Microeconomics › Section N · Labor markets and income › Topic N.3
Unions and labor supply power
Monopsony was one buyer; its mirror is one seller - and when the sellers are workers, the seller is a union. With the threat of a strike behind it, a union can push wages above what the market alone would pay, and the model shows what that raise can cost in jobs.
What a union is
A labour union is a body of workers who bargain together with employers over pay, hours and conditions. Its economic essence is supply-side market power: by bargaining as one, members replace the individual worker's take-it-or-leave-it with a collective voice - the union becomes, in effect, the sole seller of its members' labour, a monopoly facing the firms that hire. The legal machinery matters too: collective bargaining is protected by law, and the strike is the union's ultimate weapon, costly to both sides and so threatened far more often than used. The union question is thus the monopsony question turned around: what happens when the power sits with labour?
Union membership, in outline
In 2025, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, 10.0% of US wage and salary workers belonged to a union (14.7 million people), against 20.1% in 1983, the first year of comparable data. The public-sector rate (32.9%) was more than five times the private-sector rate (5.9%). Men (10.4%) were slightly more likely to be members than women (9.6%), and middle-aged workers more than the young; transportation, utilities and education have high shares, while agriculture, finance and hospitality have low ones. Many other high-income democracies keep far higher union shares than the United States, which suggests the US decline is not purely economic.
The union as monopoly seller
Analyse the union exactly as the monopolist it resembles. Facing the industry's labour demand curve, the union can threaten to withhold labour - strike - unless firms agree to a wage above the competitive level. At the union wage, firms hire less labour than they would at equilibrium, while more workers want union jobs than there are openings: an excess supply of labour, just as a price floor above equilibrium creates a surplus. Every wage gain buys a quantity loss along the demand curve - the same trade a monopolist makes when it raises its price and sells less. The comparison describes the model; it is not a verdict on unions.
Worked example: the wage-employment trade
An industry's labour demand is \(W = 50 - 5L\), supply \(W = 10 + 5L\). 1. Competitive equilibrium: \(L = 4\) at \(W = 30\). 2. The union wins a wage of \(40\): firms respond along their demand curve, \(40 = 50 - 5L\), so \(L = 2\) - employment falls by half. 3. At \(40\), the workers wanting union jobs are \((40 - 10) \div 5 = 6\) - four more than the jobs on offer: excess supply, queued. 4. Read both ways: the two hired workers earn $10 more each, while two of the four competitive jobs have gone. 5. The union's real choice is WHERE on the demand curve to stand. Assumptions: linear curves; the union wage enforced.
How the job loss actually arrives
The employment loss rarely looks like mass firings - strikes are the exception, not the rule. More often it arrives quietly: as union workers retire or quit, they are not replaced; when the firm expands, it expands less - or expands elsewhere, opening the new plant where unions are weaker; production is outsourced to non-union suppliers; in traded industries, imports take the high-cost output's place. This is why union decline can happen without dramatic layoffs: the wage premium sets a headwind that hiring, location and investment decisions all feel at the margin, every year.
Worked example: wages and machines
A higher wage changes more than the headcount - it changes HOW firms produce, because labour and capital are substitutes at the margin. A bakery can bake with sixty hours of labour and one machine (cost \(60w + 100\) at wage \(w\)) or twenty hours and three machines (\(20w + 500\)). At a wage of $8, the labour-heavy plan costs $580 against $660 - labour wins. At $10 they tie at $700. At $14, the machine-heavy plan costs $780 against $940 - machines win, and the firm hires a third of the labour. A union that raises wages strengthens the incentive to automate: the workers who remain are more productive, but there are fewer of them. Some unions have resisted labour-saving equipment for fear of job losses; others have accepted it in exchange for higher pay.
The union wage premium
Empirically, what do unions deliver? Studies comparing union and non-union workers with similar skills, industries and backgrounds typically find a wage premium of roughly 10 to 20 percent - real money, though estimates vary by industry, era and method. Where the premium comes from is genuinely debated. One story is raw bargaining power: the monopoly markup, straight from the diagram. Another is what economists call 'voice': unions that reduce turnover, negotiate training and give workers a channel that improves productivity - a premium shared rather than extracted. The evidence supports both stories in different settings: unions raise wages; the mechanism is a mix of power and productivity; the employment cost rides on whichever mix dominates.
The decline of US unions
Union membership has fallen steeply since the mid-1950s, when roughly a quarter or more of workers belonged. Economists offer four explanations, which are not mutually exclusive. Structural shift: employment grew in services - historically weakly unionised - while manufacturing, labour's stronghold, shrank; the jobs moved to where unions were not. Globalisation: import competition battered heavily unionised sectors and weakened bargaining power everywhere (auto-union membership fell with the industry's share), while public-sector unions, sheltered from imports, held their ground. Policy success: the workplace laws of the monopsony topic were causes unions fought for, and once enacted, many workers may have felt less need for a union. And the legal environment: US rules make organising harder than in many peer countries, which faced the same economic trends yet kept far higher shares.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, analysing unions without the mirror: they are monopoly sellers of labour - judge the model's predictions, not the institution's morals. Second, expecting the employment cost to look like firings: it arrives as attrition, outsourcing and where-firms-expand choices. Third, forgetting capital substitution: a wage premium makes machines relatively cheaper. Fourth, reading the premium as pure extraction OR pure productivity: the evidence supports a mix, and the mix varies. Fifth, explaining US union decline by economics alone: similar economies with different laws retain far higher shares - the comparison strongly suggests institutions are part of the story.
Key takeaways
A union is supply-side market power - workers bargaining as a monopoly seller of labour, with strikes as enforcement. Membership: 10.0% of US workers in 2025, down from 20.1% in 1983, with the public sector (32.9%) far above the private (5.9%) and many peer countries far above the US. The mechanics: a union wage above equilibrium cuts employment and queues job-seekers ($40 won; employment fell 4 to 2 while 6 applied); the losses arrive through attrition, outsourcing, relocation and imports. Premiums push firms toward machines at the margin (labour-heavy at $8, machine-heavy at $14). The empirical premium - roughly 10-20%, hedged - mixes bargaining power with voice productivity. The decline: structural shift, globalisation, labour laws' success, and a harder legal environment - the last visible in international comparison.
Flashcards
Flashcard
An organisation of workers negotiating wages and conditions collectively
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In the worked market (demand W = 50 - 5L, supply W = 10 + 5L), the union wins a wage of $40. What is the employment effect?
Question 2 of 5
Why does the employment cost of a union wage rarely appear as mass firings?
Question 3 of 5
The bakery example (labour-heavy 60w + 100 vs machine-heavy 20w + 500) shows what at wages above $10?
Question 4 of 5
What does the international comparison of union membership suggest about US decline?
Question 5 of 5
What is the honest summary of the empirical union wage premium?
