Philosophy › Section K · Political philosophy › Topic K.6

Egalitarianism, socialism, and anarchism

Some thinkers find liberal answers too timid: they ask for deeper equality, common ownership of productive wealth, or no state at all. Each has powerful arguments and serious objections.

Beyond the liberal settlement

The topics "Distributive justice" and "Conservatism, liberalism, and liberty" examined views that accept a state, private property and markets, while disagreeing about how far to regulate them. This topic turns to three traditions that push further. Egalitarians ask what equality really requires and why it matters. Socialists argue that productive property such as factories and land should be owned socially rather than privately. Anarchists argue that the state itself lacks legitimate authority. The course presents each with its strongest case and strongest objections, and endorses none.

Equality of what?

Nearly every modern theory accepts equal moral worth. Egalitarians go further, holding that some important good should be distributed equally, or that inequalities need special justification. But which good? Amartya Sen posed the question in a 1979 lecture, "Equality of What?". Candidates include welfare, resources, opportunity and capabilities. Sen and Martha Nussbaum argued for capabilities, what people are actually able to do and be. Two people with equal incomes are not equally placed if one uses a wheelchair in a city without ramps. Nussbaum listed central capabilities, such as bodily health and political participation, that a just society secures up to a threshold.

Luck or relationships?

Luck egalitarians, following Ronald Dworkin (1981), hold that inequalities caused by brute luck, such as illness or the family you are born into, are unjust and call for compensation, while inequalities flowing from people's own choices may be fair. Elizabeth Anderson, in "What Is the Point of Equality?" (1999), objected that this view would abandon a reckless driver injured through his own fault, and that it asks officials to judge citizens' choices in demeaning ways. She defended relational or democratic equality instead: the point of equality is to end oppression and let people relate as equals, not to cancel bad luck. Luck egalitarians reply that relational views leave unexplained why unchosen disadvantage seems unfair.

Is equality itself the goal?

Critics raise the levelling-down objection, named by Derek Parfit: if equality matters in itself, then making the better-off worse off, with no gain to anyone, would be an improvement in one respect. Many find that absurd. Parfit (1991) suggested prioritarianism instead: benefits matter more the worse off the person who receives them, so we should give priority to the worst off without valuing equality as such. Harry Frankfurt, in "Equality as a Moral Ideal" (1987), defended sufficientarianism: what matters is that everyone has enough, not that everyone has the same. Egalitarians reply that relative position matters too, since large gaps in wealth can become gaps in power and status.

Worked example: levelling down

Island P has two groups of equal size. Group 1 has 80 units of well-being and Group 2 has 40. A disaster strikes only Group 1, reducing it to 40, and helps no one. 1. Strict equality: Island P is now perfectly equal, so in one respect the disaster was an improvement. 2. Prioritarian: no one gained, and the losers were not the worst off, so nothing good happened. 3. Sufficientarian: if 40 units count as enough, nothing changed for the better; if not, Group 2 still lacks enough. 4. Relational egalitarian: ask whether status and power became more equal, which the bare numbers do not show. 5. Conclusion: the case tests whether equality has value in itself.

Socialism

Socialism is the view that the main means of production, such as factories, land and large firms, should be owned and controlled socially, by the state, by workers or by communities, rather than by private owners seeking profit. State socialism places production under central government planning. Market socialism, proposed by Oskar Lange in the 1930s, keeps markets for consumer goods and labour while firms are publicly owned; later versions give firms to their workers. Democratic socialists seek socialist goals through elections and civil liberties. Karl Marx's critique of capitalism, including his accounts of exploitation and alienated labour, is examined in the topic "The Marxist solution". Socialists argue that private ownership gives owners power over workers' lives that democracy should check.

Worked example: Cohen's camping trip

G. A. Cohen, in Why Not Socialism? (2009), offered an argument by analogy. 1. Imagine friends on a camping trip who share tools and food, divide tasks and cooperate without anyone claiming private ownership. 2. Suppose one camper, who found a tree full of apples, demands payment before sharing them, or the best fisher claims the best fish. 3. Most people find this behaviour objectionable in that setting. 4. Cohen argued that the trip shows two principles we already accept: equality of opportunity, and community, in which people serve one another and not only for gain. 5. He asked whether a whole society could run on them, admitting no one yet knows how.

Objections to socialism

Ludwig von Mises (1920) argued that without market prices for capital goods, planners cannot calculate which uses of resources are efficient. Friedrich Hayek added, in "The Use of Knowledge in Society" (1945), that the knowledge needed for planning is scattered among millions of people and is gathered only through prices. In The Road to Serfdom (1944) he warned that central planning concentrates power and threatens liberty. Critics also cite weak incentives and the record of communist states. Socialists reply that market socialism answers the calculation problem, that those states were authoritarian rather than democratic, and that capitalism has its own record of inequality and crisis.

Anarchism

Anarchism, from the Greek for "without a ruler", holds that the state is neither necessary nor legitimate and that society can be organised by voluntary cooperation. Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, in What Is Property? (1840), was the first to call himself an anarchist and declared that property is theft, attacking the right to draw income from ownership without labour. Lysander Spooner argued that no one had consented to the US Constitution, so it bound no one. Peter Kropotkin, in Mutual Aid (1902), argued that cooperation is as natural as competition. Emma Goldman linked anarchism to women's freedom, and the Spanish group Mujeres Libres, founded in 1936, fought for women's place among anarchists. Anarchists disagree about methods: Tolstoy was a pacifist, while others accepted revolutionary force.

Philosophical anarchism and its critics

Robert Paul Wolff, in In Defense of Anarchism (1970), argued that a person's duty of autonomy, to act on their own judgement, conflicts with any duty to obey authority simply because it commands. Philosophical anarchists such as A. John Simmons conclude that no actual state is legitimate, without demanding immediate abolition. Critics answer with Hobbes: without a state, security and the settlement of disputes would fail. Nozick argued that private protective agencies would grow, by morally permissible steps, into a minimal state. Anarchists reply that many communities have governed themselves without states, and that much violence stems from the inequalities states protect.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating egalitarianism with identical treatment: most egalitarians accept differences that are justified, for example by choices or needs. Second, assuming every socialist favours central planning: market and democratic socialists do not. Third, treating socialism, communism and Marxism as the same thing: they overlap but differ. Fourth, equating anarchism with chaos or violence: anarchists defend ordered, voluntary cooperation, and many reject violence. Fifth, confusing prioritarianism with equality: it gives extra weight to the worst off without valuing equality itself.

Key takeaways

Egalitarians ask equality of what: welfare, resources, opportunity or capabilities, as Sen and Nussbaum urge. Luck egalitarians compensate brute luck; Anderson's relational equality aims at ending oppression. The levelling-down objection led Parfit to prioritarianism and Frankfurt to sufficientarianism. Socialism favours social ownership of production, in state, market or democratic forms; Cohen's camping trip argues for it, while Mises and Hayek pressed the calculation and liberty objections. Anarchism, from Proudhon, Kropotkin and Goldman to Wolff's philosophical version, denies state authority; critics answer with security and coordination arguments.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Egalitarianism

Some important good should be distributed equally

Inequalities need special justification.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why does Sen argue that equal incomes may not mean equal positions?

Question 2 of 5

What was Anderson's main objection to luck egalitarianism?

Question 3 of 5

A change makes the better-off worse off and helps no one, but leaves everyone equal. Which view finds nothing good in it at all?

Question 4 of 5

What is the core of the Mises-Hayek calculation objection to socialism?

Question 5 of 5

What does Wolff's philosophical anarchism claim?

← Previous topicNext topic →