Macroeconomics › Section N · Money and banking › Topic N.3

The role of banks

Banks stand between people who save and people who borrow, and they run much of the machinery that moves money around. Their balance sheet shows both why they are so useful and why a bank can fail in days.

Why banks matter

The previous topic showed that most money is not cash but bank deposits. That alone makes banks central to the economy. They are part of the payment system, the network that lets wages arrive by direct deposit and bills be paid by card or transfer instead of with bags of cash. They also link savers and borrowers. A family saving for a house and a firm that wants a new warehouse would struggle to find and trust each other directly; a bank does it for them. When banks work well, nobody notices. When they stop lending or fail, the whole economy feels it.

Banks as financial intermediaries

A financial intermediary stands between savers and borrowers. Depository institutions, which take deposits and make loans, are the main kind, and they come in three types: commercial banks; savings institutions, also called thrifts or savings and loans, which historically focused on home loans; and credit unions, non-profit institutions owned by their members. Intermediaries cut transaction costs, the costs of searching for a partner, checking whether a borrower is reliable and enforcing repayment. They also pool many deposits, so one saver's withdrawal is met from the pool, and spread each saver's exposure over many loans. Insurance companies and pension funds are intermediaries too, but they do not take deposits.

Maturity transformation

Banks turn short-term money into long-term loans. Depositors can usually withdraw at any time, yet the bank lends that money for years: a 30-year mortgage, a five-year business loan. This maturity transformation is valuable, because savers want easy access while borrowers want long, stable funding, and a bank gives both at once. It works because on a normal day only a small share of depositors withdraw, and new deposits arrive. But it also builds in a weakness that the rest of this topic keeps returning to: the bank's promises to depositors are due today, while its borrowers repay slowly.

The bank balance sheet

A balance sheet lists what a firm owns, its assets, and what it owes, its liabilities. Drawn with assets on the left and liabilities on the right, it is called a T-account, after the T shape its two columns form. A bank's main assets are loans to households and firms, securities such as Treasury bonds, and reserves: cash in its vault plus its balance in its account at the Federal Reserve. Its main liabilities are customer deposits and money it has borrowed. The difference is the bank's net worth, also called bank capital:

\text{capital} = \text{assets} - \text{liabilities}

A deposit is an asset to you but a liability to the bank, because the bank owes it to you.

Worked example: a bank's capital cushion

A bank holds reserves of $40 million, securities of $110 million and loans of $350 million. It owes deposits of $450 million and has borrowed $15 million. 1. Assets: \(40 + 110 + 350 = 500\) million. 2. Liabilities: \(450 + 15 = 465\) million. 3. Capital: \(500 - 465 = 35\) million, a capital ratio of \(\frac{35}{500} = 7\%\). 4. A recession causes $20 million of loan losses. Assets fall to $480 million, but deposits are still owed in full, so capital falls to $15 million, about 3.1% of assets. 5. Losses above $35 million would leave capital negative: the bank would be insolvent. Capital absorbs losses before depositors do.

How the value of loans is judged

A loan is worth what the bank expects to collect, so its value can change. Loans are made in the primary loan market and can be sold to other lenders in the secondary loan market. A buyer pays less for a loan when the borrower looks risky, for example after missed payments, and pays less when interest rates in the economy have risen above the loan's own rate, since newer loans pay more. The same logic applies to bonds a bank holds: as "Financial markets: bonds, shares, and interest rates" showed, bond prices fall when market rates rise. A 10-year bond paying $20 a year on $1,000 face value, with each payment discounted at 5%, is worth only about $768, a loss of about 23% for a bank that bought it at $1,000.

Two ways a bank goes broke

A bank becomes insolvent when its assets are worth less than its liabilities. The first route is credit risk: far more borrowers default than the bank allowed for, as happens in a deep recession or when a bank has lent heavily to one weak sector. The second is interest rate risk from the asset-liability time mismatch. The bank's long loans and bonds pay fixed rates set years ago, but when market rates rise it must pay depositors more or watch them leave. It can end up paying more on deposits than it earns on assets, while the market value of those assets falls.

Worked example: squeezed by rising rates

A bank funded $190 million of deposits into $200 million of 30-year mortgages at a fixed 3%. Market rates then rise, and to keep its depositors it must pay them 4%. 1. Interest earned: \(0.03 \times 200 = 6\) million a year. 2. Interest paid: \(0.04 \times 190 = 7.6\) million a year. 3. Net interest: \(6 - 7.6 = -1.6\) million a year, before staff, buildings or loan losses. 4. Paying only the old rate instead would drive depositors to banks paying 4%, forcing it to sell mortgages, now worth less, to pay them. 5. Either way capital erodes. This squeeze first pushed many US savings institutions into trouble around 1980.

Protection, and the danger of a run

Banks reduce risk by diversifying, lending to many kinds of borrowers in many places so that losses in one area are offset elsewhere, though a nationwide recession hits them all. They can also hold more safe bonds and reserves, or sell loans. The sharpest danger is a bank run: depositors fearing losses rush to withdraw, and because most deposits are lent out, even a solvent bank cannot pay everyone at once. In March 2023 Silicon Valley Bank, holding bonds that had lost value as rates rose and with mostly uninsured deposits, faced withdrawal requests of about $42 billion in one day and was closed. Later topics cover deposit insurance and the other defences.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling deposits assets of the bank: they are liabilities, owed to customers. Second, thinking reserves are only cash in the vault: most are balances held at the Federal Reserve. Third, treating capital as a pile of cash: it is the gap between assets and liabilities, and it vanishes if assets lose value. Fourth, assuming a bank fails only through bad loans: rising interest rates can sink a bank whose loans are all repaid. Fifth, believing a run can topple only an insolvent bank: a solvent but illiquid bank can fail too.

Key takeaways

Banks run the payment system and act as financial intermediaries, cutting transaction costs and pooling and spreading risk. They perform maturity transformation, funding long loans with deposits that can be withdrawn at any time. Assets are loans, securities and reserves; liabilities are deposits and borrowing; capital is assets minus liabilities and absorbs losses. Banks fail through credit risk or the asset-liability time mismatch, and runs can bring down even solvent banks. Diversification, safe assets and capital are the first lines of defence.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Financial intermediary

An institution standing between savers and borrowers

Banks, thrifts and credit unions take deposits.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A bank has assets of $800 million and liabilities of $752 million. Loan losses then reduce its assets by $30 million. What is its capital afterwards?

Question 2 of 5

Where does a customer's checking deposit appear on the bank's T-account?

Question 3 of 5

Market interest rates rise sharply. Why can this hurt a bank even if every borrower keeps paying?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about maturity transformation is correct?

Question 5 of 5

Why can a bank run sink a bank that is solvent?

← Previous topicNext topic →