English Composition › Section M · The research process › Topic M.5
Ethical research and academic integrity
Research rests on trust: participants trust you with their words and privacy, and readers trust that every borrowed idea is credited and every fact is real. Ethical research protects both kinds of trust, and most lapses are avoidable with careful habits.
Two kinds of responsibility
Research ethics covers two relationships. The first is with the people you interview, survey or observe: you owe them respect for their privacy, honesty about what you are doing and, where needed, anonymity. The second is with the people whose work you use. Every idea, phrase, statistic or image you borrow must be credited to its source. Failing to do that is plagiarism. Both responsibilities come from the same principle: treating others' contributions, whether their time, their words or their ideas, as theirs rather than yours.
Human participants and review boards
Universities in the United States maintain institutional review boards (IRBs) to meet federal regulations and ethical principles for research with human participants. An IRB asks questions such as these. Is participation voluntary? Are participants chosen fairly? Will confidentiality be kept? Are there risks to participants? Will the study produce worthwhile results? Most student fieldwork, such as a short survey or an interview, carries little risk, and many class projects are handled by the instructor rather than a full board. But surveys on sensitive matters, or research you hope to publish, may need approval, so always ask your instructor before you begin. Ask participants' permission to use their names, and use a pseudonym when someone prefers not to be identified.
What academic integrity means
Academic integrity means doing your own work, crediting others honestly and representing your work truthfully. Degrees and research findings are only worth something if people can trust them. Violations include plagiarism; cheating; fabrication, inventing data or sources; falsification, altering real data; unauthorised collaboration, getting more help than the course allows; and submitting the same work for two assignments without permission, often called self-plagiarism. Policies differ between institutions and courses, especially on collaboration and AI tools, so read the syllabus and ask when you are unsure.
Deliberate and careless plagiarism
Some plagiarism is deliberate: submitting a friend's paper, buying or downloading an essay, or pasting in someone else's passage without credit. Much of it, though, comes from carelessness during note-taking or drafting. Three common slips: a passage is pasted into a draft without quotation marks or attribution; an author's idea is summarised with no name or source; or the author is credited in a signal phrase, but their exact words appear without quotation marks. Each may be unintentional, and each is still plagiarism. Patchwriting, covered in the earlier lesson on quoting and paraphrasing, is another form.
What plagiarism is not
You do not need to cite common knowledge: facts an educated reader would be expected to know, which appear in many general sources without attribution, such as the dates of major historical events, the locations of states and cities, and the general laws of science. Nor do you cite phrases in everyday use, or the standard vocabulary of your field: a biology paper need not cite a source for saying that cells contain DNA. Common knowledge depends on the audience, so what is obvious to economists may not be to general readers. Specific statistics, interpretations and recent findings almost always need citations. When in doubt, cite.
Worked example: diagnosing three passages
Invented source, offered as an example (Dr Lowe, page 22): "Night-time light pollution confuses migrating birds, drawing them towards cities." (1) "Artificial light at night confuses migrating birds, drawing them towards cities." (2) According to Dr Lowe, night-time light pollution confuses migrating birds, drawing them towards cities (22). (3) Dr Lowe warns that bright cities can lure migrating birds off course (22). Analysis: 1. Passage 1 is plagiarism: nearly the source's exact words, with no credit. 2. Passage 2 credits Lowe but copies her words without quotation marks, so it is still plagiarism. 3. Passage 3 restates the idea in new words and structure and cites the page: acceptable. 4. Passage 2 could be fixed with quotation marks.
Generative AI and integrity
Course policies on generative AI vary widely: some ban it, some allow it for brainstorming or editing, and some build it into assignments. Find out the policy for each course. Where use is allowed, be transparent about it, following any disclosure your instructor requires, and remember that you remain responsible for every claim. AI tools can produce confident, false statements and invent sources that do not exist, sometimes called hallucinations. Never cite a source you have not found and checked yourself. MLA and APA have both published guidance on citing AI-generated content; use your course's style.
Detection and consequences
Many institutions use similarity software, such as Turnitin, which compares a paper with web pages, publications and earlier submissions. Its report shows matching text, but an instructor must interpret it, because correctly quoted and cited material also shows up as a match. Tools that claim to detect AI writing are much less reliable and can wrongly flag a student's own work. Penalties for plagiarism range from redoing an assignment or failing it to failing the course, suspension or expulsion for serious or repeated cases. Outside school, plagiarism and fabricated data have cost journalists, politicians and scientists their reputations and positions.
Worked example: a note-taking slip
A student's research log contains this note, copied from a website with no quotation marks or source: "Green roofs can cut a building's summer cooling costs significantly." Three weeks later she uses it in her paper, believing it is her own summary. Repaired note: "Green roofs can cut a building's summer cooling costs significantly" [quotation; Hartley, "Roofs That Breathe", invented example web page, accessed 2 Feb.]. Analysis: 1. The original slip is unintentional plagiarism, because the words and the idea are someone else's. 2. Quotation marks show the words are borrowed. 3. The label and source record who said it and where. 4. With that record, she can quote or paraphrase correctly and cite it.
Habits that prevent plagiarism
Put quotation marks around every borrowed phrase in your notes and in your paper, and give in-text citations with a full list of sources. Cite paraphrases and summaries too, and represent the author's meaning faithfully even in your own words. For every note, record who said what, where and when. Never trim or alter a quotation so that it distorts the author's point. Keep your own analysis at the centre, so borrowed material supports it rather than taking over. And plan your time: rushed, last-minute writing is where careless attribution and the temptation to cheat both grow. If you are overwhelmed, asking for help or an extension is far better than cheating.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, believing that a citation alone excuses copied words without quotation marks. Second, assuming unintentional plagiarism does not count. Third, treating a specific statistic as common knowledge. Fourth, starting a survey of people without checking whether approval is needed. Fifth, naming an interviewee who asked to stay anonymous. Sixth, citing a source an AI tool suggested without confirming that it exists. Seventh, reusing an old essay for a new course without permission.
Key takeaways
Ethical research respects both participants and other people's work. IRBs check that participation is voluntary, selection is fair, confidentiality is kept, risks are low and results are worthwhile; ask your instructor before surveying or interviewing. Academic integrity forbids plagiarism, cheating, fabrication, falsification, unauthorised collaboration and unpermitted reuse of your own work. Careless plagiarism is still plagiarism. Common knowledge needs no citation; when in doubt, cite. Follow course AI policies, verify every source, and build habits and schedules that keep attribution accurate.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Fair treatment of participants and credit for others' work
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A student writes "According to Dr Lowe," and then copies Lowe's sentence word for word without quotation marks, adding the page number. What is the problem?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement in a paper for general readers would normally need no citation?
Question 3 of 5
Which question would an institutional review board ask about a planned student survey?
Question 4 of 5
A student's paper cites an article that an AI chatbot recommended. The article does not exist. What should the student have done?
Question 5 of 5
A similarity report highlights a passage that a student quoted correctly and cited. What does this show?
