English Composition › Section P · Print or textual analysis › Topic P.3

Editing focus: the literary present tense

A story may be told in the past tense, and its author may have died a century ago, yet when you write about it, its characters act and its author speaks in the present. Knowing when that convention applies, and when it does not, keeps your analysis clear.

Texts live in the present

The earlier editing focus on tense consistency noted that MLA convention uses the present tense for writing about texts. In textual analysis this convention has a name, the literary present. Its reasoning is simple: a novel's events are not finished history. Every time someone opens the book, the characters make their choices again, so you write about them as happening now. The narrator may tell the story in the past tense, but your discussion of it stays in the present. This topic sets out the rule, the important exceptions, and how to edit a draft that slips between them.

The basic rule

Use the present tense for what happens in a literary work and for what its characters, narrator or speaker say, think and do. Incorrect: "In the final chapter, the narrator admitted that she lied." Correct: "In the final chapter, the narrator admits that she lied." Use the present tense, too, for what an author does in a text, even if the author died long ago: "Thoreau argues that most people complicate their lives needlessly." The same applies to the effects of a text: "The repeated image of the locked door suggests that the family is trapped." Once you choose the literary present, keep it consistent.

Earlier events within the story

The literary present does not mean that every verb becomes present. A story has its own timeline, and events that took place before the action you are discussing still need a past form. Measure time from the moment in the text you are describing, then choose tenses as you would for any present-tense passage. "When the novel opens, Leon returns to the town he fled ten years earlier." Returns is the present action; fled happened before it. For something completed before that moment and still relevant, use the present perfect: "By the time the story opens, Leon has already lost his job."

Outside the text: biography and history

Facts about an author's life, about publication, and about history happen outside the text, so they take the past tense. "Thoreau lived at Walden Pond from 1845 to 1847 and published Walden in 1854." Those are completed events. In the next breath you return to the present for the book itself: "In Walden, he argues that a simple life frees the mind." The test for each verb is whether it describes something in the text, which takes the present, or something in the real world's past, which takes the past. Context paragraphs in an analysis often move between the two deliberately.

Quotations and the literary present

A quotation keeps its original tense, even when that clashes with yours. Your own framing verb stays in the present: "The narrator recalls that she 'waited by the gate until dark.'" Here recalls is your present-tense verb, and waited is the author's word, untouched. If a quotation's pronoun or verb makes your sentence ungrammatical, either rebuild your sentence around it or make a small change in square brackets, as the earlier topics on quotations explained: Thoreau explains that he "went to the woods because [he] wished to live deliberately." Never alter a quoted verb silently to match your tense.

Other texts and disciplines

The literary present covers more than novels. Use it for poems, plays, films, songs and literary nonfiction, and in MLA-style writing for the ideas in any text you discuss: "The essay claims..." Conventions differ elsewhere. APA style, used in many social sciences, usually reports what other researchers did in the past tense or the present perfect ("Lee found", "studies have shown"). Historians narrate past events in the past tense. Follow the convention of the discipline and style guide you are writing for, and if an assignment is unclear, ask your instructor which applies.

Worked example: editing a paragraph

Draft: "In the story, Mara found her grandmother's letters in the attic. She read them aloud and realises that her grandmother had once planned to leave the farm. The author showed that families hide their histories. The author grew up on a farm herself." Edits: 1. Found becomes finds: it is an event in the text. 2. Read becomes reads, matching realises. 3. Had once planned becomes once planned: the grandmother's plan comes before the story's present, and in a present-tense frame an earlier event takes the simple past. 4. Showed becomes shows: it describes what the author does in the text. 5. Grew up stays: it is a fact of the author's life, outside the text.

Worked example: a deliberate mix

Model passage: "Thoreau moved to Walden Pond in 1845 and published Walden nine years later. In the book, he argues that most people waste their lives on needless detail. His cry 'Simplicity, simplicity, simplicity!' turns that argument into a chant, and he explains that he 'went to the woods because [he] wished to live deliberately.'" Analysis: 1. Moved and published are past, because they are events in Thoreau's life. 2. Argues is present, because it describes his ideas in the text. 3. Turns is present, because it describes the text's effect. 4. Explains is present, but the quoted went keeps its original past tense. 5. The bracketed he adjusts the quotation's pronoun to fit the sentence.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, letting a story's past-tense narration pull your discussion into the past: "Mara found" instead of "Mara finds". Second, putting an author's biography into the present: "Thoreau lives at Walden Pond." Third, forcing every verb into the present, so that events before the story's action become confused. Fourth, silently changing a quoted verb to match your tense. Fifth, switching between "argues" and "argued" for the same author's ideas in one paragraph. Sixth, applying the literary present to an APA research report, where reporting verbs usually take the past.

Key takeaways

In the literary present, you discuss a text's events, characters, narrator and author's choices in the present tense, because the text happens anew whenever it is read. Events earlier in the story's own timeline still take a past or present perfect form. Biography, publication and history take the past. Quotations keep their own tenses; adjust your framing or use brackets instead. Apply the convention across literary forms and MLA writing, and follow APA or historical conventions where they apply.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Literary present

Present tense for discussing a text's events and choices

The narrator admits...

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which sentence uses the literary present correctly?

Question 2 of 5

Complete the sentence: "Thoreau ____ at Walden Pond from 1845 to 1847."

Question 3 of 5

In a present-tense analysis, which sentence correctly handles an event from before the story opens?

Question 4 of 5

A narrator says, "I waited by the gate until dark." Which sentence integrates the quotation correctly?

Question 5 of 5

Why does the literary present convention exist?

← Previous topicNext topic →