Microeconomics › Section H · Perfect competition › Topic H.3

Entry and exit in the long run

Short-run profits are an invitation, not a destination. In the long run, nothing stops new firms from joining a profitable industry or unprofitable ones from leaving - and that traffic of firms is the mechanism that drags prices down to cost and economic profit to exactly zero.

The long run opens the doors

In the short run, the roster of firms is fixed: entrants cannot build plants in a season and incumbents cannot liquidate theirs. The long run is defined by those doors opening. Entry means new firms joining the industry; exit means existing firms shutting down and leaving. What makes the long run powerful is not that firms are bigger or wiser - it is that the NUMBER of firms becomes an economic variable, responding to profit exactly as output responds to price.

Why profits are temporary

Positive economic profit means the industry's resources are earning more than their next best alternative - and the rest of the economy notices. New firms enter, and each entrant adds its supply curve to the market's: market supply shifts right, and price slides down the demand curve. Entry continues as long as profit remains positive, and it stops when nothing is left to attract: when price has fallen to where economic profit is zero. The mechanism is pure self-interest - no firm enters to be kind to consumers - yet when input costs stay constant, consumers receive the gain as lower prices.

Worked example: blueberry farms enter

A wave of interest raises the demand for blueberries; the market price reaches $9 a crate while each farm's minimum average total cost is $6. 1. At its efficient scale of 200 crates, each farm would earn \((9 - 6) \times 200 = 600\) dollars of economic profit per season, and expanding to where \(P = MC\) earns it even more. 2. New farms enter. Market supply shifts right, and price slides down the demand curve. 3. Entry continues until price reaches $6, minimum ATC. 4. Settlement: at $6, demand is 20,000 crates a season; at 200 crates each, the industry supports \(20000 \div 200 = 100\) farms. 5. Check: at $6 each farm earns zero economic profit - owners cover every cost including the opportunity cost of their land and labour - so entry stops. Assumptions: constant input prices as the industry grows (relaxed two cards on).

Long-run equilibrium: price equals minimum ATC

The long-run equilibrium of a competitive industry is a precise place: \(P = \text{minimum } ATC\). Price sits exactly at the bottom of each firm's average-cost curve, so each firm produces at efficient scale, and economic profit is zero. Three equalities hold at once: price equals marginal cost (each firm's output rule), price equals minimum average cost (the entry-exit stop), and quantity demanded equals quantity supplied. The result looks like a coincidence but is a mechanism: every gap between price and cost is an invitation that keeps the doors swinging until the gap closes.

Zero profit, comfortably

It bears repeating from the costs topics: zero ECONOMIC profit is normal profit, not hardship. Owners are being paid the full opportunity cost of their time and capital - exactly what they could earn elsewhere. Firms neither enter (nothing extra to gain) nor exit (nothing to gain elsewhere): the industry rests. Accountants will still report positive profit, because the owners' implicit costs never appear in the books - which is why news of 'record profits' in an easy-entry industry can coexist with economists' zero: the books count only the explicit share of what the factors earn. The stability of the equilibrium is the point: profit is a signal that moves firms, and in long-run equilibrium the signal is silent.

Exit: the mirror mechanism

Losses run the machinery in reverse. Negative economic profit means the industry's resources would do better elsewhere - and eventually they go there. Firms exit; market supply shifts left; price climbs the demand curve. Exit continues until the survivors' losses close - again at price equal to minimum ATC, with fewer firms serving a smaller quantity at a higher price than during the losses. Two clarifications: exit is a long-run decision, distinct from the short-run shutdown (a firm can stop producing temporarily while keeping its lease, then decide to leave when the lease ends); and exit is not failure - it is resources moving to better uses, the invisible hand doing reallocation.

Worked example: a demand slump unwinds

Demand for blueberries falls permanently, and the price drops to $4 a crate while minimum ATC remains $6. 1. At efficient scale each farm would lose \((6 - 4) \times 200 = 400\) dollars a season, and no output level avoids a loss - the owners' land, capital and labour earn less than their alternatives. 2. The least attached farms exit - the land reverts to other crops, the capital is sold on. 3. Market supply shifts left; price climbs toward $6. 4. Settlement: if buyers now want 16,000 crates a season at $6, the industry settles at \(16000 \div 200 = 80\) farms - twenty fewer than the 100 before. 5. Check: the endpoint is again P = minimum ATC and zero economic profit. Assumptions: identical farms; exit costless beyond finding the next use.

Long-run industry supply

Trace the points entry and exit steer the industry through, and the long-run supply curve appears: for each quantity, the price at which firms are willing to serve it indefinitely - which is the price equal to long-run average cost. Its shape depends on what expansion does to input prices. A constant-cost industry can grow without bidding up its inputs (their supply is elastic: more farmland elsewhere, more workers who can learn the trade): long-run supply is horizontal at minimum ATC. An increasing-cost industry bids up scarce inputs as it grows - good land, specialist workers - so each larger quantity requires a higher price: long-run supply slopes upward. Decreasing-cost industries, where growth improves supplier networks or technology, are possible but rarer.

Why some industries stay expensive

The increasing-cost case explains a durable pattern: in industries tied to genuinely scarce inputs, a lasting rise in demand keeps prices higher. As wine output expands, the best vineyard land is used first, and further expansion climbs onto poorer slopes: long-run costs per bottle rise, and the long-run supply curve slopes up. In such industries, a demand boom raises price permanently, not just temporarily - the surplus goes partly to the scarce input's owners as rising rents. The competitive model predicts this without any conspiracy: scarcity of inputs, transmitted through entry, becomes scarcity of output.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, reading zero economic profit as dying businesses - normal profit means all factors, including owners, are paid their opportunity cost. Second, confusing exit (long run: dissolving the firm) with shutdown (short run: pausing output while commitments run out). Third, expecting entry to be instant: entry takes the time a plant, licence or skill takes - which is why profit can persist for years in industries with slow entry. Fourth, drawing all long-run supply curves flat: only constant-cost industries justify that. Fifth, forgetting who ultimately receives entry's gains: with free entry, consumers get lower prices; with scarce inputs, input owners get higher rents.

Key takeaways

The long run makes the number of firms a variable. Positive economic profit invites entry, which shifts market supply right and drags price down; negative profit drives exit, which shifts supply left and lifts price up. Both roads end at \(P = \text{minimum } ATC\) with zero economic profit - normal profit, all factors paid their opportunity costs, the equilibrium silent and stable (blueberries: a $9 price draws entry until 100 farms sell at $6; a demand fall to $4 drives exit until 80 farms remain at $6). The long-run supply curve follows the industry's costs: horizontal for constant-cost industries, upward-sloping when growth bids up scarce inputs - which is why prime wine land keeps fine wine dear.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Entry

New firms joining an industry, attracted by economic profit

Shifts market supply right.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Blueberry farms face a price of $9 while minimum ATC is $6, each farm producing 200 crates. What happens in the long run?

Question 2 of 5

In long-run equilibrium under perfect competition, what is economic profit?

Question 3 of 5

A firm stops producing this month but keeps its lease for the remaining season. What is this called?

Question 4 of 5

Why does an increasing-cost industry have an upward-sloping long-run supply curve?

Question 5 of 5

A permanent demand increase hits a constant-cost industry. What is the long-run outcome?

← Previous topicNext topic →