English Composition › Section B · Language, identity, and culture › Topic B.1

Language, identity, and the issues around them

The way you speak and write carries your family, your communities and your history with it. Understanding how language, culture and identity connect, and how language has been used to include and exclude, makes you a fairer reader and a more thoughtful writer.

Writing as a mark of a people

In the early 1800s a Cherokee man named Sequoyah, who did not read or write English, set out to give his people a written form of their own language. By about 1821 he had created a syllabary, a set of symbols each standing for a spoken syllable. It spread quickly, and within a few years many Cherokee could read and write in it; from 1828 the Cherokee Phoenix newspaper printed columns in both Cherokee and English. Sequoyah's work shows how closely language is tied to a group's sense of itself: a shared written language helped preserve a culture under heavy pressure.

What identity is

Identity is the sum of the things that make you who you are: your family and upbringing, the places you have lived, the languages you speak, your beliefs, your work and the many choices and experiences that shaped you. Everyone has several identities at once. You might be a daughter, a Texan, a bilingual speaker, a nursing student and a gamer, and you may emphasise different identities in different settings. Because identity grows out of lived experience, two people who share one identity, such as a hometown, may still see the world very differently.

Privilege, discrimination and intersectionality

Some identities bring unearned advantages in a given society; these are often called privileges. Others expose people to discrimination, unfair treatment because of who they are. Because each person holds several identities, their advantages and disadvantages combine. The legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw introduced the term intersectionality in 1989 to describe how overlapping identities, such as race and gender, can produce experiences that neither identity alone explains. A Black woman, for example, may face barriers that differ from those faced by Black men or by White women.

What culture is

A culture is the set of beliefs, customs, practices and ways of communicating that connect a group of people across time. Some parts are easy to see: food, clothing, festivals, rites of passage and language. Others are hidden: attitudes to time, family duty, authority or how directly to disagree. Culture is often pictured as an iceberg, with a small visible tip and a much larger mass below the water. The hidden parts are the hardest for outsiders to recognise, which is why misunderstandings between cultures so often start below the surface.

How culture is learned

Cultures teach in two ways. Some knowledge is taught explicitly, like the rules at a school orientation. Much more is learned implicitly, such as which tables ninth-graders are expected to avoid in the cafeteria, though nobody ever says so. Together these shape a cultural lens, the outlook through which you interpret the world. Your lens is not fixed: new experiences, such as starting college, can reinforce, shift or change it. Culture itself changes too, and language is one of its most fluid and most easily misread parts.

Voice: identity on the page

When writing teachers talk about voice, they mean the personality that comes through your writing. It is built from four main ingredients: vocabulary, the words you choose; tone, the attitude they convey; viewpoint, the perspective you write from; and syntax, the way you arrange words into sentences. Because the combinations are endless, every writer's voice is distinctive, and it carries traces of their culture and identity. Academic writing does not require you to erase that voice, only to adapt it to the audience and purpose.

Oppression and language

Oppression is prolonged, systematic unjust treatment of a group. Language has often been one of its tools. Historians estimate that about 12.5 million Africans were forced onto slave ships between the 1500s and the 1860s, and enslaved people in the Americas were sometimes deliberately separated from others who shared their language. In the United States, federal boarding schools for Native American children, which operated from the 1800s well into the 1900s, commonly punished children for speaking their own languages. Today many communities are working to reclaim languages and terms that were suppressed or used against them.

Bias and language bias

A bias is a tendency to favour one person, group or idea over another, often unfairly. People naturally lean towards the familiar, and much bias is unconscious. One common form is language bias: judging someone's intelligence or character by their accent or dialect. Linguists agree that every dialect, including African American English and Southern American English, follows consistent rules of its own; none is simply broken English. Yet listeners often rate some accents as more educated than others. Questioning those reactions is a first step towards treating speakers as people first.

Worked example: surface and hidden culture

A student writes: "Every Sunday my family eats rice and beans together at two o'clock. Nobody is told to come, yet nobody misses it. My grandmother is served first, and we never leave the table until she does. When my cousin moved away, the meal didn't stop: we now set up a video call." Analysis: 1. Visible culture: the food, the fixed day and time. 2. Hidden culture: unspoken values of family duty and respect for elders, learned implicitly because "nobody is told". 3. Culture changes: the video call adapts the custom. 4. Writing about identity works best through concrete scenes like this, which let readers infer the values instead of being told them.

Worked example: describing, not ranking

A student's first draft: "My lab partner speaks bad English. She says 'he be studying' instead of 'he is studying'." Revised: "My lab partner sometimes uses habitual be, a feature of African American English: 'he be studying' means that he studies regularly, not that he is studying right now." Analysis: 1. The draft judges the speaker; the revision describes the language. 2. The revision is more accurate: habitual be marks a repeated action, a distinction Standard English needs extra words such as "usually" to make. 3. Naming the dialect treats it as a system with rules. 4. The writer can still discuss when Standard English is expected, without implying the speaker is less capable.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating identity as a single label rather than several overlapping ones. Second, describing only the visible tip of a culture, such as its food, and ignoring the values beneath. Third, assuming your own cultural lens is neutral and everyone else's is a bias. Fourth, calling a dialect "bad" or "broken" English when it follows consistent rules. Fifth, treating oppression as only historical, when its effects on language and opportunity continue. Sixth, assuming you must erase your voice to write academically.

Key takeaways

Identity is the sum of what makes you who you are, and everyone holds several identities. Privilege and discrimination combine across them, which intersectionality describes. Culture has visible and hidden parts, is taught explicitly and learned implicitly, and keeps changing. Your cultural lens shapes how you read the world. Voice, built from vocabulary, tone, viewpoint and syntax, carries identity onto the page. Language has been used to oppress and is now being reclaimed. Every dialect is rule-governed, so question language bias in yourself and in texts.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Sequoyah's syllabary

Symbols for Cherokee syllables, completed about 1821

A written language strengthened a people's identity.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What does the term intersectionality describe?

Question 2 of 5

In the iceberg model of culture, which of these lies below the waterline?

Question 3 of 5

No one tells new students where to sit at lunch, but within a week they all know which tables belong to seniors. This is an example of what?

Question 4 of 5

A writer describes a classmate who uses African American English as speaking "broken English". What is the main problem with this description?

Question 5 of 5

Which list names the four ingredients of a writer's voice described in the reading?

← Previous topicNext topic →