English Composition › Section G · The evaluation or review › Topic G.3

Editing focus: using quotations

A well-chosen quotation lets readers hear the evidence for themselves. Choosing it, introducing it, trimming it and punctuating it correctly are what turn a borrowed sentence into support for your own point.

Why quote at all?

A direct quotation reproduces someone's exact words, and it gives readers concrete evidence rather than your report of it. In a review, a line of dialogue can prove a character is witty. Calling a candidate's debate answer evasive stays abstract until you quote the answer and readers can judge it. Quotations work only when they are chosen with care, introduced clearly, copied exactly and cited.

When a quotation beats a paraphrase

Quote when the exact words matter, for one of four reasons. 1. Authority: the speaker's expertise or position makes the words themselves credible evidence, as with a public health official's statement on vaccination. 2. Style: the wording is so distinctive, funny or vivid that a paraphrase would lose it. 3. Precision: the exact phrasing carries information, such as a definition, a legal clause or a carefully worded statistic. 4. Voice: you want readers to hear the person you are writing about. If none of these applies, paraphrase or summarise instead, and cite the source just the same.

Support, don't substitute

A quotation should back up a point you have already made in your own words, not make the point for you. Sprinkling random quotations through an essay to make it look well researched only shows readers that quotations are doing the thinking. A reliable pattern is to frame each quotation on both sides. Before it, state your point and introduce the speaker. After it, explain what the quotation shows and how it supports your claim. Ending a paragraph on a bare quotation leaves readers guessing.

Signal phrases and their punctuation

A signal phrase, such as "Okafor argues" or "as one critic puts it", introduces a quotation and names its source. MLA style usually puts signal verbs in the present tense, and the verb carries meaning: "admits" and "demonstrates" suggest different attitudes. Punctuation depends on the grammar. After a verb of saying, use a comma: Okafor writes, "Planners had predicted modest use." When the quotation becomes part of your own sentence, often after that, use no comma: Okafor finds that the library "became the busiest public building in the region." After a complete sentence, use a colon to introduce the quotation.

Interrupted quotations and end punctuation

A signal phrase can sit in the middle of a quotation. Put quotation marks around each quoted part and commas around the signal phrase: "Most of its visitors," Okafor writes, "were teenagers." In American usage, which MLA follows, commas and periods go inside closing quotation marks, while colons and semicolons go outside. A question mark or exclamation point goes inside only if it belongs to the quoted words. When a parenthetical citation follows a quotation, the sentence's period moves after the parenthesis. A quotation inside a quotation takes single quotation marks: "She called it 'a lifeline,'" he said.

Citations and long quotations

In MLA style, a quotation is followed by a parenthetical citation giving the author's surname and the page number, with no comma and no "p.": (Okafor 47). If the signal phrase already names the author, give only the page: (47). A source without page numbers, such as a typical web page, needs only the author. A prose quotation that would run to more than four lines in your essay becomes a block quotation: start it on a new line, indent the whole passage half an inch from the left margin, and drop the quotation marks. In a block quotation, the citation comes after the final punctuation mark.

Ellipses: showing what you left out

An ellipsis, three spaced periods (. . .), marks words you have omitted from a quotation. MLA 9 rules: 1. Put a space before, between and after the periods. 2. Normally, do not put square brackets around your ellipsis. 3. If the omission includes the end of a sentence, or whole sentences, put the sentence's period first and then the ellipsis, giving four periods. 4. You rarely need one at the start of a quotation, or after a short phrase woven into your sentence, because readers can see it is a part. 5. Never omit words in a way that changes the original meaning.

Brackets: making a quotation fit

Square brackets mark words you have added to or changed in a quotation, usually so that it makes sense out of context or fits your grammar. The most common use replaces a vague pronoun: "it had become" might become "[the library] had become". You can also add a brief clarification, such as a date. To show that an error belongs to the original, not to you, write sic in square brackets immediately after it. Like an ellipsis, a bracket must never alter what the source meant.

Worked example: trimming and clarifying

Invented source, Dana Okafor, page 47: "The library, which cost far less than the new stadium, became the busiest public building in the region within a year. Planners had predicted modest use. Most of its visitors were teenagers looking for a quiet place to study after school." Version A: "The library . . . became the busiest public building in the region within a year" (Okafor 47). Version B: Okafor reports that the library "became the busiest public building in the region within a year. . . . Most of [the library's] visitors were teenagers . . ." (47). 1. In A, three spaced periods replace a clause; the meaning is unchanged. 2. In B, the period after "year" ends that sentence, and the ellipsis marks the dropped middle sentence. 3. Brackets replace the unclear "its". 4. The last sentence is cut short, so spaced periods follow "teenagers", then the citation, then the period.

Worked example: a model paragraph

"Public libraries have not been made obsolete by smartphones; in some places they are busier than ever. In her study of one county, Dana Okafor reports that its new library 'became the busiest public building in the region within a year' (47). Planners, she notes, 'had predicted modest use' (47). The gap between prediction and reality suggests that people now value libraries less for books than for space." (Single marks appear here only because the whole model is quoted.) 1. The writer's point comes before any source. 2. Okafor is named in the signal phrase, so each citation gives only the page. 3. Both quotations blend into the writer's grammar, so no introductory comma is needed. 4. The last sentence interprets the evidence.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, a "dropped" quotation that stands alone as a sentence with no signal phrase. Second, a period before the parenthetical citation, as in "were teenagers." (47), instead of after it. Third, a comma between author and page, or "p." inside an MLA citation. Fourth, cutting words without an ellipsis, or cutting them so that the meaning changes. Fifth, putting an ordinary MLA ellipsis inside square brackets. Sixth, misquoting from memory: check every word, spelling and punctuation mark against the source.

Key takeaways

Quote when authority, style, precision or voice makes the exact words matter; otherwise paraphrase. Make your point first, introduce the quotation with a signal phrase, and explain it afterwards. Use a comma after a verb of saying, none when the quotation blends in, and a colon after a complete sentence. Commas and periods go inside quotation marks, but a citation comes before the period. Ellipses (. . .) mark omissions and brackets mark changes; neither may alter the meaning. Long prose quotations of more than four lines become indented block quotations.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Direct quotation

Someone's exact words, in quotation marks

Evidence readers can judge for themselves.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which sentence is punctuated correctly in MLA style?

Question 2 of 5

The original reads: "The bridge, which opened in 1932, still carries 40,000 cars a day." Which version correctly omits the clause in MLA 9?

Question 3 of 5

In a quotation, what do square brackets tell the reader?

Question 4 of 5

In MLA style, when should a prose quotation be set as an indented block quotation?

Question 5 of 5

Which is the best reason to quote a source directly rather than paraphrase it?

← Previous topicNext topic →