English Composition › Section G · The evaluation or review › Topic G.2
Writing a review
A strong review is built before it is written: you choose criteria, study the work closely, and turn your verdict into a thesis that the evidence can carry from the introduction to the recommendation.
The assignment: a review that matters
A typical college review assignment asks for more than a verdict. You choose one film, book, series, podcast, play or game and argue that it does something significant for its genre: it fulfils the genre's expectations unusually well, or breaks them in a revealing way. You support an overall judgement with evidence from the work itself and, where useful, from secondary sources, and you show awareness of its cultural and historical context. The same process works for a spoken review such as a podcast, which invites a more conversational voice.
Invention: genre traits and evidence
Start by brainstorming in a two-column table. On the left, name the genre and list as many of its typical characteristics as you can: for horror, a threat, victims, an unsettling setting, sound design, suspense. On the right, list examples from your chosen work for each characteristic. Then make a second table for the subgenre, such as a ghost story within horror. List what is distinctive about that subgenre, and beside each item write a question you can use to judge it: "Is the threat frightening before it is ever seen?" These questions become your working criteria.
Choosing and testing criteria
From your tables, choose three to five characteristics that have the most evidence and that matter most to your audience. Then study the work closely with those criteria in mind. Watch, read, play or listen more than once, concentrating on one or two criteria each time. When you meet a strong example, write a vivid, precise description of it and copy any dialogue exactly, noting where it occurs, such as a page number or the episode and time stamp. Notice what draws you in; those reactions often point towards your thesis.
Planning the thesis
A planning grid helps you move from notes to an argument. Name the primary source. Decide your angle of analysis: the aspect you will focus on, such as how the game handles fear. Add filters that narrow the focus: a time period, a cultural context, or a comparison with similar works. Write the main argument, which must be debatable: a reasonable person could disagree. Finally, compress it into a thesis of one or two sentences that states your judgement and the reason for it. A plot summary is not a thesis.
Worked example: from angle to thesis
Primary source: an invented horror game, Hollow Pines. Angle: how it creates fear. Filter: compared with horror games that rely on combat. Thesis: "Hollow Pines strips away every weapon, and the result is more frightening than any monster fight: helplessness, not gore, drives its horror." Main points, previewed with because: because the player can only hide or run; because sound reveals danger before sight does; because the few glimpses of the creature are brief. 1. The thesis judges the game and gives a reason. 2. It is debatable, since some players want combat. 3. Each because-clause becomes a topic sentence. 4. The comparison filter shows what the game adds to its genre.
Summary, evaluation and secondary sources
A review mixes two kinds of sentence. Summary and observation are objective: they report what happens or what is there. Evaluation and analysis are subjective: they judge quality and explain why. Use summary only as far as readers need it to follow your judgement. Once your own view is formed, secondary sources can support it or supply context. Scholarly, peer-reviewed articles carry the most weight; college library databases such as JSTOR and the MLA International Bibliography index many on film, media and culture. Recaps, summaries of single TV episodes with commentary, are less formal but show how fans are discussing a show.
Drafting the introduction and body
The introduction should make readers want to continue: think of it as a short pitch. Open with a striking moment, a question, or a reason the subject will feel relevant. By the end, readers must know what you are reviewing: the title, when it appeared, its medium and genre, and where to find it. Give your overall evaluation and end with the thesis. In the body, each paragraph opens with a main point as its topic sentence, links it to your criteria, and backs it with concrete evidence: description, quotation and, where needed, secondary sources.
Worked example: a model introduction
"Most horror games hand you a weapon within the first five minutes. Hollow Pines, an invented survival game for consoles, never does. You play a park ranger alone in a forest at night, armed only with a torch, and can only hide or run. The design sounds limiting, yet the game grips from its opening walk to its final chase. Hollow Pines strips away every weapon, and the result is more frightening than any monster fight: helplessness, not gore, drives its horror." 1. The first sentence states a genre expectation, and the second breaks it. 2. Title, medium and genre arrive early. 3. A brief summary gives only what the thesis needs. 4. The overall evaluation precedes the thesis, which ends the paragraph.
The conclusion and peer review
The conclusion briefly shows how your criteria led to your judgement, restates or confirms the thesis in fresh words, and makes a recommendation: who should play, watch or read this, and why. Then seek a peer's response, marking where you want help. As a reviewer, read the draft once without commenting, then again with notes. Check that the introduction engages and identifies the subject, that a thesis judges and gives a reason, that each body paragraph has a clear point and concrete evidence, and that the conclusion ties the points together. Note patterns of error rather than every slip, and end with three priorities for revision.
Revising with ownership
Useful comments say what is working or not, why, and what the writer could do; praise is useful too when it explains what succeeds. When your draft comes back, remember that comments are suggestions and the revision decisions are yours. A sentence fragment, for instance, is technically incorrect but can be an effective, deliberate way to stress a point; you decide whether it suits your audience and purpose. Still, a peer may have spotted something you missed. Before submitting, check for a specific subject, an engaging opening, a debatable thesis, well-supported body paragraphs and correct citations.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, retelling the plot for most of the essay, leaving little room for evaluation. Second, a thesis that only describes ("This game is about a ranger in a forest") or only rates ("This game is great"). Third, criteria chosen at random rather than from the genre and the audience's expectations. Fourth, quoting from memory instead of copying dialogue exactly during close study. Fifth, a conclusion that introduces a new point instead of recommending.
Key takeaways
Build criteria from the genre and subgenre, then choose the three to five with the strongest evidence. Study the work repeatedly and take exact notes. Plan the thesis through an angle, filters and a debatable main argument, and preview main points with because. Use summary only as needed. The introduction identifies the work and ends with the thesis; body paragraphs pair main points with evidence; the conclusion links criteria to verdict and recommends. Give specific peer feedback, and revise as the owner of your writing.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Genre traits listed beside examples from the work
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which is the strongest thesis for a review of a cooking competition show?
Question 2 of 5
According to the drafting advice for a review, where should the thesis usually appear in the introduction?
Question 3 of 5
What is the recommended first step when you read a classmate's draft review for peer feedback?
Question 4 of 5
Which set of tasks belongs in the conclusion of a review?
Question 5 of 5
A peer marks a deliberate one-word fragment in your review as an error. What is the best response?
