English Composition › Section L · Argumentative research › Topic L.4
Evaluating a research paper
A research paper can change direction while you write it, so the draft you finish may not be the paper you planned. Evaluating it against clear criteria, before anyone grades it, shows you what to fix and in what order.
Why evaluate before you submit
While drafting, you follow your strongest interests and chase the answer to your research question. That is healthy, but it means a paper that began about one thing can end up about another. Evaluation catches the gap. The most useful yardstick is a rubric like the one your instructor will grade with: read it before you draft, consult it while drafting, and score your own paper against it before you submit. Combine that self-review with feedback from a peer partner, who can see problems that you no longer notice because you already know what you meant.
Three areas a rubric examines
Rubrics for argumentative research papers usually look at three broad areas. The first, often labelled critical language awareness, is how well the paper integrates sources: signal phrases, accurate and well-trimmed quotations, genuine paraphrases and correct citations. The second is clarity and coherence: a clear thesis, focused paragraphs and smooth connections between ideas. The third is rhetorical choices: the writer's voice, the balance between sources and the writer's own thinking, the handling of counterclaims, and awareness of the audience. Each area is often scored on a five-level scale running from beginning work up to skilful work. Knowing the areas in advance tells you what to look for.
Area one: integrating sources
Ask whether every borrowed idea is introduced, accurate and cited. Each quotation should have a signal phrase, be trimmed to the words that make the point, and be followed by explanation. Every ellipsis and bracket should leave the source's meaning intact. Paraphrases should be in your own words and sentence structure, not patchwriting. Every quotation, paraphrase and summary should carry an in-text citation that matches an entry in the works-cited list. A strong paper also makes deliberate choices: following the conventions of research writing where they serve the reader, and departing from them only on purpose.
Area two: clarity and coherence
Ask whether a reader can follow the argument without effort. The thesis should state a clear position on a debatable issue, and credible researched evidence should support it throughout. Each paragraph should be well developed, open with a topic sentence and relate directly to the thesis. In a long paper, headings and subheadings can show how the argument is organised. Transitions should connect each idea to the next, so the reader always knows how a new point relates to the last one. Weakness here is often easy to see: paragraphs with no topic sentence, or a sudden jump from one source to another.
Area three: rhetorical choices
Ask whether the writer is in control. The voice should be objective and measured, without sarcasm or overstatement. The paper should balance source information with the writer's own analysis, synthesis and original thought; a paper that is mostly borrowed material scores low here even if every source is cited. Quotations should support points rather than replace them. Counterclaims should be stated fairly and answered. Finally, the writer should stay aware of the audience, using language readers understand and giving them the background they need, neither more nor less.
Checking for drift with a reverse outline
A reverse outline shows what your draft actually argues, as opposed to what you planned. After drafting, write one short line for each paragraph stating its main point in your own words, ignoring the examples. Then read the list against your thesis. Every line should advance the thesis. A line that does not either signals a paragraph to revise, move or cut, or reveals that the paper has found a better argument than the thesis states, in which case you revise the thesis instead. The outline also shows repetition, when two lines say the same thing, and gaps, when a step in the reasoning is missing.
Worked example: a reverse outline
Thesis: "Cities should plant street trees first in the neighbourhoods with the fewest." Reverse outline: (1) introduction and thesis; (2) tree-lined streets stay cooler in summer; (3) heat harms older residents most; (4) the history of the city's tree-planting budget; (5) the poorest districts have the fewest trees; (6) critics say watering costs are too high, with a response; (7) conclusion and recommendation. Analysis: 1. Paragraphs 2, 3, 5 and 6 each advance the thesis. 2. Paragraph 4 is background that does not lead anywhere, so it should be cut or tied to the argument, perhaps by showing past budgets favoured richer districts. 3. No paragraph links paragraph 3 to paragraph 5, so a gap remains: do the poorest districts also house the most older residents?
Checking citations against the works cited
Every in-text citation must lead to a matching entry in the works-cited list, and every entry must be cited somewhere in the paper. In MLA style, the list starts on a new page headed Works Cited, entries are in alphabetical order by the author's surname, the whole list is double-spaced, and each entry after its first line is indented half an inch. Two examples, using invented sources: a book, Brennan, Moira. Shade and the City. Riverbend Press, 2022. And a web article, Okoro, Chidi. "Teaching Students to Read Advertisements." Classroom Media Review, 4 Mar. 2024, www.example.org/okoro-ads. In a real list, the book title and the website name would be in italics.
Worked example: scoring a paragraph
Draft paragraph, with invented sources: "Street trees matter. Brennan says trees 'can be several degrees cooler' (63). 'Heat is the deadliest weather hazard for older adults' (Lowell 9). Poor districts have fewer trees." Analysis: 1. Integrating sources: the first quotation does not fit its sentence, since trees are not cooler; the streets are, so the writer should quote less or adjust it with brackets. The second quotation has no signal phrase. The final claim has no citation. 2. Clarity: "Street trees matter" is a topic but not a claim, and nothing links the sentences. 3. Rhetorical choices: the writer adds no explanation, so the sources do all the talking. 4. Priority: write a real topic sentence first, then the explanations, then fix the quotations and citation.
Using feedback and revising
Revise from the largest problems to the smallest. First fix the global issues: a thesis that does not match the paper, paragraphs that do not serve it, and missing counterclaims. Then fix paragraph-level issues such as weak topic sentences, missing explanation and poor transitions. Leave sentence-level editing and citation formatting until last, since there is no point polishing a paragraph you may cut. Before submitting, check that the paper has a strong thesis, sufficient and accurate support, a mix of summary, paraphrase, quotation and synthesis, fairly answered counterclaims, complete and correct citations, and a strong closing.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading the rubric only after the paper is finished. Second, scoring your paper on what you meant rather than what the page says, which a reverse outline prevents. Third, polishing sentences before fixing the thesis and structure. Fourth, assuming a paper with many citations is well researched, when it may have little analysis of its own. Fifth, leaving an in-text citation with no matching works-cited entry, or the reverse. Sixth, ignoring a peer reviewer's comment because it is uncomfortable; at least test it against the page.
Key takeaways
Evaluate a research paper against the rubric throughout drafting, not just at the end. Rubrics usually examine source integration, clarity and coherence, and rhetorical choices, often on a five-level scale. A reverse outline, one line per paragraph, reveals drift, repetition and gaps. Every in-text citation must match an entry in an alphabetical, double-spaced works-cited list with hanging indents. Revise from global problems to paragraph problems to sentence-level editing, and finish by checking the essential elements of the paper.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A scoring guide listing criteria and levels of quality
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What is the main purpose of a reverse outline?
Question 2 of 5
A paper's quotations are accurate and fully cited, but its paragraphs lack topic sentences and jump between ideas with no transitions. Which rubric area is weakest?
Question 3 of 5
Which is a correct MLA works-cited entry for a book? (Italics are not shown.)
Question 4 of 5
A paper's thesis does not match what its body paragraphs now argue, and several sentences also have comma errors. What should the writer fix first?
Question 5 of 5
A draft cites (Okoro) in the text, but there is no Okoro entry in the works-cited list. What does this mean?
