Macroeconomics › Section Q · Government budgets and fiscal policy › Topic Q.4
Using fiscal policy against recession and inflation
When spending in the economy falls short or runs too hot, Congress and the President can change taxes and spending to push aggregate demand back towards potential GDP. This topic shows how expansionary and contractionary fiscal policy work in the AD/AS model, and how to size them.
What fiscal policy is
Fiscal policy means deliberately setting taxes and government spending to steer the economy. In the United States it is made by Congress and the President through budget and tax laws, whereas monetary policy is made by the Federal Reserve. Both work mainly through aggregate demand in the short run. Every tax and spending law affects demand to some degree, but fiscal policy as a stabilisation tool means deliberately changing the overall level of taxes or spending to fight a recession or to cool inflation. The aim is to keep real GDP close to potential GDP.
The ideal: demand keeps pace with supply
In a healthy, growing economy, more workers, more capital and better technology shift both short-run and long-run aggregate supply to the right each year. If aggregate demand grows at the same pace, the economy stays at potential GDP with only mild inflation. Trouble starts when the two fall out of step. If households grow cautious, firms cut investment or foreign demand for exports weakens, AD lags behind and output falls below potential: a recessionary gap with rising cyclical unemployment. If AD races ahead of supply, output is pushed above potential and inflation picks up: an inflationary gap.
Three channels for expansionary policy
Expansionary fiscal policy raises aggregate demand. It can work through consumption, by cutting personal income or payroll taxes or raising transfer payments, so households have more disposable income to spend. It can work through investment, by cutting business taxes or offering tax breaks for new equipment, so that projects become more profitable. Or it can work directly through government purchases, by spending more on goods and services, or by sending grants to states and cities to fund their own purchases. Each shifts the AD curve to the right. Contractionary fiscal policy uses the same three channels in reverse.
Fighting a recession
Picture an economy whose AD and SRAS curves cross below potential GDP. Output is low and unemployment high. An expansionary policy shifts AD to the right until the new equilibrium sits on the long-run aggregate supply curve at potential GDP. The price level rises somewhat, but because the economy started with idle workers and machines, the rise should be small. In practice, policymakers rarely know the exact size of the gap, and the response of spending to a policy change is uncertain, so the shift is an estimate. The earlier topic on Keynesian building blocks showed how the multiplier makes the final shift larger than the initial change.
Worked example: closing a recessionary gap
Real GDP is $200 billion below potential, and the marginal propensity to consume is 0.75, so the simple multiplier is \(\frac{1}{1 - 0.75} = 4\). Use the simple model with no other leakages. 1. By spending: purchases needed are \(200 \div 4 = 50\) billion dollars. 2. By a tax cut: households spend only 75% of a cut \(T\) in the first round, so the effect is \(0.75T \times 4 = 3T\). 3. Setting \(3T = 200\) gives \(T \approx 66.7\) billion dollars. 4. Check: the tax cut must be larger than the spending rise, because a quarter of it is saved before it enters the spending stream.
Taxes or spending?
The AD/AS model says how far demand must move, not which tool to use. That choice depends on values and on evidence about specific programmes. In US debates, people who favour a smaller role for government more often prefer expansion through tax cuts, while those who favour a larger role more often prefer spending increases, and both major parties have backed each tool at times. A tax cut leaves spending decisions with households and firms; a spending programme lets government choose what is bought, such as roads or research. Because the model can serve advocates of both smaller and larger government, the final choice is political rather than purely economic.
Two recent responses
In early 2009, during the Great Recession, Congress passed the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, a package of about $800 billion that combined tax cuts, aid to states and spending on infrastructure and other programmes. Its effect was partly offset as state and local governments, whose revenue had collapsed, cut their own spending. In 2020 and 2021 the response to the pandemic was far larger, including the CARES Act of March 2020, often described as a $2.2 trillion package, and the American Rescue Plan of March 2021, about $1.9 trillion. They funded payments to households, enhanced unemployment benefits, aid to small businesses and support for states. Economists still debate how much the 2021 package added to the inflation of 2021 and 2022.
Fighting inflation
Now picture AD crossing SRAS above potential GDP. Unemployment is very low, firms struggle to hire and wages and prices rise quickly; this is sometimes called an overheating economy. A large budget deficit can contribute, by pushing demand beyond what the economy can produce. Contractionary fiscal policy, through spending cuts or tax increases, shifts AD to the left until equilibrium is back at potential GDP, easing the upward pressure on prices. Again the model does not pick the tool: some prefer cutting spending, others raising taxes, and the right answer may depend on the circumstances.
Worked example: cooling an overheating economy
Real GDP is $90 billion above potential, and the MPC is 0.6, so the multiplier is \(\frac{1}{1 - 0.6} = 2.5\). 1. Spending cut needed: \(90 \div 2.5 = 36\) billion dollars. 2. A tax rise \(T\) lowers first-round consumption by \(0.6T\), so the total effect is \(0.6T \times 2.5 = 1.5T\). 3. Setting \(1.5T = 90\) gives \(T = 60\) billion dollars. 4. Check by rounds for the spending cut: \(36 + 21.6 + 12.96 + \cdots\) approaches \(36 \times 2.5 = 90\) billion dollars. Either policy shifts AD left by $90 billion in this simple model; real multipliers are smaller once taxes and imports leak away.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, setting the spending change equal to the output gap; the multiplier means a smaller change is needed. Second, treating a tax cut as equal in power to the same rise in purchases; part of a tax cut is saved first, so its multiplier is smaller in the simple model. Third, believing the AD/AS model tells you whether to use taxes or spending; it shows only the direction and size of the shift. Fourth, forgetting that fiscal policy is set by Congress and the President, not the Federal Reserve. Fifth, assuming expansionary policy works the same at full employment; there it mainly raises prices.
Key takeaways
Fiscal policy uses taxes and spending to steer aggregate demand towards potential GDP. Expansionary policy, through lower taxes, higher transfers or higher purchases, shifts AD right to fight a recessionary gap. Contractionary policy, through higher taxes or lower spending, shifts AD left to fight an inflationary gap. Because of the multiplier, the change needed is smaller than the gap, and a tax change must be larger than a spending change for the same effect. Major US examples include the 2009 Recovery Act and the 2020 and 2021 pandemic packages. Choosing taxes or spending is a political decision.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Using taxes and government spending to influence the economy
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Real GDP is $120 billion below potential and the MPC is 0.8. In the simple model, how large an increase in government purchases would close the gap?
Question 2 of 5
With an MPC of 0.75, why must a tax cut be larger than an increase in purchases to close the same recessionary gap?
Question 3 of 5
Unemployment is very low and inflation is rising because output is above potential GDP. Which fiscal policy fits this situation?
Question 4 of 5
Output is $90 billion above potential and the MPC is 0.6. In the simple model, what tax increase would close the gap?
Question 5 of 5
According to the AD/AS model, how should a government decide between tax cuts and spending increases to fight a recession?
