English Composition › Section I · Rhetorical analysis › Topic I.4

Evaluating a rhetorical analysis

A rubric is not just how a teacher grades your essay; it is a checklist you can use while you write. Knowing what a strong rhetorical analysis looks like lets you judge your own draft, and your classmates', with precision.

Evaluate while you write

Evaluation is not something that happens only after you hand an essay in. Checking a draft against a rubric, especially once the first full draft exists, shows you where it already meets the standard and where it falls short while there is still time to act. Your instructor will probably use a rubric much like the one described here, so aiming at its top level keeps every revision pointed in the right direction. The same criteria serve when you review a classmate's draft, which in turn sharpens your eye for your own.

Three things a reader judges

A typical rubric for this essay has three criteria. Critical language awareness covers control of sentences, here the chapter's editing focus of avoiding mixed constructions, and whether any departures from convention are deliberate and effective. Clarity and coherence covers organisation: is information presented logically, do transitions connect paragraphs, does the essay stay focused on its thesis, and is every claim supported with quoted or paraphrased evidence? Rhetorical choices covers the analysis itself: does the writer identify strategies precisely and explain them with insight, keep a consistent voice, and stay aware of the rhetorical situation?

Five levels of performance

Each criterion is usually scored on five levels, often labelled skilful, accomplished, capable, developing and beginning. The difference between them is mostly one of consistency. A skilful essay always keeps its sentences under control, presents everything clearly and supports every claim fully. An accomplished one does so usually, a capable one generally, a developing one only occasionally, and a beginning one rarely or not at all. So the most useful question is not "Did I do this?" but "Did I do this every time?" One unsupported claim may cost little; a pattern of them moves the essay down a level.

Checking language awareness

Reread the draft slowly, sentence by sentence, looking for constructions that start one way and finish another, such as a by phrase used as a subject or a definition built on is when. Reading aloud helps, because the ear notices a missing subject faster than the eye. Then look at any choice that breaks a convention: a first-person aside, a one-line paragraph, a question addressed to the reader. The rubric rewards these only when they are clearly deliberate and suit the rhetorical situation. If you cannot say why a break helps, it probably reads as an error.

Checking clarity and coherence

A reverse outline is the quickest test of organisation. Beside each paragraph, write its main point in a few words; then read the list alone. Each point should support the thesis, the order should make sense, and no two paragraphs should make the same point. Next, check the joins: does each paragraph open with a transition or topic sentence that shows how it relates to the last? Finally, test the evidence. Every claim about the text should be backed by a quotation or a precise paraphrase, with a location readers could find. A claim with no evidence is an opinion, not analysis.

Checking rhetorical choices

This criterion asks how good the analysis is. Precision means naming strategies accurately: a statistic is logos, not ethos, even if it comes from an expert, though citing that expert may also build ethos. Insight means explaining why a strategy works, or fails, on this particular audience, rather than repeating that it exists. A consistent voice means staying analytical throughout, without sudden slang, sarcasm or cheerleading. Awareness of the rhetorical situation means your judgements keep the writer's purpose, audience and context in view: a tactic that suits a hostile audience may be wasted on a friendly one.

Worked example: scoring a paragraph

Draft paragraph: "The writer uses lots of logos. She says that 60 percent of residents support the plan. This is good evidence. Also she is a doctor so we trust her. Overall the letter is really persuasive and I agree with it." Evaluation: 1. Language awareness: no mixed constructions, but the phrasing is flat and informal. 2. Clarity and coherence: the paragraph drifts from logos to ethos and ends with a verdict on the issue, not the rhetoric. 3. Rhetorical choices: strategies are named but not analysed; it never asks where the figure comes from or why it would move these readers. 4. Overall level: developing. 5. Priority for revision: explanation of effect, then focus.

Worked example: revising to a higher level

Revised paragraph: "The writer's strongest appeal is to logos. Early on, she reports that 60 percent of residents in a council survey support the plan, a figure that reassures undecided readers they would not be backing a fringe idea. Because the survey is the council's own, opponents on the council cannot easily dismiss it. However, she never says how many people responded, so a sceptical reader may still doubt how representative it is." Changes: 1. The topic sentence makes one focused claim. 2. Evidence is given with its source. 3. The effect on two audiences is explained. 4. A limit is noted, adding insight. 5. The writer's ethos and the reviewer's personal view now belong elsewhere, or nowhere.

Giving and using feedback

Useful feedback is specific and tied to a criterion. "Good job" helps nobody. "Paragraph three names pathos but never says which words create it or how readers would feel" tells the writer exactly what to do. Point to strengths too, so the writer knows what to keep, and phrase suggestions as you would want to receive them. When you get feedback, sort it against the rubric. Fix the larger problems first, such as an unfocused thesis or missing evidence, before sentence-level comments. You need not accept every suggestion, but you should be able to explain why you rejected one.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, scoring yourself on effort rather than on what the page actually shows. Second, reading the rubric only after the essay is finished, when there is no time to act on it. Third, treating the three criteria as one: a well-organised essay can still have shallow analysis. Fourth, giving peers vague praise or vague criticism instead of comments tied to a criterion and a paragraph. Fifth, counting strategies as if more labels meant a higher score, when the rubric rewards precision and insight.

Key takeaways

Use the rubric during drafting, not just at the end. A rhetorical analysis is judged on critical language awareness, clarity and coherence, and rhetorical choices, usually across five levels that differ mainly in consistency. Check sentences for mixed constructions and make any break with convention deliberate. Use a reverse outline to test focus and order, and back every claim with evidence. Name strategies precisely and explain their effect on the audience in a consistent analytical voice. Give and use feedback that is specific and tied to a criterion, fixing big problems first.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Rubric

A set of criteria and performance levels used to judge writing

Use it while drafting, not only at the end.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A draft names ethos, pathos and logos correctly in every paragraph but never explains how they affect the audience. Which criterion most needs work?

Question 2 of 5

What is a reverse outline mainly used for when evaluating a draft?

Question 3 of 5

According to the reading, what mainly separates the five rubric levels?

Question 4 of 5

Which peer review comment is most useful?

Question 5 of 5

Midway through an analytical essay, a student writes, "lol, the writer totally fails here." Which part of the rubric does this hurt most?

← Previous topicNext topic →