English Composition › Section K · Reasoning strategies › Topic K.2

Supporting reasoning with evidence

Knowing the six reasoning strategies is only the start. This topic shows how to turn each one into a body paragraph that states a point, backs it with evidence, explains that evidence, and leads the reader back to your thesis.

From reasoning to paragraphs

The previous topic introduced the six reasoning strategies. In an essay, each body paragraph usually runs on one main strategy, chosen to suit the point it makes. A strong paragraph has four working parts. The topic sentence states the paragraph's claim in the shape of its strategy and ties that claim to the thesis. Evidence supports the claim. Explanation tells the reader what the evidence shows. Analysis connects it back to the thesis, answering the question "so what?". Before you draft, write down your working thesis, so every topic sentence has something to point at.

Topic-sentence frames

A frame is a fill-in pattern that gives a topic sentence the shape of its strategy. Analogy: "[X] resembles [Y] in one key respect: [shared feature]." Cause and effect: "Because [cause], [effect]." Division: "[Whole] breaks down into [part], [part] and [part]." Classification: "[Item], [item] and [item] are all kinds of [group]." Comparison and contrast: "[X] and [Y] both [similarity], but they differ in [difference]." Problem and solution: "[Action] would solve the problem of [problem]." Definition: "[Term] usually means [common sense]; here it means [extended sense]." Frames are scaffolding. Once the draft exists, reword them freely: drafting and revising loop back on each other.

Two orders for the same material

Most strategies can run in either direction, and the order changes the emphasis. A cause-and-effect paragraph can open with the causes and build to the result, or open with the result and then explain how it came about. A problem-and-solution paragraph can describe the problem first or announce the solution first and then justify it. A comparison can lead with the similarity or with the difference. Division starts from a whole and splits it; classification starts from separate items and groups them. Lead with what your reader most needs first: familiar ground for a newcomer, or your most striking point for a reader who already knows the background.

Bringing in evidence from sources

Most academic writing combines your own ideas with ideas from others. Borrowed material helps you explore a topic, define or illustrate a point, prove a claim, push readers to think critically, and lend your argument credibility. It can come from public sources, such as articles, books and websites, or from personal ones, such as an interview or an email. Whatever the source, cite it in the format your instructor requires. In MLA style, a short parenthetical citation gives the author and page, such as (Marsh 22). Match the evidence to the strategy: a cause-and-effect paragraph needs evidence of the causal link itself, not merely that one event came after another.

Worked example: a cause-and-effect paragraph

The source here, Marsh, is invented for this example. Thesis: "The town should restore its late-night bus route." Model paragraph: "Because the late-night bus was cut last spring, evening-shift workers lost their only affordable way home. A survey of 300 riders found that 41 percent now pay for taxis at least twice a week (Marsh 22). That cost falls hardest on the lowest-paid workers, who are the people a public route exists to serve. Restoring the route would remove a cost the town itself created." Analysis: 1. The topic sentence uses "because" to set up cause and effect. 2. The survey figure is evidence, with an MLA citation. 3. The third sentence explains why the figure matters. 4. The last sentence links back to the thesis.

Worked example: a definition paragraph

The source, Okoro, is invented for this example and has no page numbers. Thesis: "Schools should treat media literacy as a core subject." Model paragraph: "Most people think media literacy means spotting fake news; in this essay, it means understanding how any message is built to persuade. A student who can name a fake headline but cannot explain why a real advertisement works has learned only half the skill. Teachers in one district reported that students who analysed real advertisements wrote sharper arguments of their own (Okoro)." Analysis: 1. The topic sentence follows the definition frame, from common meaning to extended meaning. 2. The second sentence illustrates the gap between the two meanings. 3. The cited report is evidence. 4. Revision point: the paragraph ends on evidence with no analysis, so it needs a closing sentence tying the definition to the thesis.

Combining strategies, and a visual draft

Paragraphs often blend strategies. A problem-and-solution paragraph may use cause and effect to explain how the problem arose, or a comparison to show why one solution beats another. Supporting techniques help too: description gives sensory detail, narration tells a brief story, and sequencing sets out events or steps in order. Some instructors ask for a visual draft: a poster that makes the same argument in images. Common layouts place one central image with related images around it, run images in rows or columns, or split the poster into two contrasting halves, which suits a before-and-after cause and effect. Use images you have the right to use.

Checking your topic sentences

After drafting, check that your reasoning holds up, starting with the topic sentences, because they carry the main support for the thesis. Ask four questions of each one. Does it reflect the strategy the paragraph uses? Does it directly support the thesis? Does it make a sensible point? What is its job: to give background, a reason, an illustration, an explanation, or a response to a counterclaim? If you cannot answer clearly, revise the sentence. A topic sentence that is true but does not advance the thesis is still a problem, because the reader cannot see why the paragraph is there.

Checking how each paragraph develops

Next, test the sentences that develop each topic sentence. Copy one paragraph onto a blank page so you see it on its own, then ask the same kinds of question of every supporting idea. Does it fit the paragraph's strategy? Does it support the topic sentence, not some other point? Is it sensible? Can you name its job: background, a reason for the claim, an illustration, an explanation, or evidence that demonstrates the point? Any idea whose job you cannot name should be revised or replaced with one that you can develop logically. This is also the moment to check for the fallacies covered in the previous topic.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, writing a topic sentence that announces a subject but makes no claim, such as "This paragraph is about buses." Second, choosing a strategy that does not suit the point, such as an analogy where the reader needs hard numbers. Third, dropping in evidence with no explanation or analysis, leaving the reader to guess why it matters. Fourth, using evidence of sequence in a cause-and-effect paragraph when it needs evidence of cause. Fifth, forgetting to cite borrowed facts, even ones from a conversation. Sixth, keeping the frame's wording so rigidly that every paragraph sounds the same.

Key takeaways

Each body paragraph usually runs on one main reasoning strategy. A strong paragraph has a topic sentence that makes a claim tied to the thesis, evidence, explanation of that evidence, and analysis that links back to the thesis. Topic-sentence frames give each strategy its shape, and most strategies can run in either order. Evidence from public or personal sources must fit the strategy and be cited, such as (Marsh 22) in MLA style. After drafting, check each topic sentence and each supporting idea for its strategy, its support for the point above it, its sense, and its job.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Four parts of a body paragraph

Topic sentence, evidence, explanation, analysis

Analysis links back to the thesis.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which topic sentence is framed for a problem-and-solution paragraph?

Question 2 of 5

A cause-and-effect paragraph claims a new app caused falling library visits. Its only evidence is that visits dropped after the app launched. What is the main weakness?

Question 3 of 5

In the model paragraph about the late-night bus, what does the final sentence do?

Question 4 of 5

Which sentence opens a cause-and-effect paragraph with the effect?

Question 5 of 5

A topic sentence is accurate and well written, but it does not support the thesis. What should the writer do?

← Previous topicNext topic →