs for facts and context and your readers' needs for investment, proof and explanation. Generate keywords from the question, implied words and synonyms, and combine them with AND, OR, NOT, quotation marks, truncation and parentheses. Use general reference works for background only. Search general databases first, then subject databases and Google Scholar. Remember government documents, archives, interlibrary loan and librarians, and log every search.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Searching with a plan rather than collecting everything
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which search would return the most results?
Question 2 of 5
A student has plenty of statistics, but her peer readers keep asking why the topic matters. In a needs assessment, what should she look for next?
Question 3 of 5
What is the best use of an encyclopedia in a research project?
Question 4 of 5
In most library databases, what does the search term educat* find?
Question 5 of 5
A Google Scholar search for climate change returns millions of results from every field. What is the most useful next step?
