English Composition › Section L · Argumentative research › Topic L.1

Research as evidence: types of evidence

A claim on a debatable issue persuades only when it rests on something more than the writer's say-so. Research supplies that support, and knowing where evidence comes from and what each kind can prove lets you choose the evidence your readers will trust.

Research is something you already do

Before you choose a phone or a film, you probably look for information, test it against other information, and weigh it before deciding. That everyday habit is research, and academic research is a more careful, documented version of it. In a research argument, you take a position on a debatable issue, one on which informed people disagree, and use evidence to persuade readers that your position is sound. Evidence is what turns an opinion into an argument: it shows the claim rests on more than personal preference, and it lets readers judge the claim for themselves instead of simply taking your word for it.

Research is rhetorically situated

Like any communication, research has a purpose, the goal it serves; an audience, who will receive the findings; a genre, the form the findings take; a stance, the position the research supports; a context, the situation around the subject; and a culture, the shared beliefs and experiences of the writer, audience and subject. Suppose a student notices how much food the campus cafeteria throws away. The purpose might be to propose composting, the audience the dining-services manager, the genre a short proposal or a poster, and the evidence a week of weighing the waste. Change any one element and the best evidence changes too.

What researchers do

Research processes differ, but they share habits. Researchers start from genuine interest, which can grow as they learn. They ask questions that begin broad and sharpen over time. They seek answers from people, such as librarians and specialists, as well as from texts of many kinds. Some do field research, observing directly or interviewing, which generates new data. They evaluate sources by checking whether other sources confirm them. They write throughout, from notes to drafts. They test possible answers rather than assuming them. They synthesise, combining sources to reach conclusions, and finally present their findings in a focused, documented product.

Primary sources

A primary source is a firsthand account or original material, produced by someone with direct experience or created as part of the events or data being studied. Examples include diaries and letters, eyewitness accounts, interviews, speeches, original documents such as laws, treaties and certificates, newspaper reports written at the time of an event, and the results of observations, surveys and experiments. Data you collect yourself, by surveying classmates or weighing cafeteria waste, is primary too. Primary sources put you close to the evidence, but they still need interpreting: a single eyewitness may have seen only part of what happened.

Secondary and tertiary sources

A secondary source is at least one step removed from the events or data. It relies on other sources to interpret, analyse or explain them: most books and journal articles about a subject are secondary. A tertiary source mainly condenses existing knowledge; encyclopedias and many textbooks fit here. Whether a source is primary or secondary depends on how you use it. A biography of a composer is a secondary source about the composer, but a primary source if you are studying how the biographer thought. Strong research usually combines both kinds: primary sources to engage with the evidence directly, secondary sources to engage with other people's interpretations.

Statistics and examples

Statistics show scale and pattern in a way nothing else can, which makes them persuasive. They can also mislead. Before you use a figure, ask who collected it, what exactly it measures, how large and representative the sample was, and whether it has been quoted out of context or picked selectively. Examples and anecdotes do a different job. A specific case makes an abstract claim concrete, and a vivid story can move readers emotionally. One case, however, may not be typical, so an anecdote illustrates a pattern rather than proving it. The strongest support pairs the two: a story that shows what the problem looks like, and data that show how common it is.

Expert testimony and textual evidence

Expert testimony, the findings or statements of recognised authorities, lends weight to a claim. It is strongest when the expert works in the relevant field, the view reflects the broader consensus of that field, and the source publishing it is reputable. An economist on economics carries weight; the same economist on vaccine safety does not. In literary and rhetorical analysis, the main evidence is the text itself: quotations and specific details. Choose short, precise quotations that support your point directly, and always explain how they support it, because a quotation never speaks for itself.

Evidence across disciplines and audiences

What counts as good evidence depends on the field. In the humanities, research usually works with texts, ideas and interpretations. In the social and natural sciences, it usually works with data that can be checked through observation, measurement and testing. Audiences differ too. Scientists expect peer-reviewed studies, research that other experts evaluated before publication. A neighbourhood meeting may respond more to local examples and testimony from residents. Policymakers usually want costs and outcomes. Ask what your readers already trust, then supply evidence of that kind, alongside whatever else your argument needs.

Worked example: sorting sources

Research question: did a city's new bike-share scheme change how residents commute? All sources here are invented for this example. 1. The council minutes approving the scheme are primary: an original record made at the time. 2. A survey of 250 riders that you carry out yourself is primary: you generated the data. 3. A journal article comparing bike-share schemes in eight cities is secondary: it analyses other people's data. 4. An encyclopedia entry on bike sharing is tertiary: it condenses general knowledge. 5. A newspaper report from launch week is primary for what happened that week; a columnist's later reflection is secondary. 6. Check: the mix gives you direct evidence and other people's interpretations.

Worked example: matching evidence to the audience

Claim: "The school district should offer free breakfast to every student." 1. For the school board, which controls the budget, lead with statistics: hypothetically, the cost per student and attendance data from districts that already do this. 2. For a parents' meeting, add a teacher's account of students who cannot concentrate before lunch: an anecdote that makes the problem concrete. 3. For both, cite a paediatric nutritionist on breakfast and learning, an expert speaking within her field. 4. Check each piece against its limits: the anecdote needs the data to show it is typical, and the figures need a stated source and sample.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating one vivid anecdote as proof of a general pattern. Second, quoting a statistic without checking where it came from or what it measures. Third, citing an expert outside their field, or presenting one dissenting expert as if the field agreed. Fourth, assuming a source is always primary or always secondary; its role depends on your question. Fifth, relying only on secondary sources when primary evidence is available. Sixth, choosing evidence you find convincing while ignoring what your audience actually trusts.

Key takeaways

Research turns an opinion on a debatable issue into an argument, and it is shaped by purpose, audience, genre, stance, context and culture. Primary sources are firsthand or original; secondary sources interpret them; tertiary sources condense knowledge; a source's role depends on its use. Statistics show scale but must be checked; anecdotes illustrate but do not prove; expert testimony is strongest from a relevant field and consensus; textual evidence must be explained. Match evidence to the discipline and to what your audience trusts.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Evidence

Support that shows a claim rests on more than opinion

Turns an opinion into an argument.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A student studies how 1950s biographers wrote about artists, using a 1955 biography of a painter. For this project, what is the biography?

Question 2 of 5

Research question: how did workers describe a 1912 factory strike? Which source is primary?

Question 3 of 5

Why is one moving anecdote not enough to show that a policy works?

Question 4 of 5

When is expert testimony strongest?

Question 5 of 5

A researcher's evidence supports the position that the campus should compost its food waste. Which element of the rhetorical situation is that position?

← Previous topicNext topic →