Philosophy › Section E · Logic and reasoning › Topic E.2
Logical statements
Before you can judge an argument, you have to know exactly what its statements claim. A few kinds of statement, above all the conditional, carry most philosophical reasoning, and truth tables show precisely when each one is true.
Statements and connectives
A statement is a sentence with a truth value: it is true or it is false. Connectives join simple statements P and Q into compound ones: negation, ¬P (not P); conjunction, P ∧ Q (P and Q); disjunction, P ∨ Q (P or Q); the conditional, P → Q (if P then Q); and the biconditional, P ↔ Q (P if and only if Q). A compound's truth value depends only on its parts' values. A truth table lists every combination: two simple statements give four rows, three give eight.
Not, and, or
Negation flips a truth value. A conjunction is true only when both parts are true. A disjunction is true when at least one part is true, including when both are: this is inclusive or. A menu's "soup or salad" usually means exclusive or, one but not both, which logic must state separately.
Read across: in row 2, P is true and Q false, so the conjunction is false and the disjunction true.
The conditional
In "if P then Q", P is the antecedent and Q is the consequent. A conditional is false in exactly one case: the antecedent is true and the consequent is false.
Think of a promise: "If you finish the job by Friday, I will pay you $200." The promise is broken only if you finish and I do not pay; if you do not finish, it is not broken, whatever I do. This reading is called the material conditional. Philosophers debate how well it fits every everyday "if", but it is logic's standard.
Many ways to say if
Ordinary language expresses P → Q in many forms: "if P, Q"; "Q if P"; "P only if Q"; "Q, provided that P". The tricky one is "only if". "You may board only if you have a ticket" means that if you board, you have a ticket; it does not promise that a ticket gets you on. "P unless Q" means if not Q, then P: "The match goes ahead unless it rains" says that without rain, the match goes ahead. The biconditional asserts the conditional in both directions.
Necessary and sufficient conditions
Every conditional P → Q states two relations. P is a sufficient condition for Q: its truth guarantees Q. Q is a necessary condition for P: P cannot be true without Q. Being a square is sufficient for having four sides, and having four sides is necessary for being a square, but not sufficient. Philosophers often define a term by conditions that are both necessary and sufficient, as in the traditional example: someone is a bachelor if and only if he is an unmarried adult man. Such a definition must admit every case it should and exclude every case it should not.
Converse and contrapositive
The converse of P → Q is Q → P, and it is not equivalent: "If it is a square, it has four sides" is true, but "If it has four sides, it is a square" is false. The contrapositive, ¬Q → ¬P, is equivalent: "If it does not have four sides, it is not a square" says just what the original says. The inverse, ¬P → ¬Q, is equivalent to the converse, not to the original. Two statements are logically equivalent when they have the same truth value in every row of a truth table.
Worked example: checking equivalence with a truth table
Is P → Q equivalent to its contrapositive and to its converse?
1. List the four combinations of P and Q. 2. P → Q is false only in row 2, where P is true and Q false. 3. For ¬Q → ¬P, the antecedent ¬Q is true in rows 2 and 4; in row 2, ¬P is false, so the conditional is false there and true elsewhere. 4. Q → P is false only in row 3, where Q is true and P false. 5. Compare: the contrapositive matches P → Q in every row, so they are equivalent; the converse differs in rows 2 and 3.
Counterexamples
A general conditional claim is refuted by a single counterexample: a case where the antecedent is true and the consequent is false. For centuries Europeans held that if a bird is a swan, it is white; the black swans of Australia refuted the claim. Notice which cases do not count. A white goose is irrelevant, because its antecedent is false: it is not a swan. And any number of white swans cannot prove the claim; they only fail to refute it. Hunting for counterexamples to your own beliefs is one of philosophy's best habits.
Universal statements
A universal affirmative statement has the form "All A are B", one of the statement types at the heart of Aristotle's logic. It is equivalent to a conditional about any individual: for anything at all, if it is an A, then it is a B. So "All metals conduct electricity" means that if something is a metal, it conducts electricity. Being an A is sufficient for being a B, and being a B is necessary for being an A. One counterexample, an A that is not a B, refutes it.
Worked example: translating and testing
Claim 1: "A shape is a square only if it has four sides." 1. Translate: if a shape is a square, then it has four sides. 2. Sufficient condition: being a square; necessary condition: having four sides. 3. Seek a counterexample, a square without four sides: none exists, so the claim stands. 4. Test the converse: a 2 cm by 5 cm rectangle has four sides but is not a square, so the converse is false. Claim 2: "All metals are solid at room temperature." 5. Translate: if something is a metal, it is solid at room temperature. 6. Counterexample: mercury is a metal and is liquid at room temperature. 7. So claim 2 is false.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading "P only if Q" as "if Q then P"; it means if P then Q. Second, treating a conditional as equivalent to its converse. Third, calling a conditional with a false antecedent false; the table makes it true. Fourth, reading every "or" as exclusive. Fifth, offering a case with a false antecedent as a counterexample. Sixth, swapping necessary and sufficient: in P → Q, P is sufficient and Q necessary.
Key takeaways
Connectives build compound statements whose truth values follow from their parts, as truth tables show. Negation flips a value; conjunction needs both parts true, disjunction at least one. A conditional is false only when its antecedent is true and its consequent false. In P → Q, P is sufficient and Q necessary; "only if" introduces the necessary condition. The contrapositive is equivalent, while the converse and inverse are not. "All A are B" works as a conditional, and one counterexample refutes a general claim.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A sentence with a truth value: true or false
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
When is the conditional "If P, then Q" false?
Question 2 of 5
"You may enter the lab only if you wear goggles." Which statement means the same?
Question 3 of 5
In "If an animal is a whale, then it is a mammal", what is being a mammal?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement is logically equivalent to "If it is raining, the ground is wet"?
Question 5 of 5
Which case is a counterexample to "All birds can fly"?
