Macroeconomics › Section N · Money and banking › Topic N.4
How banks create money
Most of the money you use was not printed by anyone: it came into being when a bank made a loan. The textbook money multiplier shows how lending ripples through the banking system, and the modern view explains what really limits it today.
Lending creates deposits
When a bank grants you a $20,000 car loan, it does not hand over notes from a vault. It types $20,000 into your checking account. Your deposit is new money, part of M1, and nobody else's deposit went down to make room for it. The bank's balance sheet grows on both sides: a new $20,000 loan among its assets and a new $20,000 deposit among its liabilities. When you repay the loan, the process runs backwards and the money disappears. This is why economists say that commercial banks, not the central bank's printing presses, create most of the money in a modern economy.
The textbook model: fractional reserves
The classic way to show this assumes a fractional reserve system. Banks must hold a fraction of their deposits, the required reserve ratio \(rr\), as reserves, and they lend out all the rest. Holding reserves at exactly or just above the required amount is called a limited reserves environment, which describes US banks before 2008, when reserves earned no interest and so had a clear opportunity cost. Because a loan is spent and the seller deposits the money in another bank, that bank now has new deposits too, and it can lend most of them. One bank's loan becomes another bank's deposit, round after round.
Worked example: following the rounds
Suppose \(rr = 0.20\) and a customer deposits $10,000 of cash in Bank A. 1. Bank A keeps \(0.20 \times 10{,}000 = 2{,}000\) as reserves and lends $8,000. 2. The borrower pays a supplier, who deposits $8,000 in Bank B. Bank B keeps $1,600 and lends $6,400. 3. That $6,400 lands in Bank C, which keeps $1,280 and lends $5,120. 4. Each round is 80% of the one before, so deposits form the series
5. Each new deposit is a checkable balance, so M1 grows with every round, while the original $10,000 of cash simply changed from currency into a deposit.
The money multiplier formula
The rounds form a geometric series whose sum is the initial deposit times \(\frac{1}{rr}\). That factor is the simple money multiplier:
With \(rr = 0.20\) it is 5, so the $10,000 deposit supports $50,000 of deposits in total. Of that, $10,000 is held as reserves and $40,000 has been lent out, which is the new money created, because the first $10,000 was already money as cash. A useful shortcut: the total new money from lending equals the multiplier times the bank's initial excess reserves, \(5 \times 8{,}000 = 40{,}000\). A lower reserve ratio means a bigger multiplier: 10 at 10%, 20 at 5%.
Worked example: checking the multiplier
Verify the totals for \(rr = 0.20\) and a $10,000 cash deposit. 1. Multiplier: \(\frac{1}{0.20} = 5\). 2. Total deposits: \(5 \times 10{,}000 = 50{,}000\). 3. Total reserves: \(0.20 \times 50{,}000 = 10{,}000\), exactly the cash that started the chain, which is now all held as reserves somewhere in the system. 4. Total loans: \(50{,}000 - 10{,}000 = 40{,}000\). 5. Change in M1: deposits rose by $50,000 but currency held by the public fell by $10,000, so M1 rose by \(40{,}000\). 6. Check the balance sheets: across all banks, assets of $10,000 reserves plus $40,000 loans equal $50,000 of deposits.
Leaks that shrink the multiplier
The formula is a maximum, because it assumes every dollar lent is redeposited and every bank lends all it can. Two leaks cut it down. If people keep part of each loan as cash, that cash leaves the banking system; with a 20% reserve ratio and 10% of each loan held as cash, each round carries on only \(0.8 \times 0.9 = 0.72\) of the last, and the deposit multiplier falls from 5 to about 3.6. And if banks hold excess reserves, reserves above the requirement, because they fear defaults in a weak economy, they lend less. Where people distrust banks and keep savings at home, the multiplier is small.
Why the simple story is dated
The multiplier is a useful model of how deposits spread, but it misdescribes how the US system works today. Since the 2008 crisis, banks have held reserves far above any requirement, an ample reserves environment, partly because the Fed pays interest on reserves. And the Fed set reserve requirements to 0% for all depository institutions with effect from 26 March 2020, so \(\frac{1}{rr}\) is not even defined. Before then, US banks faced a tiered requirement of up to 10% of checkable deposits, and savings and time deposits had no requirement after 1990, so the multiplier never applied as neatly as the model suggests.
What really limits bank lending
In the modern view, set out in a widely cited 2014 Bank of England bulletin, banks lend first and the reserves follow, because the central bank supplies whatever reserves the system needs at its chosen interest rate. What limits lending is therefore not a reserve ratio but: the demand for loans from creditworthy borrowers; whether a loan is profitable at the interest rates the central bank's policy rate shapes; capital requirements, which force banks to hold enough capital against their loans; and banks' own caution about risk. So the quantity of money and the quantity of credit still move together, but the central bank steers them through interest rates rather than reserve ratios.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking a bank lends out other customers' deposits: lending creates a new deposit, and both sides of the balance sheet grow. Second, counting the initial cash deposit as new money; it was already money. Third, multiplying the multiplier by the whole deposit when asked for the new money created by lending: use the excess reserves, or subtract the original deposit. Fourth, treating \(\frac{1}{rr}\) as an exact description of today's US system, which has had no reserve requirement since March 2020. Fifth, forgetting that repaying loans destroys money.
Key takeaways
Banks create money when they lend, by crediting borrowers with new deposits, and money disappears when loans are repaid. In the fractional reserve model, each loan becomes another bank's deposit, and total deposits reach the initial deposit times the multiplier, 1/rr. Cash holding and excess reserves shrink the multiplier. The US has had a 0% reserve requirement since 26 March 2020 and operates with ample reserves, so the multiplier is a teaching model; real limits on lending are loan demand, profitability, capital rules and interest rates.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A new loan is credited to the borrower as a new deposit
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In the textbook model the required reserve ratio is 10%. A customer deposits $5,000 of cash. What is the maximum total of deposits in the banking system once all rounds of lending finish?
Question 2 of 5
With a 25% required reserve ratio, a $12,000 cash deposit starts the lending process. How much new money does lending create in total?
Question 3 of 5
A bank approves a $30,000 business loan by crediting the firm's checking account. What happens to M1 at that moment?
Question 4 of 5
Why is the simple 1/rr multiplier not an exact description of the US banking system today?
Question 5 of 5
In the textbook model, which change would make the money multiplier process create more money?
