Microeconomics › Section O · Poverty and economic inequality › Topic O.5
Policies to reduce inequality
Economics cannot say how much inequality a society should accept, but it can lay out the tools for reducing it and what each one costs. The central question is whether greater equality must mean less output, or whether some policies deliver both.
How much inequality?
No society should expect complete equality of income in any one year. Earnings rise from a first job to middle age and fall after retirement, so a population of mixed ages always shows some inequality. People also differ in how much they choose to work and save. Beyond that, how much inequality is acceptable is a value judgement. If a society decides to reduce inequality, economists group its tools into three sets: redistributing income from higher to lower incomes, widening the ladder of opportunity so that birth matters less, and taxing large inheritances.
Redistribution through taxes and spending
Redistribution means taking income from those with more and providing it, in cash or services, to those with less. On the tax side, a progressive tax takes a larger percentage of income as income rises. The federal income tax is progressive, with marginal rates from 10% to 37%, and refundable credits such as the earned income tax credit give many low-income families a negative income-tax rate. On the spending side are the safety-net programmes of the previous topics, Social Security, and public services such as schools, which are worth more to low-income families than the taxes they pay for them.
Worked example: marginal and average rates
A hypothetical tax charges 10% on the first $20,000 of income, 20% on income from $20,000 to $80,000, and 35% on income above $80,000. 1. Income of $40,000: \(0.10 \times 20{,}000 + 0.20 \times 20{,}000 = \$6{,}000\), an average rate of 15%. 2. Income of $200,000: \(2{,}000 + 0.20 \times 60{,}000 + 0.35 \times 120{,}000 = \$56{,}000\), an average rate of 28%. 3. The marginal rate is the rate on the next dollar: 20% for the first earner, 35% for the second. 4. Read it: each rate applies only within its band, so entering a higher band never lowers take-home pay, and the average rate rises with income.
The ladder of opportunity
Inequality troubles most people more when it comes from circumstances of birth than from effort or talent. Research led by Raj Chetty found that the share of Americans earning more than their parents at age 30 fell from about 90% for those born in 1940 to about 50% for those born in the 1980s. Where children grow up matters: in the Moving to Opportunity experiment, children whose families moved to lower-poverty neighbourhoods before about age 13 earned roughly 31% more as young adults. Ladder policies include high-quality early education, better schools in poor areas, need-based college aid such as Pell Grants, apprenticeships and retraining for adults, and laws against discrimination.
Merit and demerit goods
Some redistribution works through particular goods rather than cash. Merit goods, such as education and vaccination, tend to be underconsumed if left to the market, often because people undervalue long-term benefits or because the goods carry external benefits to others. Governments subsidise, provide or require them, which also tends to narrow gaps in opportunity. Demerit goods, such as tobacco, tend to be overconsumed, so governments tax or restrict them. Taxes on demerit goods often fall hardest on low-income households, which spend a larger share of income on them, so they can widen inequality even while improving health.
Inheritance and the estate tax
Many people accept inequality that comes from building a successful firm more readily than inequality that comes from inheriting a fortune. The federal estate tax taxes very large estates when their owner dies. Under the 2025 budget law, from 2026 each person can pass on $15 million free of estate tax, indexed to inflation afterwards, and the top rate on amounts above that is 40%. So a hypothetical $20 million estate would owe about \(0.40 \times (20 - 15) = \$2\) million. Because the exemption is so high, fewer than one estate in a thousand pays any federal estate tax (about 0.07% of deaths in 2019, under a lower exemption), so its effect on overall inequality is small.
The trade-off: Okun's leaky bucket
Arthur Okun, in a 1975 book, described redistribution as carrying money from rich to poor in a leaky bucket. Some leaks away in administrative costs. More leaks because taxes and benefit phase-outs can reduce incentives to work, save and invest, which shrinks output. Pushed to an extreme, very high taxes on the rich and generous benefits with steep phase-outs could discourage work and enterprise substantially. The question is how big the leak is, and how much leakage a society will accept to make the distribution more equal. That depends on how much more it values a dollar for a poorer household.
Worked example: is the transfer worth it?
A policy takes $1,000 from a high-income household. Administration costs and reduced work effort leak away $300, so a low-income household receives $700. 1. Unweighted: society loses $1,000 and gains $700, a net output loss of $300. 2. Now suppose society values each dollar to the poorer household twice as much. 3. Weighted gain: \(2 \times 700 = 1{,}400\), against a loss of 1,000, so the transfer passes. 4. Break-even: it passes as long as at least $500 arrives, since \(2 \times 500 = 1{,}000\). 5. Read it: the verdict depends on the leak, which economists can estimate, and on the weight on equality, which is a value judgement.
Is the trade-off always steep?
The trade-off may be gentler than the leaky bucket suggests, and sometimes it runs the other way. Public education redistributes, since poorer families receive more in schooling than they pay in taxes, yet it also builds the skilled workforce that drives growth, so it can raise both equality and output. Rich democracies with broadly similar living standards differ widely in inequality, which suggests a middle range where choices about equality cost little output. Softening hardship may also sustain political support for markets, rather than pressure for price controls or trade barriers.
Choosing policies wisely
Because both markets and governments are imperfect, good policy compares them carefully rather than assuming either works perfectly. Cost-benefit analysis sets a programme's measured gains against its costs. Pilot programmes and randomised controlled trials, which assign help by lottery and compare the groups, show what actually works before money is spent at scale, as Moving to Opportunity did. Sunset clauses make a policy expire unless lawmakers renew it, forcing a review. Designs that work with incentives, such as slow phase-outs, tend to leak less than designs that fight them.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing marginal and average tax rates: a 35% marginal rate does not mean 35% of all income goes in tax. Second, believing a move into a higher bracket can cut take-home pay: the higher rate applies only to income above the threshold. Third, assuming every move towards equality costs output: education can raise both. Fourth, assuming redistribution is free: the leaky bucket is real, and its size depends on design. Fifth, thinking the estate tax touches most families: with a $15 million exemption, fewer than one estate in a thousand pays it.
Key takeaways
Societies reduce inequality through redistribution, a wider ladder of opportunity and taxes on large inheritances. Progressive taxes raise the average rate with income: in the worked example, 15% at $40,000 and 28% at $200,000. Where children grow up shapes their earnings, and mobility has fallen: about 90% of those born in 1940 out-earned their parents, against about 50% of those born in the 1980s. Okun's leaky bucket frames the trade-off; with equality valued at twice the weight, a transfer is worthwhile if at least $500 of each $1,000 arrives. Some policies, like education, raise both equality and output.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Redistribution, the ladder of opportunity, inheritance taxes
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Using the hypothetical tax (10% to $20,000; 20% to $80,000; 35% above), what tax is owed on $40,000 and what is the average rate?
Question 2 of 5
A worker's income rises just past the threshold where the 35% rate begins. What happens to her take-home pay?
Question 3 of 5
A transfer takes $1,000 from a richer household and delivers $700 to a poorer one. If society weights the poorer household's dollars twice as heavily, what is the verdict?
Question 4 of 5
Why can public education raise both equality and economic output?
Question 5 of 5
From 2026, the federal estate tax exempts $15 million per person and taxes the excess at up to 40%. Roughly what does a $20 million estate owe?
