Philosophy › Section C · Early philosophy around the world › Topic C.1

Indigenous philosophy

Indigenous peoples in Africa and the Americas developed their own answers to the oldest philosophical questions: what reality is, what a person is, what truth is and how to live well. Studying them takes care, because much of this thought was carried in speech, story and practice rather than in written treatises.

From myth to reason, gradually

Early texts such as the Vedas of India and the Hebrew Bible raise questions about the origin of the cosmos and the purpose of life inside religious stories. Greek writers contrasted mythos, sacred story, with logos, reasoned account. Karl Jaspers, in a book of 1949, called roughly 800 to 200 BCE the Axial Age, when reflective traditions arose in Greece, India, China and the Near East; scholars debate how well the idea fits. The move from myth to reason was gradual and uneven everywhere: early philosophers used stories, and religious texts often contain careful argument.

Studying Indigenous philosophy

Indigenous philosophy means the ideas of Indigenous peoples about reality, knowledge, ethics, personhood and society. Much of it was passed on orally, through stories, proverbs, ceremonies and songs, so researchers often work with living knowledge holders. Academic philosophy in Europe and America long dismissed this thought as mere myth, and colonial rule destroyed records, suppressed languages and cost countless lives. The traditions are also many: there is no single Indigenous philosophy, any more than a single European one, so every generalisation here has exceptions.

African philosophy and the ethnophilosophy debate

In 1945 the Belgian missionary Placide Tempels published Bantu Philosophy, arguing that Bantu-speaking peoples of central Africa held a coherent philosophy centred on vital force, which flows from God through people, animals and things. African scholars such as Alexis Kagame of Rwanda and John Mbiti of Kenya studied proverbs, language and religion more closely, and Mbiti summed up a communal view of the self by reversing Descartes: I exist because we exist. Others objected. Paulin Hountondji of Benin criticised this approach under the label ethnophilosophy and argued that it wrongly treats a whole people's beliefs as one unanimous philosophy, when philosophy needs individual thinkers who argue and disagree.

Ubuntu and sage philosophy

One widely shared idea is ubuntu, a word from the Nguni languages of southern Africa, such as Zulu and Xhosa, often translated as humanness. It is expressed in the proverb umuntu ngumuntu ngabantu, a person is a person through other persons. On this view, you become fully a person through your relationships, so caring for others is part of who you are. Ubuntu has inspired African communitarian political thought. Henry Odera Oruka's sage philosophy, met in the topic "What is philosophy?", answered Hountondji differently: by recording named sages who reasoned critically, it showed that philosophy without writing can still be individual and argumentative.

Olúwọlé: Ọ̀rúnmìlà and Socrates

The Nigerian philosopher Sophie Olúwọlé (1935 to 2018) studied Yoruba thought preserved in the Odu Ifá, the vast oral literature of the Ifá divination system. She argued that Ọ̀rúnmìlà, the sage at the centre of Ifá, was a historical thinker with as strong a claim as Socrates to found a philosophical tradition. In her book Socrates and Ọ̀rúnmìlà (2015) she compared them. Neither wrote anything down; both put virtue at the centre of a good life, admitted the limits of human knowledge and linked wrongdoing to ignorance. She also found a key difference. Socrates, as Plato presents him, sharply separates opposites, while Ifá treats good and bad, or matter and idea, as complementary pairs.

Worked example: weighing Olúwọlé's comparison

Evaluate Olúwọlé's claim that Ọ̀rúnmìlà stands alongside Socrates. 1. Shared situation: both are known only through others, Socrates through Plato and Xenophon, Ọ̀rúnmìlà through generations of Ifá priests. 2. Shared doctrines: both admit that human wisdom is limited, and both teach that people who knew the results of wickedness would not choose it, as in the topic "Socrates as a model philosopher". 3. Difference: Ifá's complementary pairs against the sharper Greek either-or. 4. Objection: the Odu Ifá grew over centuries, so attributing it to one person is uncertain. 5. Reply: the same uncertainty surrounds Socrates. 6. Conclusion: oral transmission does not rule out philosophy; it calls for careful method with both sources.

