English Composition › Section L · Argumentative research › Topic L.3
Editing focus: quoting, paraphrasing, and summarizing
Every borrowed idea enters your paper in one of three forms: a quotation, a paraphrase or a summary. Choosing the right form, introducing it smoothly and reproducing it accurately keep your argument readable, honest and clearly your own.
Three ways to bring in a source
A quotation reproduces a source's exact words inside quotation marks. A paraphrase restates one specific passage in your own words and your own sentence structure; it may be about as long as the original or somewhat shorter. A summary condenses the main ideas of a longer passage, or a whole work, into a few sentences of your own. All three need a citation, because the ideas still belong to the source even when the words are yours. In MLA style that citation is usually brief and parenthetical, such as (Brennan 63), and it points to a full entry in your list of works cited.
Choosing among the three
Quote when the exact words matter: a precise definition or distinction, wording that is especially vivid or historically significant, an authority's own statement, a passage you will analyse or dispute, or a claim you want to keep at arm's length. Paraphrase when you need the idea rather than the wording: for statistics, for long or jargon-heavy passages, when combining several sources, or when a quotation would break the flow. If a technical term must stay, keep it in quotation marks within the paraphrase. Summarise when readers need background or the gist of a source's argument before you respond to it. Too many quotations make a paper choppy and drown out your voice.
Patchwriting and how to avoid it
Patchwriting means swapping some of a source's words for synonyms while keeping its sentence structure and sequence. Even with a citation, it can count as plagiarism, because the expression is still largely the source's. It usually comes from writing with the source open beside you. To avoid it, read the whole passage until you understand it, put the source out of sight, and write the idea as you would explain it to a friend. Then compare your version with the original: check that the meaning is accurate, and put any phrase you kept word for word in quotation marks.
Worked example: paraphrase, not patchwriting
Invented source (Brennan, page 63): "City trees do more than shade pavements. In a hot summer, a street lined with mature trees can be several degrees cooler than a bare street nearby, and that difference matters most to older residents, who are the most vulnerable to heat." Patchwriting: "Urban trees do more than shade sidewalks. In a warm summer, a road lined with older trees can be a few degrees cooler than a treeless road close by." Paraphrase: "Brennan points out that well-grown street trees can cool a road noticeably during summer heat, which protects elderly people most because they suffer most when temperatures rise (63)." Analysis: 1. The patchwriting follows the original clause by clause, only swapping synonyms. 2. The paraphrase rebuilds the sentence around the writer's point. 3. Both still need the citation.
Signal phrases and signal verbs
A signal phrase introduces borrowed material and tells readers whose words or ideas follow and why they matter. A well-known name may be enough. For a less familiar source, add a credential: "Lena Ortiz, a hydrologist who has studied the reservoir for a decade, warns that..." When your paper is about a particular work, introduce the quotation by the work's title instead. The verb carries a stance. "Notes", "reports" and "observes" are neutral; "argues" and "maintains" mark a position; "concedes" and "admits" signal yielding a point; "claims" can hint at doubt. Vary both the verbs and the placement, putting signal phrases at the start, middle or end of the sentence.
Quoting accurately: ellipses and brackets
The earlier editing-focus topic on quotations introduced these marks; here the focus is accuracy. You may shorten or adjust a quotation, but every change must be marked and the meaning must not change. An ellipsis, three spaced periods (. . .), marks words left out; when the omission includes the end of a sentence, a fourth period marks that end. Square brackets mark words you add or alter, for example to clarify a pronoun or make the quotation fit your grammar. If a quotation does not fit your sentence, you have three choices: quote less of it, rebuild your own sentence around it, or make a small bracketed change. Never cut words in a way that reverses or distorts what the source said.
Worked example: an accurate cut and a distorted one
Invented source (Adeyemi, page 12): "The museum's new wing is not a triumph of design, though its lighting is excellent. It will still draw new visitors." Distorted: Adeyemi calls the wing "a triumph of design" (12). Accurate: Adeyemi denies that the wing is "a triumph of design" but admits that "its lighting is excellent" (12). Clarified: Adeyemi predicts that "[the wing] will still draw new visitors" (12). Analysis: 1. The distorted version drops "not", reversing the critic's judgement. 2. The accurate version quotes two short phrases and uses signal verbs, denies and admits, that report the stance faithfully. 3. The brackets replace the vague "It" with the noun it stands for, so the reader knows what will draw visitors.
Short and long quotations in MLA
As a reminder of the MLA rules, a prose quotation of four lines or fewer runs inside your paragraph in quotation marks. The parenthetical citation comes after the closing quotation mark and before the sentence's full stop: "can be several degrees cooler" (Brennan 63). If the signal phrase names the author, give only the page: (63). A prose quotation longer than four lines becomes a block quotation. Introduce it, usually with a complete sentence ending in a colon, indent the whole block half an inch from the left margin, and leave out the quotation marks, since the indentation signals quotation. Put the citation after the block's final punctuation. For poetry, the limit for running a quotation in the text is three lines.
The quotation sandwich
A quotation needs bread on both sides. First, introduce it with a signal phrase that gives the source and some context. Second, present the quotation itself, trimmed to the words you need. Third, explain it: say what it means and how it supports your point. A quotation dropped into a paragraph with no introduction leaves readers unsure who is speaking, and one that ends a paragraph with no explanation leaves them to guess why it is there. Quotations do not speak for themselves. As a rough guide, your explanation and analysis should run longer than the words you quote.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, patchwriting: changing words while keeping the source's structure. Second, leaving out the citation for a paraphrase or summary because the words are your own. Third, using an ellipsis or a selective cut that changes the source's meaning. Fourth, making changes to a quotation without marking them with brackets. Fifth, dropping a quotation into a paragraph with no signal phrase or no explanation. Sixth, punctuating MLA citations wrongly: no comma between author and page, no "p.", and the full stop after the parenthesis for a short quotation. Seventh, using quotation marks around a block quotation.
Key takeaways
Quote when the exact words matter, paraphrase a specific passage in your own words and structure, and summarise main ideas briefly; all three need citations. Avoid patchwriting by writing from understanding with the source out of sight. Introduce sources with signal phrases and verbs that report their stance fairly. Mark omissions with ellipses and changes with brackets, and never distort meaning. In MLA, short quotations run in the text with the citation before the full stop; prose quotations over four lines are indented blocks without quotation marks. Introduce, quote, then explain.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A source's exact words in quotation marks
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A student changes "rapid" to "fast" and "residents" to "locals" in a source's sentence but keeps its structure, then adds a citation. What has the student produced?
Question 2 of 5
Which sentence punctuates an MLA quotation correctly?
Question 3 of 5
A source says: "The plan is not affordable, though its goals are admirable." Which quotation is accurate?
Question 4 of 5
When is paraphrasing usually better than quoting?
Question 5 of 5
In MLA style, how should a six-line prose quotation be presented?
