Philosophy › Section E · Logic and reasoning › Topic E.3

Arguments, validity, and soundness

An argument asks you to accept a conclusion for stated reasons. Judging one well means asking two separate questions, whether the reasons support the conclusion and whether the reasons are true, and validity and soundness give those questions exact form.

What an argument is

An argument is a set of statements in which some, the premises, are offered as reasons for another, the conclusion. The word "offered" matters: a bad argument, whose premises fail to support its conclusion, is still an argument. Not every sentence containing "because" is one. An explanation tells us why something we already accept is true: "The pavement is wet because it rained overnight." An argument tries to show that something is true: "It must have rained overnight, because the pavement is wet." The same words can do either job, so ask what the speaker is trying to establish.

Finding the parts

Start with the conclusion: what is the speaker trying to get you to accept? Indicator words help. Conclusion indicators include therefore, so, hence, thus, consequently and it follows that. Premise indicators include because, since, given that, for and as shown by. They are clues, not rules: "since" can simply mean "from the time when", and many arguments use no indicators at all. Once the parts are found, write the argument in standard form: number each premise on its own line and put the conclusion last, introduced by "Therefore".

Unstated premises

Real arguments often leave a premise unstated because the speaker takes it for granted. An argument with a missing premise is called an enthymeme. "She is a doctor, so she studied for years" relies on the unstated premise that every doctor studied for years. Supplying such premises is essential, because the hidden assumption is often exactly where the argument is weakest. Be fair when you do it: choose the most plausible premise that makes the reasoning work, not a weak one that is easy to attack.

Worked example: putting an argument in standard form

Passage: "The council should not pave the meadow for a car park. It is the only place in the county where a rare orchid grows, and the council has pledged to protect rare species." 1. Conclusion: the council should not pave the meadow for a car park. 2. Stated premises: the meadow is the county's only site for a rare orchid; the council has pledged to protect rare species. 3. Gaps: paving would destroy the orchid's site, and the council ought to keep its pledges. 4. Standard form: (1) The meadow is the county's only site for a rare orchid. (2) Paving the meadow would destroy that site. (3) The council has pledged to protect rare species. (4) The council ought to keep its pledges. Therefore, the council should not pave the meadow. 5. Each premise can now be checked separately.

Two questions: logic and truth

Every argument faces two separate tests. Logical analysis asks whether the premises, if true, would support the conclusion. Truth analysis asks whether the premises actually are true. Keep them apart. "Water boils at 100 °C at sea level. Tokyo is in Japan. Therefore, the Moon orbits the Earth" has true premises and a true conclusion, yet it is worthless, because there is no inference: nothing leads from the premises to the conclusion. To test the logic, assume the premises are true for the moment, however doubtful they seem, and ask whether the conclusion would follow.

Validity

A deductive argument is valid if and only if it is impossible for all its premises to be true while its conclusion is false. Put another way, if the premises were true, the conclusion would have to be true. Validity concerns the link between premises and conclusion, not their actual truth. "All planets are made of glass. Mars is a planet. Therefore, Mars is made of glass" is valid: if both premises were true, the conclusion could not be false. Its first premise is false, but that is a separate matter. Note the vocabulary: statements are true or false, while arguments are valid or invalid.

Soundness

A sound argument is valid and has all true premises, so its conclusion must be true. The glass-planet argument is valid but unsound. There are two ways to criticise an argument: show that it is invalid, so the conclusion does not follow even granting the premises, or show that a premise is false, so the argument is unsound. If an argument is valid and you reject its conclusion, logic forces you to reject at least one premise. But showing that an argument is unsound does not show that its conclusion is false; a true conclusion can be badly argued for.

The four combinations

A valid argument with all true premises has a true conclusion: it is sound. A valid argument with a false premise can have a true or a false conclusion: "All fish are mammals. All whales are fish. Therefore, all whales are mammals" is valid, with two false premises and a true conclusion. An invalid argument can have true premises and either kind of conclusion. Exactly one combination is impossible: a valid argument whose premises are all true and whose conclusion is false. That impossibility is what validity means.

Worked example: a truth-table test

Is this valid? Premise 1: not both P and Q. Premise 2: P. Conclusion: not Q.

\begin{array}{cc|c|c} P & Q & \neg(P \wedge Q) & \neg Q \\ \hline T & T & F & F \\ T & F & T & T \\ F & T & T & F \\ F & F & T & T \end{array}

1. List the four combinations of P and Q. 2. Premise 1 is false only in row 1, where both are true. 3. Premise 2, P itself, is true only in rows 1 and 2. 4. Both premises are true together only in row 2. 5. In row 2 the conclusion, ¬Q, is true. 6. No row makes both premises true and the conclusion false, so the argument is valid. Had such a row existed, it would have shown the argument invalid.

Worked example: refuting by logical analogy

Argument: "All novelists are writers. Some writers are poets. Therefore, some novelists are poets." 1. Do not ask whether the conclusion happens to be true; ask whether it follows. 2. Build an argument with exactly the same form: "All dogs are mammals. Some mammals are cats. Therefore, some dogs are cats." 3. Its premises are plainly true and its conclusion plainly false. 4. So the form allows true premises with a false conclusion, which means the form is invalid, and so is the original argument. 5. Diagnose: the writers who are poets may all lie outside the group of novelists. This technique is called refutation by logical analogy.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling an argument invalid because its conclusion is false, or valid because its conclusion is true; validity concerns the link, not the outcome. Second, speaking of "true arguments" or "valid statements". Third, assuming an unsound argument has a false conclusion. Fourth, ignoring unstated premises, where weaknesses often hide. Fifth, treating indicator words as proof that an argument is present, or their absence as proof that it is not.

Key takeaways

An argument offers premises as reasons for a conclusion; an explanation instead tells why an accepted fact holds. Find the conclusion first, use indicator words as clues, supply unstated premises charitably and write the result in standard form. Judge logic and truth separately. A valid argument cannot have all true premises and a false conclusion; a sound argument is valid with all premises true, so its conclusion is true. Test validity by searching for a case, or a truth-table row, with true premises and a false conclusion, or by building an argument of the same form that has one.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Argument

Premises offered as reasons for a conclusion

A bad argument is still an argument.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

"All metals are liquids. Iron is a metal. Therefore, iron is a liquid." How should this argument be classified?

Question 2 of 5

Which combination is impossible for a valid argument?

Question 3 of 5

"Since the bridge into town is closed, we will be late for the meeting, so we should phone ahead to warn them." What is the main conclusion?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is an explanation rather than an argument?

Question 5 of 5

In a truth table for an argument, every row in which all the premises are true also has a true conclusion. What follows?

← Previous topicNext topic →