Macroeconomics › Section Q · Government budgets and fiscal policy › Topic Q.5

Automatic stabilizers

Some fiscal policy needs no vote at all. Taxes and benefit programmes already on the books loosen the budget when the economy weakens and tighten it when the economy booms, acting like shock absorbers on the business cycle.

Two kinds of fiscal policy

Discretionary fiscal policy happens when Congress and the President pass a new law that changes taxes or spending, such as a stimulus package. Automatic stabilisers are features of existing tax and spending laws that change the budget without any new decision: they push aggregate demand up when the economy slows and hold it back when the economy speeds up. Because they respond to the economy rather than to a vote, they are a built-in form of countercyclical policy, meaning policy that leans against the business cycle. This topic explains how they work and how economists measure them.

The tax side

Taxes are levied on incomes, payrolls and profits, so tax receipts rise and fall with the economy. In a recession, fewer people work, hours are cut and profits shrink, so income, payroll and corporate tax payments fall at once. Because the income tax is progressive, receipts fall faster than incomes: a household whose income drops may slide into a lower bracket, so its tax falls by a larger percentage than its income. Corporate tax receipts are especially volatile, since profits swing more than wages. In a boom the reverse happens, and receipts climb faster than incomes, draining some spending power from the economy.

The spending side

Several programmes pay out more when times are hard. Unemployment insurance, run by the states with federal support, replaces part of a laid-off worker's wages, for up to 26 weeks in most states, though some offer fewer. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, grows as more households qualify for food help. Medicaid enrolment rises as people lose jobs and job-based health cover. None of these needs new legislation: anyone who meets the existing rules can claim. When the economy recovers, claims fall and this spending shrinks again.

Worked example: one household's cushion

Sam earns $1,000 a week, and $180 is withheld in income and payroll taxes. He is laid off and receives unemployment benefits of 45% of his former wage. For simplicity, ignore any tax on the benefit. 1. Take-home pay before: \(1{,}000 - 180 = 820\) dollars. 2. Benefit after: \(0.45 \times 1{,}000 = 450\) dollars. 3. Fall in take-home income: \(820 - 450 = 370\) dollars, not 1,000. 4. The cushion: $180 of lower taxes plus $450 of benefits, $630 in all, which is \(630 \div 1{,}000 = 63\%\) of the lost wages. 5. Check: \(1{,}000 - 630 = 370\), matching step 3. Sam still cuts back, but much less than if his income had fallen by the full $1,000.

Stabilisers in the AD/AS model

Add up millions of cases like Sam's and the effect on aggregate demand is clear. When AD falls, lower tax payments and higher benefits support household spending, so the leftward shift of AD is smaller than it would otherwise be. This is expansionary fiscal policy delivered automatically. When AD rises strongly and pushes output above potential, higher tax payments and lower benefit claims hold spending back, a dose of contractionary policy that eases inflationary pressure. The budget moves into a larger deficit in recessions and a smaller deficit, or a surplus, in booms, exactly the direction the AD/AS model recommends.

Bigger government, stronger stabilisers

The strength of automatic stabilisers depends on the size of taxes and transfers relative to the economy. Before the 1930s, federal spending was only a few percent of GDP, there was no permanent federal income tax before 1913, and there was no national unemployment insurance until the Social Security Act of 1935. Today federal spending is around a fifth of GDP or more, and income-linked taxes and benefits are much larger. Many economists argue that stronger stabilisers are one reason US recessions since the Second World War have been milder, on average, than those before it.

The cyclically adjusted budget

Because stabilisers move the deficit up and down with the cycle, the actual deficit can mislead. The Congressional Budget Office therefore estimates what the deficit would be if the economy were at potential GDP. This cyclically adjusted, or standardised-employment, budget removes the effect of the automatic stabilisers. In a recession, the actual deficit is larger than the cyclically adjusted one, since stabilisers are adding to it. In a strong boom, the actual deficit is smaller, or the surplus larger, than the cyclically adjusted figure. The gap between the two measures shows how much work the stabilisers are doing.

Worked example: splitting a deficit

Suppose each 1% that GDP is below potential adds about 0.5% of GDP to the deficit through the stabilisers. 1. Recession year: GDP is 4% below potential and the actual deficit is 5% of GDP. 2. Cyclical part: \(0.5 \times 4 = 2\)% of GDP. 3. Cyclically adjusted deficit: \(5 - 2 = 3\)% of GDP, the part that would remain at potential. 4. Boom year: GDP is 2% above potential and the actual deficit is 1.5% of GDP. The stabilisers are now shrinking it by \(0.5 \times 2 = 1\)%, so the cyclically adjusted deficit is \(1.5 + 1 = 2.5\)%. 5. Check: the boom year looks better on the actual measure, but its adjusted deficit, 2.5%, is not far below the recession year's 3%.

Fast, but only partial

Automatic stabilisers act quickly. Withholding falls the moment pay falls, and benefits start as soon as claims are approved, so there is no wait for data to confirm a recession or for Congress to pass a bill. But they offset only part of a fall in demand, not all of it, so deep recessions usually bring discretionary action too. In 2020, for example, the CARES Act added $600 a week to unemployment benefits for several months and extended how long benefits lasted. The huge 2020 deficit came from both sources: stabilisers responding to mass lay-offs, and new laws on top.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling a new stimulus law an automatic stabiliser; stabilisers work under laws already in force. Second, judging a government's policy from a recession-year deficit alone; the cyclically adjusted figure removes the effect of the cycle. Third, assuming the cyclically adjusted deficit is larger than the actual one in a recession; it is smaller. Fourth, thinking stabilisers fully offset a downturn; they soften it. Fifth, forgetting the tax side: falling tax payments are as much a stabiliser as rising benefits.

Key takeaways

Automatic stabilisers are taxes and benefits in existing law that support demand in recessions and restrain it in booms without any new vote. On the tax side, progressive income tax and profit-linked corporate tax receipts fall faster than incomes in a downturn. On the spending side, unemployment insurance, SNAP and Medicaid expand. They act quickly but offset only part of a shock. CBO's cyclically adjusted budget shows what the deficit would be at potential GDP; in a recession it is smaller than the actual deficit.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Automatic stabilisers

Existing taxes and benefits that lean against the cycle

No new law needed.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which of these is an automatic stabiliser?

Question 2 of 5

A worker earning $800 a week has $140 withheld in taxes. After a lay-off she receives untaxed benefits of $400 a week. By how much does her take-home income fall?

Question 3 of 5

In a recession year, how does the actual budget deficit compare with the cyclically adjusted deficit?

Question 4 of 5

GDP is 3% below potential, and each 1% shortfall adds 0.5% of GDP to the deficit. The actual deficit is 6% of GDP. What is the cyclically adjusted deficit?

Question 5 of 5

Why have automatic stabilisers become stronger since the early twentieth century?

← Previous topicNext topic →