English Composition › Section I · Rhetorical analysis › Topic I.2

Writing a rhetorical analysis

Naming ethos, pathos and logos is only the start. A rhetorical analysis essay makes an argument of its own: a reasoned judgement about how, and how well, another writer persuades a particular audience.

Analysing the how, not the what

A typical assignment asks you to choose a persuasive text, such as an editorial, a review, a speech or a letter to the editor, and explain the strategies its writer uses. Your job is not to agree or disagree with the writer's position. It is to show how the writer tries to persuade, and to judge how well those choices work for the intended audience. You might oppose a columnist's view and still find her argument skilfully built. That detachment is what makes an analysis convincing.

Map the rhetorical situation

Before judging any strategy, work out the conditions it was designed for. Ask about the subject: what exactly is the text about? The writer: who are they, what qualifies them, and do they have an agenda? The audience: who was meant to read it, and were those readers likely to be neutral, sympathetic or hostile? The purpose: what does the writer want readers to believe or do? The context: when and where did it appear, and what was happening at the time? The culture: which shared values and customs could the writer count on? A strategy is only effective or ineffective relative to these answers.

Read more than once, pen in hand

Read the text once for its main claim. Then reread slowly and annotate: underline claims, mark evidence, label appeals and devices in the margin, and note where the tone shifts. Many writers keep a strategy log, a simple table with three columns: the strategy, where it appears, and its effect on the argument. You do not need to log every device in the text. Choose the strategies that carry the central argument, plus any that seem misleading. Finally, ask what the writer left out, because a missing counterargument or source can matter as much as what is there.

Summary versus analysis

A summary restates a text's main points briefly and neutrally, in your own words. An analysis explains the writer's choices and their effects. "The writer argues that the town needs a skate park" is summary. "By calling the empty car park 'wasted ground', the writer makes the proposal feel like a rescue rather than a cost" is analysis. Most rhetorical analyses include a short summary near the start so readers know what the text says. After that, every paragraph should be doing analysis; retelling the text in order is a common reason drafts fall short.

A thesis about effectiveness

The thesis of a rhetorical analysis is a claim about how effectively the writer uses rhetoric to achieve a purpose with an audience. It is not a claim about the issue itself, and it is not an announcement such as "This essay will analyse the letter." A good thesis names the main strategies and gives a verdict, and the verdict can be mixed. Two useful frames are "The writer succeeds in ___ because ___" and "The writer succeeds in ___ but not in ___." Readers should finish your introduction knowing exactly what you will prove.

Worked example: sharpening a thesis

The text is a fictional op-ed by a headteacher, Dana Ruiz, urging parents to support a ban on phones in lessons. 1. Draft: "Phones should be banned in lessons." This argues about the issue, not the rhetoric. 2. Draft: "This essay will look at the rhetoric of Ruiz's op-ed." This announces a topic but makes no claim. 3. Draft: "Ruiz uses ethos and logos." This labels strategies without a verdict. 4. Final: "Ruiz wins over undecided parents by pairing her twenty years in classrooms with her school's own test data, but her closing claim that phones 'destroy childhood' overreaches and risks losing the sceptics she most needs." 5. Check: it names strategies, an audience and a mixed, arguable verdict.

Introduction and organisation

An introduction can open with a brief anecdote, then give the writer's name and relevant qualifications, the title and genre of the text, the writer's main claim ("Ruiz argues that..."), and any context readers need, before ending on your thesis. For the body, two structures are common. You can follow the text from beginning to end, analysing each section in turn, or organise by strategy, giving each main appeal or device its own paragraph. Many writers open with the writer's strongest move. A full essay often has four or more body paragraphs.

Building an analytical paragraph

Each body paragraph makes one point about the writer's rhetoric. Open with a topic sentence that names a strategy and its effect. Give the evidence: a short quotation or a precise paraphrase, with its location in the text. Then explain how that wording works on this audience, which is where most of your sentences should go. Evaluate whether the move succeeds and why. Finally, link the point back to your thesis or forward to the next paragraph.

Worked example: an analytical paragraph

Model paragraph: "Ruiz's most persuasive move is to make her evidence local. Rather than citing national studies, she reports that maths scores at her own school rose after a one-term trial in which phones were collected at the door. For parents, this turns an abstract debate into a story about their own children's classrooms. Yet the paragraph never mentions whether anything else changed that term, so a careful reader may wonder whether the phones deserve the credit." Analysis: 1. The topic sentence names a strategy and judges it. 2. The evidence is paraphrased precisely. 3. The third sentence explains the effect on the audience. 4. The final sentence evaluates and finds a limit, which supports the mixed thesis.

Conclusion, peer review and revision

The conclusion confirms your evaluation, often restating the thesis in fresh words, and adds no new points. It may raise a question the text leaves open. In peer review, a reader should identify your main claim, check that the major appeals and any fallacies are explained, and note whether you discuss how the writer handles counterarguments. Comment on others' drafts tactfully, as you would want them to comment on yours. When revising, fix the big picture first, the thesis and the order of paragraphs, before polishing sentences, or small edits may be wasted.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, arguing about the issue instead of the rhetoric: your view on phones in lessons is not the subject. Second, retelling the text in order and calling it analysis. Third, listing appeals without explaining their effect on the audience. Fourth, dropping in quotations with no explanation after them. Fifth, ignoring the rhetorical situation, so that a strategy is praised or criticised without asking who it was aimed at. Sixth, stating a thesis with no verdict, such as "the writer uses many strategies".

Key takeaways

A rhetorical analysis argues about how, and how well, a writer persuades an audience, not about the issue itself. Start by mapping the rhetorical situation, then reread and annotate, keeping a log of key strategies. Keep summary brief; analysis explains choices and effects. The thesis names strategies and gives a verdict, which may be mixed. Organise by the text's order or by strategy, and build each paragraph from a claim, evidence, explanation of effect, evaluation and a link. Conclude by confirming your judgement, and revise the big picture before the sentences.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Rhetorical analysis essay

An argument about how, and how well, a text persuades its audience

Not about whether you agree with the writer.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which is the best thesis for a rhetorical analysis of an op-ed arguing for a four-day school week?

Question 2 of 5

Which sentence is analysis rather than summary?

Question 3 of 5

A student's draft spends three paragraphs retelling an editorial's points in order. What is the most useful revision advice?

Question 4 of 5

According to the reading, what should you revise first in a rhetorical analysis draft?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these belongs in the introduction of a rhetorical analysis?

← Previous topicNext topic →