English Composition › Section P · Print or textual analysis › Topic P.4

Self-directed assessment

Reviewers are not always available, and even when they are, you are the one who must decide what to change. Self-directed assessment means building your own checks from the standards your writing will meet, then applying them honestly.

Being your own reviewer

Many writers depend on someone else to tell them how a draft is going, and outside readers are valuable. But a classmate may not be available, and even good feedback arrives only after you have done your own thinking. Self-directed assessment is a review you design and carry out yourself, ideally near the end of the process, when a full draft exists but there is still time to revise. You have practised self-evaluation with rubrics before. This time the emphasis is on independence: turning criteria into your own checks and applying them to a textual analysis.

Changing the medium

The main obstacle to reviewing your own work is familiarity: you read what you meant, not what you wrote. Changing the medium breaks that habit. Read the draft aloud, so your ear catches clumsy rhythm and missing words. Print it and mark the paper copy, or change the font, size or device, so the page looks new. Each change makes you slow down and see the text as a stranger might. Leaving the draft for a day, if the deadline allows, helps for the same reason.

Checking against your goals

Begin with the big picture. Every project has goals, whether personal, professional or academic: to persuade an instructor that your reading of a poem holds up, perhaps, or to explain a text to classmates who have not read it. Ask whether four things serve those goals: the points you make, the organisation, the tone and the style. A reverse outline, which you have used before, strips the draft back to its basic structure, so you can see whether the order of points still matches the thesis. Fix problems at this level before polishing sentences.

Building your own checklist

A rubric describes performance in general terms. To use it independently, rewrite each descriptor as a question you can answer yes or no about your own draft, and point to the passage that proves your answer. Add questions for your personal weak spots, such as confused words you know you misuse. A checklist of eight to twelve questions is usually enough: long enough to cover every criterion, short enough to apply carefully. Keep it, and reuse it for the next assignment in the same genre.

The literary present and conventions

For a textual analysis, critical language awareness centres on the chapter's editing focus: the literary present tense. At the top level, the essay always discusses the text's events, characters and author's choices in the present, while keeping the past for biography and history. A useful check is to highlight every verb that describes the text and confirm each one. The category also rewards meeting or challenging conventions deliberately and effectively, such as a short first-person sentence that acknowledges your own interpretive community, when the assignment allows it.

Clarity and coherence in an analysis

In this rubric, clarity and coherence asks whether every paragraph serves the purpose stated in the thesis and makes room for a thorough analysis of the work. The top level describes a clear overall organisation, effective transitions, and paragraphs that each open with a topic sentence and proceed logically from it to support the thesis. The lower levels describe a thesis that gives little focus, paragraphs that ramble or appear out of logical order, few transitions, and paragraphs that lack a topic sentence or have more than one.

Rhetorical choices: tone and fairness

Rhetorical choices asks whether the tone and language suit the audience and purpose, and whether the work shows thought, fairness, comprehension and awareness of the rhetorical situation. For a textual analysis, fairness means representing the text accurately: not quoting selectively, not ignoring lines that contradict your reading, and acknowledging that other readers may interpret differently. Comprehension means that your summary and quotations show you understood the text. Check that casual expressions such as "really love" have not slipped in where an academic audience expects measured analysis.

Format and design features

Self-assessment includes the look of the document, because different kinds of text have different formats. A literary analysis in MLA style is usually double-spaced with one-inch margins, has your name, instructor, course and date at the top left of the first page, your last name and the page number at the top right of every page, a centred title, and a Works Cited list on a new page. It rarely needs headings. A case study or lab report, by contrast, uses headed sections. Check the format your assignment requires.

Worked example: from rubric to checklist

Descriptors from the textual analysis rubric become questions. 1. "Paragraphs reflect the purpose stated in the thesis" becomes: can I link every paragraph to a phrase in my thesis? 2. "Topic sentences, then logical support" becomes: does each paragraph have exactly one topic sentence, and does each later sentence support it? 3. "Effective transitions" becomes: does each paragraph's opening connect to the one before? 4. "Literary present" becomes: have I highlighted and checked every verb about the text? 5. "Fairness and comprehension" becomes: have I ignored any line that contradicts my reading? Each question can be answered by pointing at the page.

Worked example: assessing a paragraph

Draft paragraph: "Frost was a great poet. In the poem, the speaker chose a road and said it made all the difference. I really love this ending, and the roads were probably different anyway. Also, the poem rhymes." Assessment: 1. Literary present: chose and said should be chooses and says. 2. Clarity and coherence: the opening is praise, not a topic sentence linked to a thesis, and the rhyme comment starts a second, unrelated focus. 3. Tone: "I really love" suits a chat more than an analysis. 4. Fairness: "probably different anyway" ignores the line saying the roads were worn "really about the same". 5. Plan: write a topic sentence, use that line as evidence, fix the tenses, and cut or connect the rhyme comment.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, rereading a draft in the same form, on the same screen, straight after writing it. Second, scoring yourself on effort or on how the essay felt to write. Third, copying the rubric's wording without turning it into checkable questions. Fourth, polishing sentences before checking that every paragraph serves the thesis. Fifth, checking only grammar and ignoring tone and fairness. Sixth, forgetting format: a strong analysis in the wrong layout still makes a poor first impression.

Key takeaways

Self-directed assessment is a review you design and run yourself, best done near the end of drafting. Change the medium to see the draft freshly, and check that points, organisation, tone and style serve your goals. Turn rubric descriptors into yes-or-no questions answered with evidence from the page. For a textual analysis, check the literary present, thesis-driven paragraphs with single topic sentences and transitions, a suitable tone, fairness to the text, and the required format.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Self-directed assessment

A review you design and carry out on your own draft

Best near the end of drafting.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which strategy changes the medium so that you see your own draft freshly?

Question 2 of 5

In the textual analysis rubric, which problem falls under clarity and coherence?

Question 3 of 5

What does turning a rubric into a personal checklist involve?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is part of MLA format for a literary analysis?

Question 5 of 5

A writer's thesis works only if one contradicting line of the poem is ignored. Which rubric area does this mainly affect?

← Previous topicNext topic →