Philosophy › Section L · Contemporary philosophy and social theory › Topic L.1

Enlightenment social theory

If reason and observation could explain the motion of the planets, could they also explain and repair society? This topic follows that Enlightenment hope from Kant and Condorcet through Comte's positivism to Du Bois's empirical sociology, and weighs the case for and against it.

Reason as a tool for a better society

The Enlightenment, a European intellectual movement running roughly from the late 17th to the late 18th century, held that reason, rather than tradition or church authority, should guide belief and public life. Immanuel Kant's 1784 essay "What is Enlightenment?" took as its motto the Latin phrase sapere aude, dare to know. Social contract theories built to protect individual freedom are covered in "Political legitimacy, the social contract, and duty". This topic follows a different thread: the hope that reason could study and reform society itself.

Two roads to knowledge

Two theories of knowledge, met in "What epistemology studies", shaped this hope. Rationalists such as René Descartes (1596-1650) gave reason the leading role: some truths, like those of mathematics, can be known by thinking alone. Empiricists such as John Locke (1632-1704) and David Hume (1711-1776) traced most or all substantive knowledge to experience. Earlier still, Francis Bacon (1561-1626) had urged that knowledge of nature be built by observation and experiment. In practice the two cooperate: science uses mathematical reasoning to frame hypotheses and observation to test them, and social theorists hoped to bring that partnership to human affairs.

Progress across generations

Many Enlightenment writers believed history moves forward. The Marquis de Condorcet, writing in hiding during the French Revolution, argued in his Sketch for a Historical Picture of the Progress of the Human Mind (published in 1795, after his death) that knowledge, equality and happiness could advance without fixed limit. Kant's Idea for a Universal History (1784) was more cautious: the capacities of reason develop fully in the human species, not in any one person, and only over many generations of trial, error and education. Kant also held that reason can identify moral laws binding on everyone, as "Deontology" explains, so progress could be moral as well as technical.

Comte's law of three stages

The French philosopher Auguste Comte (1798-1857) turned progress into a law of history. In his law of three stages, each branch of thought, and society as a whole, passes through three ways of explaining things. In the theological stage, events are explained by the will of gods or spirits. In the metaphysical stage, gods give way to abstract forces or essences, such as a hidden power inside things. In the positive stage, people stop asking for ultimate causes and look for laws: regular, observable relations between phenomena that can be tested and used to predict. Positivism is the view that genuine knowledge is of this last kind.

A science of society

Comte thought the sciences reach the positive stage in order, from mathematics and astronomy through physics, chemistry and biology, with the study of society last. As the Sociology topic "The history of sociology" explains, he popularised the name sociology in 1838. He divided it into social statics, what holds a society together, and social dynamics, how societies change. Knowing social laws, he believed, would let experts guide reform without revolution. Fearing that a society without religion would lose its moral bonds, he later founded a secular Religion of Humanity, with its own calendar and rituals.

Worked example: why does opium cause sleep?

Apply Comte's stages to one question. 1. Theological: a god of sleep sends drowsiness to whoever takes the drug. 2. Metaphysical: opium contains a sleep-inducing power. Molière mocked this answer in his comedy The Imaginary Invalid (1673), because it merely renames the effect it claims to explain. 3. Positive: give measured doses, record a regular relation between dose and drowsiness, and later isolate the active compound, morphine, and study how it acts on the body. 4. Evaluate: only the third answer makes predictions that could turn out false, which is what Comte prized. 5. Caution: the stages are types of explanation, and real societies mix them.

Du Bois: evidence before theory

Comte's sociology stayed largely theoretical. W. E. B. Du Bois (1868-1963) criticised early sociologists for building sweeping generalisations about societies and races from impressions rather than data, and set out to gather evidence first. The Philadelphia Negro (1899) rested on a house-to-house survey of one city ward, set against census figures for the whole city. From 1897 he taught at Atlanta University, where he soon took charge of its annual studies of Black American life. Du Bois kept the Enlightenment hope that knowledge could improve society, but insisted it be earned by careful measurement, and he used it against the racist theories of his time.

Worked example: testing an armchair claim

Suppose a writer in 1900 claims that a city's Black residents are poor because they lack ambition. Test it in Du Bois's way. 1. Restate the claim so evidence could count against it: if ambition were the cause, trained and skilled people should rarely be stuck in poor jobs. 2. Gather data: survey households on schooling, trade skills and occupation. 3. Compare: Du Bois's survey found many skilled Black workers shut out of their trades by employers and unions, working as labourers or servants. 4. Conclude: the evidence points to discrimination, not character. 5. Note the method: an armchair claim became a testable hypothesis.

The case for Enlightenment social theory

Defenders point to results. Public health and mass schooling grew from the conviction that social problems have discoverable causes. Arguments about universal rights were used by campaigners against slavery and by early feminists: Mary Wollstonecraft's A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) argued that women's apparent inferiority came from the education they were denied, turning Enlightenment reasoning on Enlightenment society. Today the psychologist Steven Pinker, in Enlightenment Now (2018), argues that reason, science and humanism explain much of modern progress. On this view, failures are reasons to apply reason better, not to abandon it.

Objections from the start

Doubts arose inside the Enlightenment itself. Rousseau's Discourse on the Sciences and Arts (1750) argued that advances in learning had polished manners while corrupting morals. Edmund Burke (1790) warned that redesigning society by abstract reason destroys inherited institutions that hold practical wisdom, a theme of "Conservatism, liberalism, and liberty". Critics note that the age of reason was the peak of the Atlantic slave trade, and that Hume and Kant wrote racist passages. Positivism faces a logical objection: the rule that only observable laws count as knowledge is not itself an observable law. Later topics develop deeper critiques.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating rationalism and empiricism as enemies: Enlightenment science combined them. Second, calling Comte's middle stage religious: the metaphysical stage replaces gods with abstract forces. Third, equating positivism with optimism; it is the narrower claim that genuine knowledge consists of testable laws. Fourth, thinking Kant expected each person to reason out a perfect morality alone; he placed progress in the species. Fifth, assuming every critic rejected reason: Rousseau and Wollstonecraft used argument to expose its failures.

Key takeaways

Enlightenment social theory hoped that reason and observation could improve society. Condorcet saw unlimited progress; Kant (1784) placed it in the species over generations. