Philosophy › Section C · Early philosophy around the world › Topic C.2

Classical Indian philosophy

Over more than two thousand years, Indian thinkers built rival schools with sophisticated theories of the self, reality, knowledge and logic. Most saw philosophy as a path to freedom from suffering, and they argued with one another as sharply as any philosophers anywhere.

Philosophy as a path to freedom

Classical Indian philosophy is a vast tradition, and one topic can only map its landmarks. Its schools disagreed about almost everything, yet most shared a practical aim. Many held that beings are caught in samsara, the cycle of birth, death and rebirth, driven by karma, the law that actions bring consequences to those who perform them. The goal of philosophy was moksha, liberation from that cycle, or in Buddhism nirvana, the end of suffering. Ignorance was usually seen as the root problem and right knowledge as the cure. Like the Greek schools, Indian philosophy was a way of life as well as a body of theory.

The Vedas

The oldest texts are the four Vedas: the Rigveda, Samaveda, Yajurveda and Atharvaveda. Scholars usually date the hymns of the Rigveda to about 1500 to 1200 BCE. They were memorised and recited word for word for many centuries before being written down, and they are called shruti, what was heard, because tradition holds them to be revealed. Each Veda grew in layers: hymns, then ritual manuals called Brahmanas, then forest texts called Aranyakas, then the Upanishads. Philosophy already stirs in the hymns. The creation hymn of the Rigveda's tenth book asks what existed before existence and non-existence, and ends by wondering whether even the highest overseer knows.

The Upanishads: atman and Brahman

The earliest Upanishads, such as the Brihadaranyaka and the Chandogya, were composed from about 800 BCE. The name suggests sitting near a teacher, and many take the form of dialogues. Their central questions are what the true self, atman, is and how it relates to Brahman, the ultimate reality behind all things. In the Chandogya Upanishad, the teacher Uddalaka asks his son Shvetaketu to dissolve salt in water: the salt cannot be seen, yet every sip tastes of it. So too Brahman pervades everything unseen, and Uddalaka concludes, "you are that" (tat tvam asi). On one influential reading, the deepest self and ultimate reality are identical.

Orthodox and heterodox schools

Later thinkers organised Indian philosophy into darshanas, from a Sanskrit word for seeing: each school is a way of viewing reality. Six schools are called astika, orthodox, because they accept the authority of the Vedas. They are often grouped in pairs: Nyaya and Vaisheshika, Samkhya and Yoga, and Mimamsa and Vedanta. Three major schools are nastika, heterodox, because they reject Vedic authority: Buddhism, Jainism and the materialist Charvaka school. "Heterodox" describes a school's relation to the Vedas, not its quality, and all the schools sharpened their views by attacking one another.

Samkhya and Yoga

Samkhya is a dualist school. Reality has two kinds of principle: purusha, pure consciousness, of which there are many, and prakriti, matter, made of three interacting qualities called gunas. From prakriti unfold intellect, ego, mind, the senses and the elements. Suffering comes from confusing consciousness with the body and mind; liberation comes from discriminating between them. Yoga shares this picture and adds a practice. The Yoga Sutras attributed to Patanjali, compiled at a debated date, perhaps between the second century BCE and the fifth century CE, define yoga as stilling the movements of the mind. Its eight limbs run from moral restraints, including ahimsa, through posture, breath and concentration, to samadhi, complete absorption.

Nyaya and Vaisheshika

Nyaya, meaning method or reasoning, is the school of logic and epistemology. It asked what the pramanas, the reliable means of knowledge, are, and accepted four: perception, inference, comparison and testimony from a trustworthy source. Vaisheshika, traditionally founded by the sage Kanada, is a school of metaphysics. It sorted everything that exists into categories, such as substance, quality and action, and taught that physical things are made of eternal, indivisible atoms that combine into larger bodies. Vaisheshika accepted only perception and inference as means of knowledge. Over time the two schools merged into one tradition.

Worked example: a Nyaya inference

Nyaya set out an inference in five steps, using the classic example of smoke on a hill. 1. Thesis: the hill has fire. 2. Reason: because it has smoke. 3. Example with a general rule: wherever there is smoke there is fire, as in a kitchen. 4. Application: this hill has smoke, which is always accompanied by fire. 5. Conclusion: therefore the hill has fire. Check the logic: the inference depends on the rule in step 3, called pervasion, the invariable connection between smoke and fire. If the rule fails, as with mist mistaken for smoke, the reason is faulty, and Nyaya catalogued such faulty reasons.

Mimamsa and Vedanta

Mimamsa, investigation, studied how to interpret the Vedas' commands about dharma, duty, which led to careful theories of language and meaning. Vedanta, the end of the Vedas, interprets the Upanishads, and its sub-schools disagree about Brahman and the self. For Advaita Vedanta, set out by Shankara in about the eighth century CE, only Brahman is ultimately real, the self is identical with it, and the world of separate things is maya, a kind of appearance. Ramanuja, in the eleventh to twelfth centuries, taught qualified non-dualism, and Madhva, in the thirteenth, taught that God and selves are eternally distinct.

Buddhists, Jains and Charvakas

The Buddha, Siddhartha Gautama, taught in northern India in about the fifth century BCE. His Four Noble Truths diagnose suffering, its origin in craving, its possible end, and the Eightfold Path to that end. Buddhists denied a permanent self, a doctrine called anatta: a person is a changing stream of physical and mental processes. Nagarjuna, in about the second century CE, argued that all things are empty of independent existence. Jains, following Mahavira, taught anekantavada, many-sidedness: any single viewpoint grasps only part of reality. The Charvakas were materialists who accepted only perception as knowledge, denied rebirth and an afterlife, and treated the self as the living body.

Worked example: four views of the self

Compare what four schools say a self is. 1. Advaita Vedanta: the true self, atman, is identical with Brahman; individuality is an appearance. 2. Samkhya: there are many selves, each a pure consciousness, purusha, entirely distinct from matter. 3. Buddhism: there is no permanent self at all, only a changing stream of processes. 4. Charvaka: the self is the living body, which ends at death. 5. Link to practice: Advaita seeks realisation of oneness, Samkhya discrimination of consciousness from matter, Buddhism release from craving, and the Charvakas happiness in this life. 6. Conclusion: each answer to "what am I?" shapes how to live.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, Indian philosophy is not one doctrine; its schools disagreed about the self, God, knowledge and reality. Second, "heterodox" does not mean inferior; it means rejecting Vedic authority. Third, the Vedas are much older than the Upanishads; the Rigveda dates from about 1500 to 1200 BCE, the earliest Upanishads from about 800 BCE. Fourth, yoga in its classical sense is a discipline of mind and conduct, not mainly a fitness routine. Fifth, not every Indian school believes in rebirth: the Charvakas rejected it.

Key takeaways

Most Indian schools treated philosophy as a path to liberation from samsara through right knowledge. The Vedas, from about 1500 BCE, and the Upanishads, from about 800 BCE, explored atman, Brahman and the teaching "you are that". Six orthodox schools accept the Vedas: Nyaya and Vaisheshika on logic, knowledge and atoms; Samkhya and Yoga on consciousness, matter and discipline; Mimamsa and Vedanta on interpreting the Vedas. Buddhists, Jains and Charvakas rejected Vedic authority, offering no-self, many-sidedness and materialism.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Samsara

The cycle of birth, death and rebirth

Driven by karma.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why are Buddhism, Jainism and the Charvaka school called nastika, or heterodox?

Question 2 of 5

In the Chandogya Upanishad, what is the salt dissolved in water meant to show?

Question 3 of 5

In the Nyaya inference "the hill has fire because it has smoke", what does the whole argument depend on?

Question 4 of 5

Which school held that there are many selves, each a pure consciousness entirely distinct from matter?

Question 5 of 5

What did the Charvaka school accept as the only reliable means of knowledge?

← Previous topicNext topic →