English Composition › Section M · The research process › Topic M.4
Note-making, synthesis, and the research log
A research paper is only as good as the notes behind it. Notes that record exactly where each idea came from, and what you think of it, protect you from accidental plagiarism and turn a pile of sources into material you can actually synthesise.
Why notes need a system
A research project brings in many kinds of text: articles and PDFs, images, audio and video, archival documents, and your own field notes. Without a system, a writer ends up with a strong quotation and no idea where it came from, or a sentence she can no longer tell apart from her own words. Good notes do three jobs. They let you find every source again, they keep borrowed words and ideas clearly marked, and they record your thinking while it is fresh. Two kinds of notes, bibliographic and informational, plus a research log, cover all three jobs.
Bibliographic notes
Bibliographic notes identify a source. Make one as soon as you find a useful source, before you take any notes from it. For MLA style, record the nine core elements, where they apply: author, title of source, title of container (the larger work holding it, such as a journal or website), other contributors, version, number, publisher, publication date and location (pages, a DOI or a URL). Prefer a DOI (digital object identifier), a permanent link that survives website changes, to a URL. For web pages without a date, also note the date you accessed them. Complete records now make the works-cited list a matter of sorting later.
Informational notes
Informational notes record what a source says. Keep one idea per note, headed with the author, a brief title and the page number, and label each note by type. Put a source's exact words in quotation marks and label them as a quotation; label restatements as paraphrase; and mark a summary as such, to remind you later that it leaves out detail. The earlier lesson on quoting, paraphrasing and summarising explained when to use each in your paper; in notes, the labels matter most, because they keep borrowed material visible. Finally, add your own comments, clearly marked, for example in square brackets beginning "Me:".
Worked example: one passage, three notes
Invented source, offered as an example (Okafor and Reyes, page 47): "Students threw away about a third of the vegetables served, and waste was highest when lunch periods were shorter than twenty minutes." Note A, quotation: "waste was highest when lunch periods were shorter than twenty minutes" (Okafor and Reyes 47). Note B, paraphrase: Short lunch breaks went with the most wasted food (Okafor and Reyes 47). Note C, comment: [Me: Is time the cause, or do short lunches fall at unpopular times? Check the methods.] Analysis: 1. Each note carries the author and page. 2. The quotation marks and labels show whose words are whose. 3. The comment is bracketed, so it can never be mistaken for the source.
The research log
A research log is a running record of what you find, what you wonder and what came of it. The common format has three columns. The first, information, holds the note from the source with its in-text citation. The second, connection to thesis, says how the note supports or challenges your thesis or a main point. The third, notes, cross-references and synthesis, holds your questions, ideas for visuals and links to other sources. Date each entry and give the full citation beneath it. Begin the log with a freewrite answering three questions, and return to them often: What have I found? What do I still need? Where am I likely to find it?
Worked example: a log entry
Date: 4 March. Information: About a third of served vegetables were thrown away, with most waste when lunch lasted under twenty minutes (Okafor and Reyes 47). Connection to thesis: Supports my claim that longer lunch periods would reduce waste. Notes and synthesis: Compare with Lindqvist, who blames menu choice; are both true? Possible chart. Citation, an invented example: Okafor, Amara, and Liam Reyes. "Plate Waste in Secondary School Cafeterias." Journal of School Nutrition Studies, vol. 8, no. 2, 2022, pp. 41-58, https://doi.org/10.5555/jsns.2022.041. Analysis: 1. The paraphrase keeps its citation. 2. The second column ties it to the thesis. 3. The cross-reference to Lindqvist begins a synthesis. 4. The citation is complete MLA 9; in a real list the journal title would be italic.
Adapting the log, and other tools
The three-column log is a starting point. You might colour-code entries by theme, add a column for questions or links between sources, or drop columns altogether. Keep field data, such as interview and observation notes, in a separate record or a clearly marked section. Digital tools help: reference managers such as Zotero, which is free, or EndNote store citations and PDFs and let you tag notes; your library may provide one. Whatever the tool, the aim is the same: one place where every source, note and idea can be found again.
From notes to a synthesis matrix
The earlier lesson on balancing sources and voice showed the difference between summary and synthesis. A synthesis matrix is a practical bridge from one to the other. Make a grid with one row per source and one column per theme or sub-question. Fill each cell with a brief note and its page number, or leave it empty if the source is silent. Then read down each column rather than across each row. Reading down a column shows where sources agree, where they disagree and where nobody has looked: the gaps. Those patterns, not the individual sources, become the topic sentences of your paragraphs.
Worked example: reading down a column
Column "causes of waste" in a matrix of three invented sources: Okafor and Reyes: short lunch periods (47). Lindqvist: unpopular menus (12). Baptiste: no data on causes; reports only amounts. Model synthesised sentence: "Researchers disagree about why so much food is wasted: Okafor and Reyes point to short lunch periods (47), while Lindqvist blames unpopular menus (12), yet neither tests the two causes together, so it remains unclear whether more time would help if the menu stayed the same." Analysis: 1. The sentence is organised by idea, not by source. 2. It states the disagreement. 3. The empty cell becomes a gap. 4. The final clause is the writer's own point.
Entering the conversation
The critic Kenneth Burke described research and argument as an endless conversation in a parlour. You arrive after the discussion has begun, so you listen until you understand the argument, then contribute, and others answer you. Eventually you leave, and the conversation carries on. The image explains why notes and synthesis matter: they are how you listen. It also shows how to frame a thesis, in relation to what others have said: "While most studies blame ___, the evidence suggests ___."
Common mistakes to avoid
First, taking notes before recording the source's details. Second, copying exact words without quotation marks, then later mistaking them for your own. Third, omitting page numbers. Fourth, putting several ideas in one note. Fifth, mixing your comments into source notes unmarked. Sixth, leaving the connection-to-thesis column empty, so notes never become argument. Seventh, reading a synthesis matrix row by row, which produces summaries rather than synthesis.
Key takeaways
Make a bibliographic note, with MLA's core elements and a DOI where available, before taking notes. Keep informational notes to one idea each, with author, page and a label, and mark your own comments clearly. A research log has three columns: information, connection to thesis, and notes, cross-references and synthesis. A synthesis matrix, read down its columns, reveals agreement, disagreement and gaps. Burke's parlour reminds you to listen before you join the conversation.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A record of a source's publication details
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why should a researcher make a bibliographic note before taking any notes from a source?
Question 2 of 5
In a three-column research log, where does "Supports my claim that longer lunches would reduce waste" belong?
Question 3 of 5
Why is it worth labelling a note as a summary?
Question 4 of 5
A student fills in a synthesis matrix. How should she read it to plan her paragraphs?
Question 5 of 5
What does Kenneth Burke's image of the parlour conversation suggest about research writing?
