Microeconomics › Section H · Perfect competition › Topic H.2

How a competitive firm chooses output

A price taker cannot choose its price - so the whole strategy of the firm collapses into one number: how much to produce. The answer follows a marginal comparison older than economics itself: keep going while the next unit earns more than it costs, and stop exactly where the two meet.

One decision, made at the margin

From the previous topic, a competitive firm takes the market price as given and can sell any quantity at it - so marginal revenue equals price, \(MR = P\). With price beyond its influence, the firm's entire strategic life reduces to a single choice: the quantity. And quantity is decided the way every marginal question in this course is decided - one unit at a time. The firm asks, of each possible next unit: does it add more to revenue than to cost? That question, repeated, is the whole theory of the firm.

The rule: produce where MR = MC

Marginal revenue is the extra revenue from one more unit; marginal cost is the extra cost of it. If \(MR > MC\), the next unit adds more revenue than cost - profit rises, so produce it. If \(MC > MR\), the last unit produced lost money - profit falls, so cut back. Only where the two are equal is there no move left that improves profit: \(MR = MC\) is the profit-maximising rule. It will hold in EVERY market structure of this course; what changes across structures is MR, and for a competitive firm MR is simply the price. So the competitive firm's rule reads: produce where price equals marginal cost, \(P = MC\).

Worked example: finding the profitable quantity

A competitive firm faces a market price of $40. Fixed costs are $20; marginal costs for units one to five are \(12, 20, 28, 40, 60\) dollars. 1. Compare each unit's MC with \(MR = 40\). 2. Units 1 to 3: costs 12, 20 and 28 are all below 40 - produce. Unit 4: cost exactly 40 - the knife-edge, produce it. Unit 5: cost 60 exceeds 40 - stop. 3. Profit-maximising output: 4 units. 4. Check with totals: total cost \(20 + 100 = 120\), revenue \(4 \times 40 = 160\), profit \(40\) dollars. 5. Check the alternatives: 3 units also gives profit 40 (revenue 120, cost 80), while 5 units gives only \(200 - 180 = 20\) - the rule lands on the peak. Assumptions: price given, marginal costs as listed.

Measuring the profit

Once quantity is chosen, profit has a one-line formula:

\text{Profit} = (P - ATC) \times Q

- price above average cost per unit, times the number of units. At the example's output of 4, total cost is 120, so \(ATC = 120 \div 4 = 30\), and profit is \((40 - 30) \times 4 = 40\) dollars, matching the totals check. On the diagram this is a rectangle: height \(P - ATC\), width \(Q\). The same rectangle runs negative when ATC sits above price, and its sign is decided only by where the price has landed relative to the firm's cost curves.

Producing at a loss: the shutdown rule

Suppose the price falls below ATC: every quantity now loses money. Should the firm produce at all? Fixed costs must be paid whether or not it produces - that is what fixed means. So the comparison is narrower: does revenue cover the VARIABLE costs, with something left over to chip away at the fixed bill? If \(P \ge AVC\), producing contributes toward fixed costs and the loss is no bigger than shutting down. If \(P < \) minimum AVC, each unit fails even to pay its own variable cost - producing deepens the loss, and the firm shuts down temporarily, losing only its fixed costs. The shutdown rule: in the short run, shut down when price falls below minimum average variable cost.

Worked example: comparing two losses

A firm can sell 500 units at a price of $7. At that output, AVC is $6 and ATC is $9. 1. It is losing money: price 7 is below ATC 9. 2. Option A - keep producing: revenue \(3500\), total cost \(4500\), loss \(1000\). 3. Option B - shut down: revenue zero, but fixed costs \((9 - 6) \times 500 = 1500\) still fall due. Loss \(1500\). 4. Compare: producing loses $1000, shutting down loses $1500 - revenue pays all $3000 of variable costs plus $500 toward the fixed bill, so keep running. 5. Boundary check: at a price of exactly $6, revenue would merely cover variable costs, and both options would lose the fixed $1500 - the knife-edge of the shutdown rule. Assumptions: costs steady at this output; the long run is the next topic's business.

The firm's supply curve, revealed

Run the rule across all possible prices and something appears. At a high price, the firm produces many units - every unit whose MC falls below it. As price falls, the firm walks down its marginal cost curve, cutting units whose MC now exceeds it; below minimum AVC it produces nothing. So the firm's supply curve IS its marginal cost curve above minimum AVC: at each price, quantity supplied is the \(P = MC\) quantity. The market supply curve is the sum across firms - which is why supply slopes upward (marginal costs rise) and why the demand-supply model of the early topics stood on this foundation all along.

Why supply slopes upward: the unified story

Supply's upward slope always needed a reason; here it is, assembled from earlier topics. Diminishing marginal returns (production topic) make marginal cost rise; rising marginal cost (costs topic) makes each firm supply more only at higher prices; summing firms gives a rising market supply. In the short run, then, the upward slope of supply is diminishing marginal returns expressed in prices: no firm chooses it; it is the shape of congestion.

Averages decide nothing

A caution worth its own card: the output decision is marginal, and averages are the wrong tools for it. Profit per unit (\(P - ATC\)) tells whether the firm is profitable, not whether to produce one more - a firm with positive profit per unit should still expand if \(P > MC\), and a firm losing money should still produce if \(P \ge AVC\). The right sequence: choose quantity by \(P = MC\); then use ATC to read how profitable that quantity is; then use AVC to decide whether to operate at all. Marginal to decide, average to evaluate.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, maximising revenue or output instead of profit - the peak of revenue is not the peak of profit, and the fifth unit in the example earned revenue while destroying profit. Second, deciding quantity with averages: \(P = MC\) chooses output; ATC evaluates it afterwards. Third, shutting down merely because price is below ATC - fixed costs fall due either way, so produce whenever price covers AVC. Fourth, forgetting the boundary cases: \(P = MC\) exactly, and price exactly at AVC, are the knife-edges where the firm is indifferent. Fifth, expecting the rule to deliver whole-number exactness in reality - costs and prices are estimated, and firms land near \(P = MC\), not on it.

Key takeaways

A competitive firm's whole strategy is quantity, chosen where \(MR = MC\); since \(MR = P\), the rule is produce where \(P = MC\) - and it holds in every market structure, with only MR changing. The worked firm at $40 produced 4 units (MCs 12, 20, 28, 40, 60) for a profit of \((40 - 30) \times 4 = 40\) dollars. Losses change the question, not the logic: fixed costs fall due either way, so produce whenever \(P \ge AVC\) (producing lost $1000 versus shutting down's $1500) and shut down only below minimum AVC. The firm's supply curve is its MC curve above AVC, market supply is the sum - and the short-run upward slope of supply is diminishing marginal returns, priced. Marginal to decide, average to evaluate.

Flashcards

Flashcard

MR = MC

Produce where marginal revenue equals marginal cost

The profit rule in every market structure.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A competitive firm's marginal costs for successive units are 12, 20, 28, 40 and 60 dollars, and the market price is $40. How many units should it produce?

Question 2 of 5

Why is a competitive firm's marginal revenue equal to the market price?

Question 3 of 5

A firm can sell 500 units at $7; AVC is $6 and ATC is $9 at that output. What should it do in the short run?

Question 4 of 5

What is a competitive firm's short-run supply curve?

Question 5 of 5

Why does the market supply curve slope upward in this model?

← Previous topicNext topic →