English Composition › Section I · Rhetorical analysis › Topic I.3

Editing focus: mixed sentence constructions

Some sentences start down one grammatical road and finish on another. Learning to spot these mixed constructions, and to rebuild them, keeps a sharp analysis from being blurred by sentences that do not hold together.

When a sentence changes direction

A mixed construction is a sentence whose parts do not fit together, either grammatically or logically. It happens when a writer begins with one structure and, partway through, switches to another, often while drafting fast or after revising only half a sentence. Each half may make sense alone, but the joint fails, and readers stall trying to work out who is doing what. In a rhetorical analysis, that can make a good point sound confused. The cure is not a comma: it is rebuilding one half to match the other.

A phrase posing as a subject

A prepositional phrase, a group beginning with a word such as by, for or in, cannot be the subject of a sentence. Yet writers often treat it as one. "By practising every evening improved her timing" has no real subject: who or what improved? There are two fixes. Drop the preposition so the -ing phrase becomes the subject: "Practising every evening improved her timing." Or keep the phrase and add a subject: "By practising every evening, she improved her timing." Similarly, in "In the survey of commuters showed long delays", the in phrase cannot be the subject; write "The survey of commuters showed long delays."

Doubled subjects and shifting people

Another grammatical mix adds a pronoun that repeats a subject already in place. In "The editorial's final paragraph it repeats the opening question", the word it collides with the subject already in place; delete it. A related problem is switching who the sentence is about halfway through: "Volunteering at the food bank teaches patience, and you meet people from all over town." The first clause is about an activity, the second about the reader. Keep one focus: "Volunteering at the food bank teaches patience and introduces volunteers to people from all over town."

Faulty predication

Sometimes the grammar is fine but the subject and predicate do not make sense together. This is faulty predication. With a linking verb such as is, whatever follows must rename or describe the subject. "The main cost of the trip is the drivers we hire" claims that a cost is a group of people, which it cannot be. Revise to "The main cost of the trip is the drivers' wages" or "Hiring drivers is the trip's main cost." An appositive can mismatch in the same way: "Our new captain, a decision made by the coach, has lifted morale" calls a person a decision; "The choice of a new captain, a decision made by the coach, has lifted morale" makes the two fit.

Is when, is where and the reason is because

Definitions written with is when or is where are a common form of faulty predication. "Burnout is when you feel exhausted by work" makes burnout a time; "Burnout is exhaustion caused by prolonged stress at work" makes it a condition. "A thesis is where you state your claim" makes a sentence a place; "A thesis is the sentence that states your claim" fixes it. The phrase the reason is because says the same thing twice, since because already means for the reason that. Write "The reason is that..." or simply use because on its own.

Just because... doesn't mean

"Just because a source is online doesn't mean it is unreliable" is common and natural in speech. In it, though, a because clause, which normally modifies a verb, acts as the subject of doesn't mean, a role formal grammar does not normally give it, and many teachers and editors ask writers to rephrase it in academic work. Two clean versions: "A source is not unreliable simply because it is online" and "Being online does not make a source unreliable." Each has a clear subject and a verb that fits it.

A three-step repair method

When a sentence feels tangled, work through it in order. 1. Find the subject and main verb: who or what is doing what? If you cannot find a subject, or you find two competing ones, you have located the problem. 2. Decide which half of the sentence says what you mean, and keep it. 3. Rebuild the other half to fit, then read the whole sentence aloud. There are usually two good fixes; choose the one that keeps your emphasis.

Worked example: four repairs

1. "By repeating the word 'together' creates a sense of unity." No subject; drop By: "Repeating the word 'together' creates a sense of unity." 2. "The danger of the ad is children who copy the stunt." Children are not a danger in this sense; the copying is: "The danger of the ad is that children may copy the stunt." 3. "Satire is when a writer mocks something to criticise it." Is when; give a category: "Satire is humour that mocks its target in order to criticise it." 4. "The reason the poster works is because it is short." Redundant; write "The poster works because it is short." Check: each revision has one clear subject that its verb fits.

Watch for these in analysis

Rhetorical analysis invites a few mixed constructions in particular. Writers reach for "By using pathos makes readers sympathise", where the fix is "By using pathos, the writer makes readers sympathise" or "The use of pathos makes readers sympathise." They write "The effect of the repetition is when readers remember the slogan", which should become "The effect of the repetition is that readers remember the slogan." And they explain with "The reason the speech succeeds is because...", which should drop either the reason is or because. Scan your draft for by, for, is when and is because.

Worked example: editing a paragraph

Draft: "By opening with a story about a lost dog grabs the reader's attention. Pathos is when the writer makes readers feel concern, and you want to keep reading. The reason the opening works is because it is so specific." Revision: "By opening with a story about a lost dog, the writer grabs the reader's attention. This appeal to pathos makes readers feel concern and want to keep reading. The opening works because it is so specific." Analysis: 1. Sentence one gained a subject, the writer. 2. Sentence two lost its is when definition and its shift to you. 3. Sentence three dropped the doubled reason. 4. Every analytical point survived the edit.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, adding a comma and hoping: "By practising every evening, improved her timing" is still missing a subject. Second, fixing one half and breaking the other, so always reread the whole sentence. Third, deleting the meaning along with the error; the revision should say everything the draft meant. Fourth, banning is when everywhere: "The best time to revise is when the draft has rested" is correct, because its subject really is a time. Fifth, assuming a long sentence must be mixed; length is not the problem, mismatched parts are.

Key takeaways

A mixed construction joins parts that do not fit grammatically or logically. A prepositional phrase cannot serve as a subject, and a sentence should not add a second subject or switch whom it is about. Faulty predication pairs a subject with a predicate that cannot apply to it, as in definitions using is when or is where. Prefer "the reason is that" or plain because, and rephrase just because... doesn't mean in formal writing. To repair, find the subject and verb, keep the half that says what you mean, and rebuild the other half.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Mixed construction

A sentence whose parts do not fit together grammatically or logically

It starts one way and finishes another.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which revision correctly fixes "By studying the speech closely revealed several hidden appeals"?

Question 2 of 5

Which sentence contains faulty predication?

Question 3 of 5

Which is the best revision of "Hyperbole is when a writer exaggerates for effect"?

Question 4 of 5

In which sentence is the phrase "is when" acceptable?

Question 5 of 5

What is wrong with "For readers who skim, they may miss the writer's main claim"?

← Previous topicNext topic →