Native North American thought

Hundreds of distinct nations have lived in North America, each with its own traditions, now studied by philosophers who are often Native American themselves. Some themes recur. Many traditions see the world as made of relationships and processes rather than separate things, and extend kinship to animals, plants, rivers and land. The Standing Rock Sioux scholar Vine Deloria Jr., in God Is Red (1973), argued that Native religions are rooted in particular places, while European Christianity is organised around history and time. The Jicarilla Apache philosopher Viola Cordova described a self that exists only within its community and its land. Such views put reciprocity at the centre of ethics.

Maya thought: writing, time and creation

The Maya of southern Mexico and Central America developed a full writing system, recorded on stone and in bark-paper books called codices. In 1562 the Spanish friar Diego de Landa burned Maya books at Maní, and only four codices are known to survive. The Maya tracked time in interlocking cycles, a 260-day ritual count and a 365-day year that realign every 52 years, and they were among the few peoples to invent a sign for zero. The Popol Vuh of the K'iche' Maya, written down in the 1500s, tells how the gods first made people of mud, who crumbled and dissolved, and then of wood, who could talk but had no hearts or minds and did not remember their makers. They succeeded only with maize: people who could speak and remember them.

Aztec metaphysics and knowledge

Nahua thinkers of the Aztec world, called tlamatinime, knowers of things, reflected on reality and the good life. In the influential reading of the philosopher James Maffie, their metaphysics centred on teotl, a single sacred energy that is everything and is constantly moving and changing. That makes the view a process monism and a form of pantheism, but teotl is not a moral judge like the God of the Abrahamic religions. A Nahua saying held that the earth is slippery: life is unstable and it is easy to fall.

Worked example: two ideas of truth

Compare Nahua truth, neltiliztli, with a familiar modern idea. 1. The familiar idea: a statement is true when it matches the facts, so truth belongs to sentences and beliefs. 2. The Nahua idea, in Maffie's reading: neltiliztli means rootedness, so truth belongs first to a person or a way of life that is well-grounded and balanced. 3. Why it fits their metaphysics: if reality is teotl, always moving, a fixed match between words and world is hard to hold, but staying balanced is possible. 4. What it joins: knowing and living well become one task. 5. Check: the two ideas are not simply rivals; a rooted life still needs many true beliefs.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, oral traditions are not the same as having no philosophy; Odera Oruka and Olúwọlé showed that reasoned, critical thought can live in speech. Second, "Indigenous philosophy" is not one doctrine; African, Native North American and Mesoamerican traditions differ greatly, and so do peoples within each. Third, Tempels's Bantu Philosophy is not the last word: African philosophers criticised and corrected it. Fourth, teotl is not a personal, moral God; it is an amoral, ever-changing energy.

Key takeaways

Philosophy grew gradually out of mythic thought in many places. Indigenous philosophy is studied through oral traditions and living knowledge holders. In Africa, Tempels's account of vital force prompted work by Kagame and Mbiti and Hountondji's critique of ethnophilosophy; ubuntu holds that a person is a person through other persons; and Olúwọlé set Ọ̀rúnmìlà alongside Socrates. Many Native North American traditions stress relationship, place and kinship with land. The Maya developed writing, calendars and zero, and the Nahua saw reality as teotl and truth as being well-rooted on a slippery earth.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Mythos and logos

Sacred story contrasted with reasoned account

The shift between them was gradual and uneven.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Paulin Hountondji criticise ethnophilosophy?

Question 2 of 5

What does the ubuntu proverb umuntu ngumuntu ngabantu express?

Question 3 of 5

According to Sophie Olúwọlé, what is a key difference between Socrates and Ọ̀rúnmìlà?

Question 4 of 5

In the Popol Vuh, why did the gods' attempt to make people out of wood fail?

Question 5 of 5

In Nahua (Aztec) thought, what did it mean for a person to have truth, neltiliztli?

← Previous topicNext topic →