English Composition › Section J · The position argument › Topic J.1

Position arguments and crafting a thesis

A position argument takes a side on a question that thoughtful people disagree about, and it lives or dies by its thesis. Learning to turn a broad topic into a sharp, arguable claim is the single most useful skill in argument writing.

Taking a position

In a position argument, you present your viewpoint on a debatable issue and try to persuade readers that it is right, or at least worth serious consideration. Op-eds, letters to the editor and policy papers are all position arguments. In writing, argument does not mean a quarrel. It means a reasoned case: a set of reasons and evidence offered to show that a position deserves support. In academic work the aim is less about winning than about changing minds and advancing understanding, so a good position argument treats opposing views seriously rather than mocking them.

What a position argument includes

Most position arguments, whatever their length, share a handful of moves. The writer introduces the issue and states a position on it, explains the issue so that readers understand what is at stake, presents reasons supported by evidence, addresses the views of those who disagree, and closes with a conclusion. This pattern echoes the classical argument of ancient rhetoric, which the next topic explores, along with other structures. Your instructor may ask you to follow it closely, but you can also adapt it when your audience or purpose calls for something different.

Choosing a debatable issue

A debatable issue is one on which reasonable, informed people disagree. Settled facts do not qualify: there is nothing to argue about the year a law was passed. Neither do pure matters of taste, such as whether mint is a nicer flavour than lemon, or claims so one-sided that no one would defend the other side. Good issues involve real doubt about which policy, reading or solution is soundest. In literature and history, they often concern how to interpret a text or event; in business and engineering, they often concern which solution to a problem is best.

Topic versus thesis

A topic is what you are writing about: "school uniforms". A thesis is what you claim about it: "Public secondary schools should drop compulsory uniforms, because the cost falls hardest on low-income families and the promised gains in behaviour have not been shown." The thesis is a declarative sentence, occasionally two, that states your position on the issue. It answers the central question of the essay, and every paragraph that follows should help explain, support or defend it. In most academic essays it appears near the end of the introduction, after enough context for readers to see why it matters; reports and business writing often put the main point first.

Four tests of a strong thesis

A strong thesis passes four tests. It is arguable: someone could reasonably disagree. It is specific: narrow enough to support well in the space you have. It is significant: it matters to someone and answers the question "So what?" And it is supportable: evidence and reasoning can back it, rather than personal preference alone. "Pizza is the best food" fails the last test. "The school cafeteria should offer a plant-based main dish every day to cut costs and widen choice" passes all four, because a reader could disagree and the writer could gather evidence on prices and student demand.

Weak theses and how to spot them

Weak theses tend to fall into a few types. A factual statement, such as "Many teenagers use social media", gives nothing to argue. A sweeping claim, such as "Technology is ruining society", is too broad to support. An announcement, such as "This essay will discuss school uniforms", names a topic but takes no position. A fence-sitter, such as "There are pros and cons to remote learning", is vague because it refuses to choose. Each needs the same fix: decide exactly what you claim, about whom, and why, then say it in one clear sentence.

The because clause and thesis frames

Thinking about the reasons behind your position helps a thesis grow from an opinion into an argument. Try adding a because clause: "The college should provide free campus Wi-Fi because many students have no reliable internet at home." The reason can come first or last, and it may be implied. Sentence frames can also help you find wording. "___ should (or should not) ___ because ___." "___ is caused by ___, so ___ should be done." "___ is similar to (or nothing like) ___ because ___." Adapt any frame freely; it is scaffolding, not a formula. A thesis can also map the main reasons in the order the essay will take them, which helps readers through a long essay.

From working thesis to final thesis

Few writers start with their final thesis. Most begin with a working thesis, a tentative claim that guides research and drafting. Asking the reporters' questions about your issue (who, what, when, where, why and how) often exposes what you still need to find out. As you learn more, revise. A working thesis usually becomes narrower and more qualified: "Homework is bad" might grow into "Primary schools should replace nightly worksheets with independent reading, because short daily reading builds skills without the stress of graded tasks." Revising the thesis is a sign of thinking, not failure.

Worked example: from topic to thesis

1. Topic: "public libraries". Too broad to argue. 2. Question: "Should our town's library open on Sundays?" Now there are sides. 3. Working thesis: "The library should open on Sundays." Arguable, but with no reason. 4. Reporters' questions: who would use it (students and shift workers), why (they work or study on weekdays), how it could be paid for (moving some quiet Monday-morning hours). 5. Final thesis: "The town library should open on Sunday afternoons, funded by trimming its quietest weekday hours, because students and shift workers cannot reach it during the week." 6. Check: arguable, specific, significant to those users, and supportable with usage records.

Worked example: testing three candidates

Issue: phones in high school classrooms. 1. "Phones are common in high schools." Fails the arguable test; it is a fact. 2. "Phones are destroying education." Arguable, but fails the specific and supportable tests: "destroying" and "education" are too large to prove. 3. "High schools should require phones to be stored in lockers during lessons, because constant notifications cut the time students spend focused on work." Passes: someone could argue for teaching responsible use instead, the scope is one rule in one setting, the stakes for learning are clear, and research on attention and classroom observation could support it.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing a topic with a thesis: a noun phrase is not a claim. Second, stating a fact and calling it a position. Third, making the claim so broad that no essay could support it. Fourth, announcing what the essay will do instead of saying what you think. Fifth, sitting on the fence to avoid disagreement, which leaves readers unsure where you stand. Sixth, refusing to revise the working thesis even after your research points somewhere new.

Key takeaways

A position argument is a reasoned case, not a quarrel, on an issue where informed people genuinely disagree. It typically introduces the issue and a position, explains the issue, gives reasons and evidence, addresses opposing views and concludes. A thesis is a declarative sentence stating your position, usually at the end of the introduction. Strong theses are arguable, specific, significant and supportable; weak ones state facts, sweep too broadly, announce or sit on the fence. A because clause and sentence frames help, and a working thesis should be revised as you learn.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Position argument

A reasoned case for a viewpoint on a debatable issue

Op-eds and letters to the editor are examples.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which is the strongest thesis for a position argument?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these is a debatable issue suitable for a position argument?

Question 3 of 5

"There are advantages and disadvantages to year-round schooling." What is the main weakness of this thesis?

Question 4 of 5

What is the main purpose of a working thesis?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these is a topic rather than a thesis?

← Previous topicNext topic →