Macroeconomics › Section R · The impacts of government borrowing › Topic R.4
Fiscal policy, investment, and growth
Long-run growth rests on more and better machines, more skilled workers and new ideas. Government budgets touch all three: heavy borrowing can squeeze private investment, while well-chosen public spending on infrastructure, education and research can raise the economy's potential.
Two ways budgets shape growth
The topic "The components of economic growth" showed that output per worker rises with physical capital, human capital and technology. Fiscal policy affects each of them in two opposite ways. On the cost side, the topic "Government borrowing, investment, and crowding out" showed that sustained deficits can absorb saving that would otherwise fund private factories, equipment and software, leaving a smaller capital stock and lower future output. On the benefit side, governments pay for much of a country's roads, schools and basic research, which private markets tend to underprovide. Good fiscal policy for growth limits the first effect and makes the most of the second.
Public physical capital
Governments build and maintain highways, bridges, ports, airports, water and sewer systems, power grids and, increasingly, broadband networks. These raise the productivity of private firms: a reliable road cuts delivery times, and clean water keeps workers healthy. In the US, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021 authorised about $1.2 trillion, including roughly $550 billion of new federal spending. Public projects lack the discipline of profit and loss, though. Some are chosen for political reasons, some run far over budget, and maintenance is often neglected because ribbon-cutting is more popular than repairing pipes.
How the project is paid for
Financing matters as much as the project. A road paid for with higher taxes or cuts elsewhere does not directly compete with private borrowers, though higher taxes may reduce private saving a little. A road paid for by borrowing adds to the deficit and may crowd out private investment. That is worthwhile only if the public project earns a higher return for society than the private investment it displaces. A useful rule is to ask two questions of every borrowed project: does its social return exceed the interest cost, and does it beat the private projects that would otherwise have been funded?
Worked example: is a bridge worth borrowing for?
A city can build a bridge for $200 million, borrowed at 4%. Suppose, hypothetically, that the bridge saves drivers and firms $14 million a year in time and fuel, and costs nothing to run. 1. Annual interest: \(200 \times 0.04 = 8\) million dollars. 2. Net gain: \(14 - 8 = 6\) million dollars a year, so the bridge passes the first test. 3. Now suppose the borrowing crowds out $200 million of private investment that would have earned 10%: \(200 \times 0.10 = 20\) million dollars a year. 4. The bridge's $14 million is less than that $20 million, so it fails the second test. 5. Check: a project can beat its interest cost and still be a poor use of scarce saving.
Investing in people
Most countries fund schooling through taxes, and education raises human capital, the skills and knowledge workers bring to their jobs. For low-income countries, getting more children through primary and secondary school is among the surest routes to higher productivity. In high-income countries the debate is less about how much to spend than about results: US spending per pupil has risen a great deal over recent decades while test scores have improved only modestly. Researchers therefore study incentives, teacher quality and early education. Head Start, created in 1965, funds pre-school programmes for children from low-income families.
Paying for new ideas
Private firms underinvest in research because they capture only part of its benefits: once an idea is known, others can copy and build on it. These spillovers give governments a reason to support research and development (R&D). They can fund it directly, through agencies such as the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation, which pay for much of the basic science done at universities. They can also offer tax incentives; the US research tax credit dates from 1981. Defence research sometimes produces civilian breakthroughs, such as early work on GPS, but research aimed at civilian problems is generally thought to spill over into the wider economy more directly.
Supply-side tax policy
Taxes affect incentives to work, save and invest. Lower marginal tax rates, the rates on an extra dollar of income, can encourage more of each, and tax breaks for investment can lift business spending on equipment. Economists agree these effects exist but disagree about their size. Claims that tax cuts pay for themselves through faster growth are generally not supported. In 2018 the Congressional Budget Office estimated that faster growth would offset only about a fifth of the cost of the 2017 tax law over ten years. A tax cut financed by borrowing can also crowd out investment, working against its own goal.
Worked example: why small growth gains matter
Two hypothetical economies start the same size. One grows at 2.0% a year, the other at 2.2%, perhaps thanks to better infrastructure and research. 1. After 30 years the first is \(1.02^{30} \approx 1.81\) times its starting size. 2. The second is \(1.022^{30} \approx 1.92\) times as large. 3. The ratio is \(1.92 \div 1.81 \approx 1.06\), so the faster economy is about 6% larger. 4. Check: 0.2 percentage points looks tiny in one year, but compounding turns it into a gap of about 6% of output. Growth policy works slowly, but its effects add up.
Deficit cuts, rules and growth
Because deficits can crowd out investment, many governments adopt fiscal rules. The EU, for example, uses reference values of a 3% of GDP deficit and 60% of GDP debt, with an escape clause it used during the pandemic. Timing matters, though. Cutting deficits sharply in a slump can deepen it: after 2010 several European governments imposed austerity, and a 2013 IMF study by Olivier Blanchard and Daniel Leigh found that forecasters had underestimated how much these cuts would reduce output. The usual lesson is to reduce deficits when the economy is strong, and to protect high-return public investment when doing so.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating all government spending as investment; transfers and day-to-day spending do not add to the capital stock. Second, judging a borrowed project only against its interest cost, ignoring the private investment it may displace. Third, assuming more education spending automatically means better education; how it is spent matters. Fourth, believing tax cuts pay for themselves; evidence suggests growth offsets only part of the cost. Fifth, assuming deficit cuts always help growth; sharp austerity in a slump can lower output, as Europe found after 2010.
Key takeaways
Growth comes from physical capital, human capital and technology, and fiscal policy affects all three. Sustained deficits can crowd out private investment and slow growth. Public spending on infrastructure, education and research can raise growth, if projects are well chosen, well managed and earn more than the private investment they displace. Supply-side tax cuts have real but limited effects and rarely pay for themselves. Small changes in growth compound into large differences over decades. Fiscal rules restrain deficits, but cutting sharply in a slump can backfire.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Physical capital, human capital and technology
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A town borrows $100 million at 5% for a project yielding $3 million a year in benefits. What does the first test for a borrowed project say?
Question 2 of 5
Why do governments fund basic research rather than leave it to private firms?
Question 3 of 5
One economy grows at 2.0% a year and another at 1.5%, starting from the same size. After 35 years, how much larger is the faster one?
Question 4 of 5
A government builds a highway by borrowing rather than by raising taxes. What is the main extra risk?
Question 5 of 5
What does the evidence suggest about cutting income tax rates to raise growth?
