Macroeconomics › Section O · Monetary policy and bank regulation › Topic O.3

Financial regulation and the future of money

After 2008, governments rewrote the rules for big banks, and the bank failures of 2023 tested them. Meanwhile apps, cryptocurrencies, stablecoins and central bank digital currencies are changing what money looks like. This topic covers both, with facts dated to late 2026.

Too big to fail

One lesson of 2008 was that some firms are so large and so connected to others that governments feel unable to let them collapse; they are too big to fail. That creates moral hazard on a grand scale. If lenders expect a rescue, they lend to these firms cheaply whatever risks they run, so the firms gain an edge and an incentive to grow and take more risk. The post-2008 reforms tried to make such firms safer and to make it possible for even a giant to fail without a taxpayer bailout.

The post-2008 rulebook

Internationally, the Basel III standards, agreed in 2010, raised the quality and quantity of capital banks must hold and added liquidity rules requiring enough cash-like assets to survive a month of heavy outflows. In the US, the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 created the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and a council of regulators to watch system-wide risks. It required annual stress tests of large banks, living wills setting out how each could be wound down in an orderly way, and the Volcker Rule limiting banks' trading for their own profit. Many derivatives were moved onto central clearing houses. Debate continues over whether these rules are too strict or too loose.

Worked example: a stress test

Regulators ask whether a bank could survive a severe recession. Suppose a bank has $1,000 billion of assets and $100 billion of capital, and must keep capital of at least 5% of assets in the test. 1. Starting ratio: \(\frac{100}{1{,}000} = 10\%\). 2. The severe scenario produces losses of 6% of assets, \(0.06 \times 1{,}000 = 60\) billion. 3. Capital falls to \(100 - 60 = 40\) billion, and assets to $940 billion. 4. New ratio: \(\frac{40}{940} \approx 4.3\%\), below the 5% minimum. 5. Result: the bank fails the test and must raise capital or cut dividends now, while times are good, rather than discover the gap in a crisis.

2023: the rules tested

In March 2023 Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank failed within days, and First Republic Bank followed in May. All three were mid-sized banks with many large, uninsured deposits; SVB had also lost heavily on bonds as interest rates rose. To stop the panic spreading, regulators guaranteed all deposits at SVB and Signature, and the Fed opened a temporary lending programme for banks. The Fed's own review faulted both the bank's management and its supervisors, and noted that a 2018 law had eased some rules for banks of SVB's size. Some conclude that rules must also cover mid-sized banks; others, that supervisors had the tools but were slow to use them.

Consumer protection and inclusion

Finance is also regulated to protect ordinary customers, who face complex products and powerful lenders. US law requires lenders to state the annual percentage rate, or APR, which includes most fees, so borrowers can compare loans fairly, and bans many unfair practices. Inclusion matters too. The World Bank's Global Findex 2025 report found that 79% of adults worldwide had an account in 2024, leaving roughly 1.3 billion without one. Mobile money has helped: Kenya's M-Pesa, launched in 2007, lets people send and save money by phone, and studies have linked its spread to lower poverty.

Fintech and instant payments

Financial technology, or fintech, firms offer payments, lending and investing through apps, both competing and partnering with banks. Public instant-payment systems have spread fastest. India's UPI, launched in 2016, and Brazil's Pix, launched by its central bank in 2020, let people pay each other or a shop in seconds, usually free of charge, using a phone number or a code. In the US, the Fed's FedNow service, launched in 2023, offers banks a similar instant-payment network. These systems make deposits move faster, but the money moved is still ordinary bank money.

Cryptocurrencies

Bitcoin, launched in 2009, was the first cryptocurrency: a digital asset recorded on a blockchain, a shared ledger maintained by a decentralised network rather than a bank or government, with a supply capped at 21 million coins. Thousands of others followed. Supporters value their independence from governments and banks. Critics point to large price swings, energy use, fraud and use in crime. Prices are very volatile: bitcoin peaked at about $69,000 in November 2021 and fell below $16,000 a year later. The collapse of the crypto exchange FTX in November 2022 froze billions of dollars of customer funds, and its founder was later convicted of fraud. Few shops accept it, so it serves more as a speculative investment than as money.

Worked example: crypto as a unit of account

A café prices a $48 meal in bitcoin when one bitcoin trades at $60,000. 1. Price in bitcoin: \(\frac{48}{60{,}000} = 0.0008\) bitcoin. 2. Over a few weeks the bitcoin price falls 20%, to $48,000. 3. To keep receiving the same dollar value, the café must now charge \(\frac{48}{48{,}000} = 0.001\) bitcoin. 4. The price in bitcoin has risen 25% though nothing about the meal changed. 5. Interpret: a good unit of account keeps prices steady, but here the café must keep repricing, and in practice it is still thinking in dollars. A volatile asset makes a poor unit of account.

Stablecoins

Stablecoins are crypto tokens designed to hold a steady value, usually one US dollar, by keeping reserve assets such as cash and Treasury bills. Their total value grew to a little over $300 billion by mid-2026, used mainly for trading crypto and for cross-border transfers. The risk is a run: if holders doubt the reserves, all try to redeem at once. In July 2025 the US passed the GENIUS Act, which requires payment stablecoins to be backed one for one by safe, liquid assets, with regular public disclosure of reserves. The OCC issued its final implementing rule in October 2026, and the Act takes effect on 18 January 2027.

Central bank digital currencies

A central bank digital currency, or CBDC, would be a digital form of cash issued directly by the central bank, unlike a bank deposit. By 2026 well over 100 countries were researching or testing one, but only a few, such as the Bahamas in 2020, Nigeria in 2021 and Jamaica in 2022, had launched one for public use. China has run large pilots of its digital renminbi. The European Central Bank plans a pilot in 2027 and a possible first issuance in 2029, if EU legislation is adopted. The US took the opposite path: a January 2025 executive order bars federal agencies from issuing or promoting a CBDC. Supporters cite cheaper, safer payments; critics cite privacy and the risk that deposits flee from banks.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking post-2008 rules ended bank failures: 2023 showed otherwise. Second, assuming deposit guarantees beyond the $250,000 limit are automatic; in 2023 they required special decisions. Third, calling a stablecoin a deposit: it is not FDIC-insured. Fourth, treating a CBDC as the same as a stablecoin or bitcoin: a CBDC would be a liability of the central bank. Fifth, assuming apps like Pix or FedNow create new money; they move existing bank money faster. Sixth, presenting crypto prices or adoption figures without a date: they change quickly.

Key takeaways

Too-big-to-fail firms create moral hazard. After 2008, Basel III and the Dodd-Frank Act raised capital and liquidity requirements and introduced stress tests, living wills and the Volcker Rule. Disclosure rules such as the APR protect consumers, and mobile money and instant payments widen inclusion. Cryptocurrencies are volatile and rarely used as money. Stablecoins, regulated in the US by the GENIUS Act from 2027, carry run risk. CBDCs are advancing in some places, such as the euro area, while a 2025 executive order bars US federal agencies from issuing one.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Too big to fail

Firms governments feel unable to let collapse

Creates moral hazard and cheap funding.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A bank has $400 billion of assets and $36 billion of capital. A stress scenario causes losses of $12 billion. What is its capital ratio after the losses?

Question 2 of 5

Why does being too big to fail create moral hazard?

Question 3 of 5

A shop prices a $30 item in bitcoin at 0.0005 bitcoin. The bitcoin price then rises 25%. To receive the same dollar value, what must the shop now charge?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about a central bank digital currency is correct?

Question 5 of 5

What does the US GENIUS Act of 2025 require of payment stablecoins?

← Previous topicNext topic →