Macroeconomics › Section R · The impacts of government borrowing › Topic R.2
Fiscal policy and the trade balance
A government that borrows heavily can end up importing more than it exports, as foreign savings flow in to fund the gap. The link runs through spending, interest rates and the exchange rate, and when the inflow turns into an outflow it can end in crisis.
From one deficit to another
The previous topic set out the identity \(S + (M - X) = I + (G - T)\) and showed that a larger budget deficit must be matched by lower investment, higher private saving, a larger trade deficit, or some mix. This topic follows the third route. If private saving and investment barely change, then extra government borrowing has to be financed from abroad, and the inflow of foreign capital is, by definition, a larger trade deficit. Two economic channels make this happen in practice: higher spending on imports, and a stronger currency. Both are worth tracing step by step.
The spending channel
A budget deficit created by tax cuts or extra spending raises aggregate demand. Households and firms with more income buy more of everything, including imported goods and services, and the government itself may buy some goods from abroad. With exports unchanged, a rise in imports widens the trade deficit. The foreign sellers now hold extra dollars. Many of them, or the people they sell the dollars to, invest those dollars in US assets, often in the Treasury bonds the government is selling to fund its deficit. In this way the dollars spent on imports return as the foreign lending that finances the budget deficit.
The exchange-rate channel
Government borrowing also raises interest rates, as the previous topic showed. Higher US rates attract foreign investors, who demand more dollars to buy US bonds, while Americans keep more money at home and supply fewer dollars. Demand for dollars shifts right and supply shifts left, exactly as in the topic "Demand and supply shifts in currency markets", so the dollar appreciates. A stronger dollar makes US exports dearer abroad and imports cheaper at home, so net exports fall. The spending, interest-rate and currency stories are different ways of describing one chain: bigger budget deficit, capital inflow, stronger currency, bigger trade deficit.
Worked example: the currency effect
Suppose, hypothetically, that daily demand for dollars is \(Q_d = 160 - 100e\) and supply is \(Q_s = 40 + 100e\), in billions of dollars, with \(e\) in euros per dollar. 1. Equilibrium: \(160 - 100e = 40 + 100e\), so \(e = 0.60\) and 100 billion dollars trade. 2. A larger US deficit draws European investors: demand rises by 10 to \(170 - 100e\) and supply falls by 10 to \(30 + 100e\). 3. New equilibrium: \(e = 0.70\), with 100 billion still traded. 4. A US good priced at $50 now costs a European \(50 \times 0.70 = 35\) euros instead of 30. 5. Check: the dollar rose about 17%, so US exports become harder to sell.
Twin deficits, but not always
In the mid-1980s the US budget deficit and trade deficit both grew sharply, and commentators called them the twin deficits. Later experience shows they need not move together, because saving and investment change too. In the late 1990s the federal budget swung into surplus, yet the trade deficit grew: a boom in business investment, much of it in technology, was drawing in foreign capital. In 2009 the opposite happened: the budget deficit soared while the trade deficit shrank, because private investment collapsed and households saved more in the recession. The two deficits are related, but the link is loose.
Worked example: cutting the budget deficit
A hypothetical economy has private saving of 3,000, investment of 3,200 and a budget deficit of 500, in billions of dollars. 1. Trade deficit: \(M - X = 3{,}200 + 500 - 3{,}000 = 700\). 2. The government cuts its deficit by 300, to 200. 3. Suppose households respond by saving 100 less, so \(S = 2{,}900\), while investment stays at 3,200. 4. New trade deficit: \(3{,}200 + 200 - 2{,}900 = 500\). 5. Check: the budget deficit fell by 300 but the trade deficit fell by only 200, because saving changed too. Reducing a budget deficit narrows a trade deficit only partly unless saving and investment hold still.
When inflows become dangerous
A moderate budget deficit with a moderate trade deficit and a somewhat stronger currency is not, in itself, a cause for alarm. The danger grows when large deficits are financed year after year by short-term foreign portfolio investment in government bonds, which can be sold in seconds. Bad news can then trigger a sudden outflow: the currency plunges, banks with foreign-currency debts fail, as the topic "Macroeconomic effects of exchange rates" showed, and a deep recession follows. Heavy short-term foreign borrowing preceded crises in Mexico in 1994 to 1995, Russia in 1998 and Argentina in 2001 to 2002. Large budget deficits played a big part in Russia and Argentina; in Mexico the weak point was short-term government debt linked to the dollar.
Inflation and default fears
Very large deficits raise two further worries for foreign investors. First, they may push aggregate demand so far beyond potential output that inflation takes off, eroding the real value of bonds. Second, investors may start to doubt that the government will repay in full, or fear it will let inflation shrink its debts. Argentina, for example, has defaulted on its government debt several times, most recently in 2020. Either fear lowers the expected return, so investors demand higher interest rates or leave. The US borrows in its own currency, the world's main reserve currency, which makes it less exposed, though not immune.
Using fiscal policy on a trade deficit
A trade deficit financed by long-term foreign direct investment in factories and firms is rarely a worry; it brings capital, skills and jobs. The concern is a deficit financed by short-term loans to a government. When the budget deficit really is the main cause of a trade deficit, reducing it is the most direct fix, since it lowers the need for foreign borrowing. But as the worked example showed, other terms in the identity can move instead. A later topic, "The trade-offs of trade policy", reaches a related conclusion: tariffs are a weak tool for a trade deficit, which mirrors saving minus investment.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, expecting the budget and trade deficits to move one for one; saving and investment change too. Second, reversing the currency effect: a deficit financed from abroad tends to strengthen the currency, not weaken it, until confidence breaks. Third, treating all foreign inflows alike; direct investment is far more stable than short-term lending to a government. Fourth, assuming any trade deficit signals danger, when a moderate one funding productive investment may be healthy. Fifth, forgetting that very large deficits can raise inflation and default fears that reverse the inflow.
Key takeaways
A larger budget deficit can widen the trade deficit through higher spending on imports and through higher interest rates that attract foreign capital and strengthen the currency. The twin deficits of the 1980s showed the link, but the late 1990s and 2009 showed it is loose, because saving and investment also move. Moderate deficits are manageable. Sustained large deficits funded by short-term portfolio inflows risk a sudden outflow, a currency collapse, bank failures and recession, and can stoke inflation and default fears.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Foreign capital funds the borrowing, so M − X rises
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A larger US budget deficit is financed mainly by foreign investors buying Treasury bonds. What is the most likely chain of effects?
Question 2 of 5
Private saving is 2,000, investment is 2,100 and the budget deficit is 400. The deficit is cut to 100, with saving and investment unchanged. What is the new trade deficit?
Question 3 of 5
In the late 1990s the US budget moved into surplus, yet the trade deficit grew. Which change best explains this?
Question 4 of 5
Which way of financing a country's budget and trade deficits carries the greatest risk of a sudden crisis?
Question 5 of 5
A larger deficit raises the dollar from 0.60 to 0.70 euros. A US product is priced at $50. What happens to its price in euros?
