English Composition › Section B · Language, identity, and culture › Topic B.2

How writing constructs identity

When you write about who you are, you do more than report it. You choose which moments, objects and words will stand for you, and those choices shape how readers, and you yourself, understand your identity and culture.

Writing builds identity

No piece of writing can hold a whole life, so every account of a self is a selection. When you decide to describe your grandmother's kitchen rather than your first job, or to use your family's word for a dish rather than a translation, you are constructing an identity on the page. Readers meet that version of you, not the full person. The process often changes the writer too: putting an experience into words forces you to decide what it meant, so many writers find they understand an experience only after explaining it to someone else.

Competing identities

Many people move between cultures that expect different things: home and school, a heritage language and English, a small town and a big campus. In The Souls of Black Folk (1903), W. E. B. Du Bois named one form of this experience double consciousness: the feeling of constantly measuring yourself through other people's eyes. He was describing Black Americans' experience of seeing themselves both as they were and as a racist society saw them. Writing about moments when your language or culture clashed with, or was supported by, another setting is a powerful way to explore identity.

The cultural artifact essay

A common assignment asks you to choose an artifact that symbolises something about a culture you belong to, and to write a short piece, often a few hundred words, describing it and explaining what it means to you and within your culture. The artifact can be a physical object, such as a religious symbol, a piece of traditional clothing or a family recipe card. It can also be metaphorical, like Du Bois's image of a veil, or linguistic: a saying, a greeting or a way of talking. The best choices are small and concrete but point to something larger.

Finding material: journaling

Journaling, keeping a written record of your thoughts, helps you discover what you want to say. Start with a freewrite: set a timer for ten minutes and write about your artifact without stopping or correcting. A character sketch describes a person linked to the artifact: their appearance, habits, way of speaking, history and tie to the object, often opening with an anecdote. A captured moment uses the artifact to recall one specific event, reliving what you saw, heard and felt, then asking what it has meant to you since.

Planning the piece

Before drafting, answer a few planning questions in writing. Who is your audience, and how much do they know about your culture? What is your purpose: to explain, to celebrate, to question? How will you introduce the artifact, and which sensory details will make it vivid? Which anecdotes or examples will you include? What cultural background will readers need? How will you organise the piece, connect its parts and end it? Your answers turn the loose material from journaling into a plan.

Closing the gap with context

Readers outside your culture cannot understand an artifact's meaning without context, the background that explains the traditions, beliefs and history behind it. Du Bois's veil means little until readers know about segregation and racial violence in his time. Ask what an outsider would need to know, then supply it briefly, ideally woven into the description rather than delivered as a lecture. Your goal is to close the gap between your culture and your readers' so that they can see why the object matters, even if they have never encountered it.

Sensory and figurative language

Description comes alive through the senses: how the artifact looks, sounds, smells, tastes and feels in the hand. Figurative language adds meaning by comparison. A simile compares using "like" or "as" (the old quilt was as heavy as a sleeping child). A metaphor states the comparison directly (the quilt was a map of the family). Personification gives human qualities to an object (the kettle complained on the stove). Use these devices to carry the artifact's significance, not just to decorate the page.

Worked example: a character sketch

Model sketch: "Tío Ramón never wrote anything down. He kept every family recipe in his head and every phone number in a battered notebook only he could read. On Saturdays he stood at the stove in a pressed white shirt, humming boleros and tasting the beans from a wooden spoon, which he waved like a conductor's baton when someone added too much salt. 'Food remembers,' he liked to say. That spoon now hangs in my kitchen." Analysis: 1. It opens with a surprising trait. 2. Habits and appearance are shown through specific details. 3. A simile turns the spoon into a sign of his authority. 4. His own words reveal personality. 5. The last line ties the person to the artifact.

Worked example: adding context

Draft: "My grandmother's molcajete sits on our counter. We use it to make salsa." Revision: "My grandmother's molcajete, a heavy bowl of rough grey volcanic stone used in Mexican kitchens for grinding, sits on our counter. She carried it from Puebla in 1978, wrapped in a blanket. When I crush roasted tomatoes and chillies in it, the smoky smell fills the room, and I am grinding them on the same stone she did." Analysis: 1. A short definition gives outsiders the context they need. 2. Sight, touch and smell make the object vivid. 3. The history links it to migration and family. 4. The final clause turns an object into a sign of continuity across generations.

Feedback and revision

Writing is recursive: you move forward, step back and repeat stages as your ideas develop. For this kind of piece, a peer reviewer from outside your culture is especially valuable, because they can tell you exactly where they lacked context. Ask them what they learned, what confused them and how they would describe your voice. Then reread for that voice: could a friend hear you in the draft? Finally, look at the piece from outside your own experience and check that its language is accurate and respectful towards every group it mentions.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, choosing an artifact so broad, such as "food", that nothing specific can be said about it. Second, describing the object without explaining what it means. Third, assuming readers share your background, so key terms and customs go unexplained. Fourth, explaining so much that the description turns into a lecture. Fifth, piling up decorative figures of speech that add no meaning. Sixth, presenting your own experience as if it spoke for everyone in your culture, when it is one perspective among many.

Key takeaways

Writing about identity is an act of selection, so it constructs a self as well as describing one. Du Bois's double consciousness names one experience of competing identities. A cultural artifact, physical, metaphorical or linguistic, can stand for something larger about a culture. Journaling through freewrites, character sketches and captured moments generates material; planning questions shape it. Context closes the gap between your culture and your readers'. Sensory and figurative language give the artifact meaning, and outside readers show where context is missing.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Writing as selection

Every account of a self chooses what to include

So writing constructs identity as well as describing it.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which of these would count as a cultural artifact for the assignment described in the reading?

Question 2 of 5

Why is a peer reviewer from outside your culture especially useful for a cultural artifact essay?

Question 3 of 5

Which revision of "We use my grandmother's molcajete to make salsa" best adds cultural context?

Question 4 of 5

What did W. E. B. Du Bois mean by double consciousness?

Question 5 of 5

A student writes a paragraph describing her uncle's habits, appearance, favourite saying and connection to a wooden spoon. Which journaling technique is this?

← Previous topicNext topic →