Macroeconomics › Section R · The impacts of government borrowing › Topic R.1
Government borrowing, investment, and crowding out
A government whose spending outruns its tax revenue must borrow, and the money has to come from somewhere. Following where it comes from shows why large deficits can squeeze private investment, and why that squeeze is much stronger in some years than others.
Where the money comes from
In fiscal year 2026 the US federal government ran a deficit of about $2.0 trillion, or about 6% of GDP, according to the Congressional Budget Office, and federal debt held by the public reached roughly 100% of GDP. Every dollar of that deficit was borrowed, mostly by selling Treasury bonds. From the point of view of the whole economy, there are only three possible sources for such funds. Households and firms might save more. Firms might borrow less for investment, leaving the funds for the government. Or foreign investors might lend more. This topic builds the framework that says one of these must happen, and then looks closely at the second.
The identity behind it
In the financial capital market, the quantity of funds supplied must equal the quantity demanded. Funds are supplied by private saving \(S\) and by the inflow of foreign capital, which equals the trade deficit \(M - X\). They are demanded by private investment \(I\) and by government borrowing, the budget deficit \(G - T\), where \(T\) is net taxes. So
This is the identity met in the topic "The national saving and investment identity". It always holds. If one term changes, at least one other term must change to keep the two sides equal.
Surpluses switch sides
The identity looks different when signs change, though the logic does not. A government running a budget surplus, as the US did from 1998 to 2001, is a saver, so \(T - G\) joins private saving on the supply side. A country running a trade surplus is sending capital abroad, so \(X - M\) becomes a use of funds on the demand side, alongside investment. Before calculating, ask of each item: does it supply funds to the market, or take funds from it? Writing the identity with every term positive, on its correct side, avoids most sign errors.
Worked example: using the identity
A hypothetical economy has private saving of 4,000, investment of 3,800 and a budget deficit of 600, in billions of dollars. 1. Rearrange: \(M - X = I + (G - T) - S\). 2. Substitute: \(3{,}800 + 600 - 4{,}000 = 400\), so the trade deficit is 400. 3. Now the deficit rises to 1,000. If saving and investment stay the same, the trade deficit must rise to \(3{,}800 + 1{,}000 - 4{,}000 = 800\). 4. If instead saving and the trade deficit stay the same, investment must fall: \(I = 4{,}000 + 400 - 1{,}000 = 3{,}400\). 5. Check: in each case both sides of the identity are equal.
Three possible responses
The example shows the general rule. A larger budget deficit must be matched by some mix of three changes: private investment falls, private saving rises, or the trade deficit widens as foreign capital flows in. A smaller deficit, or a surplus, works in reverse. The identity does not say which mix will occur; that depends on how households, firms, foreign investors and the central bank behave. The next topics take up the trade deficit and private saving. This topic concentrates on the first response, a fall in private investment, which economists call crowding out.
The interest-rate channel
Crowding out works mainly through interest rates. Picture the market for financial capital, with the interest rate on the vertical axis. Government borrowing adds to demand for funds, shifting the demand curve to the right. With supply unchanged, the equilibrium interest rate rises, say from 4% to 5%. Some business projects that were worth doing at 4%, such as a new warehouse or software system, no longer pay at 5%, so firms drop them. Interest-sensitive household spending, such as house building, falls too. Studies disagree about how much a given deficit raises US rates, but the direction of the effect is not in doubt.
Why crowding out can matter for growth
Gross private investment includes spending that only replaces worn-out or obsolete equipment. Suppose, hypothetically, that gross investment is 18% of GDP and half of it is replacement, so net additions to the capital stock are 9% of GDP. A deficit of 4% of GDP that came entirely out of investment would remove \(4 \div 9\), about 44%, of the economy's new capital each year. In reality saving and foreign inflows absorb part of the deficit, so the effect is smaller. But the arithmetic shows why sustained large deficits worry economists: less new capital means slower growth in productivity and wages.
It depends on the economy
How much crowding out happens depends on the state of the economy and on the central bank. Near full employment, extra government borrowing competes for scarce funds, and if the central bank raises rates to stop inflation, the squeeze on investment grows. In a deep recession, firms have little appetite for investment anyway and saving is high, so a deficit takes little from them. If the central bank holds rates near zero, as the Federal Reserve did after 2008 and in 2020, crowding out may be very small. Stimulus that lifts sales can even encourage some firms to invest more.
Worked example: multipliers in two settings
The fiscal multiplier is the change in GDP for each dollar of extra government spending. Suppose, hypothetically, that a government spends an extra $40 billion. 1. In a deep slump with idle resources and interest rates held near zero, there is little crowding out. With a multiplier of 1.5, GDP rises by \(40 \times 1.5 = 60\) billion dollars. 2. Near full employment, with the central bank raising rates, private spending is pushed aside. With a multiplier of 0.5, GDP rises by only \(40 \times 0.5 = 20\) billion dollars. 3. Check the logic: the same spending does three times as much in the slump, because less private activity is displaced.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, putting a budget surplus or a trade surplus on the wrong side of the identity; ask whether each item supplies funds or uses them. Second, assuming a deficit must reduce investment one for one; saving and foreign inflows can absorb part of it. Third, believing a central bank can cancel the identity; it can only influence which of the three responses occurs. Fourth, treating crowding out as equally strong at all times; it is usually small in a deep recession with low rates. Fifth, confusing gross investment with net additions to capital.
Key takeaways
The national saving and investment identity, \(S + (M - X) = I + (G - T)\), always holds. A larger budget deficit must be met by lower private investment, higher private saving, a larger trade deficit, or a mix. Crowding out is the fall in private investment, working mainly through higher interest rates. It matters for growth because net investment is a small share of GDP. It is largest near full employment, especially if the central bank tightens, and smallest in a deep slump with low rates, which is also when fiscal multipliers are largest.
Flashcards
Flashcard
About $2.0 trillion, about 6% of GDP
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Private saving is 900, investment is 800 and the budget deficit is 300. What trade balance does the saving and investment identity imply?
Question 2 of 5
What do economists mean by crowding out?
Question 3 of 5
In which situation is a larger budget deficit likely to crowd out the least private investment?
Question 4 of 5
Near full employment, with the central bank raising rates, a government spends an extra $60 billion. If the multiplier is 0.5, by how much does GDP rise?
Question 5 of 5
The budget deficit rises by $100 billion. Private saving and the trade balance do not change. What must happen?
