English Composition › Section E · The profile › Topic E.4
Evaluating a profile as an introduction
Writing a profile is like introducing a friend to someone new: you choose the details that will make them connect. Evaluating your draft means checking that those details work, against clear standards for language, coherence and rhetorical choices.
A profile as a personal introduction
When you introduce two people at a party, you rarely recite facts. You mention what they share: both play chess, both grew up near the coast, both love the same band. A profile works the same way. You are introducing your subject to readers, so you select details that help those particular readers relate to it. For a campus magazine, that might be the subject's link to a building every student knows; for a hometown newsletter, a shared memory of a flood. Asking "What would make my readers care about meeting this subject?" is the first step in evaluating any draft.
Evaluating against a standard
Self-evaluation works best against a rubric, a table that names the areas of focus and describes each level of performance. A typical profile rubric has three areas, described in the next cards: language, coherence and rhetorical choices. Each is scored on five levels: 5 Skillful, 4 Accomplished, 3 Capable, 2 Developing and 1 Beginning. The words that change between levels are revealing. The language area moves from a text that always follows the editing focus, through usually, generally and occasionally, to one that does not. Aim for the Skillful description in every area, and use the lower descriptions to diagnose what is missing.
Critical language awareness
This area asks how consciously you handle language. For the profile, it covers three things. First, the chapter's editing focus, verb tense consistency: a Skillful text keeps its base tense and shifts only when time changes. Second, sentence variety: a mix of short and long, simple and complex sentences, rather than one pattern repeated. Third, deliberate choices about convention. A Skillful writer either meets readers' expectations or challenges them on purpose, for example by opening with a one-word sentence or by keeping a speaker's regional English intact in a quotation, and the effect is clearly rhetorical rather than accidental.
Clarity and coherence
This area judges whether the profile hangs together and rests on solid research. A Skillful profile shows robust interview research, carefully recorded field notes and credible, relevant secondary sources. It balances narrative and reporting, so the subject is both shown and explained. Its transitions knit paragraphs into a unified whole, and its anecdotes, quotations, location, thick description and background flow together. Lower levels drift in recognisable ways. A Capable draft tends to lean on too much reporting; a Developing one is often disorganised, with research that is haphazard and undocumented and only a few of the genre's elements present.
Rhetorical choices
The third area looks at the big decisions: subject, angle, tone and content. In a Skillful profile these are carefully chosen and stay consistent from the first paragraph to the last, so the piece holds the target audience's interest throughout. An Accomplished draft makes good choices that occasionally waver, perhaps a tone that turns gushing in the middle. A Capable draft loses focus now and then, wandering into material unrelated to the angle. At the lower levels, the subject, angle or tone seems poorly chosen or is missing, and readers' attention is lost in many places. This is where the "personal introduction" test matters most.
Worked example: scoring a paragraph
Draft paragraph: "Rosa Mendes opened Sunrise Bakery in 2008. It is on Elm Street. She bakes bread every day. She started baking because of her grandmother. She was very hardworking. The bakery sells 400 loaves a week." 1. Language: every sentence follows the same short pattern, and was shifts out of the present without a reason, since she is still hardworking. 2. Coherence: it is all reporting, with no anecdote, quotation or sensory detail, and no transitions link the facts. 3. Research: nothing shows an interview or a visit. 4. Rhetorical choices: hardworking is a vague trait, not an angle, and the tone is flat. 5. Verdict: around Developing in all three areas.
Worked example: revising towards Skillful
Revision: "At 4 a.m., when Elm Street is still dark, the windows of Sunrise Bakery already glow. Inside, Rosa Mendes is shaping the first of the roughly 400 loaves she sells each week, from the rye recipe her grandmother taught her. 'If I skip a day, people ask whether I'm ill,' she says, laughing. Since 2008, that dependability has made her bakery less a shop than the street's clock." 1. Base tense is present; taught marks finished past time, and has made links 2008 to now. 2. Sentence lengths and openings vary. 3. Thick description, a quotation and a fact are woven together. 4. The angle, dependability as a neighbourhood rhythm, gives the paragraph its point. 5. The tone is warm and steady.
Using peer feedback
A peer reviewer can apply the same standards from outside. A useful review sheet asks about each genre element: what interests the reader about the subject; what angle the draft takes and how to sharpen it; how it is structured; whether paragraphs mix anecdotes, quotations, facts and background; whether tone, tense and description work; what evidence shows interview, field and credible secondary research; and how to connect with the audience. Sentence frames keep comments specific and kind, such as "Three things that work well are..." and "You could strengthen this by...". Weigh comments several reviewers share most heavily.
Questions for self-evaluation
Before you hand in, question your own draft. Have you proofread for tense consistency, and do sentence lengths vary? Do your body paragraphs balance anecdotes, quotations, location, description and background, or does one element dominate? Where would one more interview detail or field note help? Does each paragraph support your thesis, and do transitions connect them? Read the piece aloud to hear its tone, and mark any passage where your own interest dips: readers will lose interest there too. Finally, ask whether your subject appears in the light most likely to engage your intended audience.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, scoring yourself on effort rather than on the rubric's actual descriptions. Second, treating the rubric as a checklist and cramming in one of every element, so paragraphs feel crowded instead of flowing. Third, fixing only language issues while the angle stays vague. Fourth, forgetting the audience: details that mean nothing to your readers do not introduce your subject to them. Fifth, accepting every peer comment, or rejecting all of them, without weighing each against the standards and your purpose.
Key takeaways
Think of a profile as a personal introduction, and choose details that connect your subject to your readers. Evaluate the draft against a rubric with three areas: critical language awareness (tense consistency, sentence variety, deliberate choices about convention), clarity and coherence (research, a balance of narrative and reporting, transitions) and rhetorical choices (subject, angle, tone and content held steady). Use the five levels, from Skillful down to Beginning, to diagnose gaps, and combine peer feedback with honest self-questioning.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Present the subject with details that help readers relate to it
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In the profile rubric, which area covers verb tense consistency and sentence variety?
Question 2 of 5
A draft profile is full of accurate dates and figures but has almost no scenes. What would most improve it?
Question 3 of 5
Why can a profile be thought of as a personal introduction?
Question 4 of 5
In the five-level rubric, what is the top level called?
Question 5 of 5
In the Sunrise Bakery draft, why does "She was very hardworking" weaken the paragraph?
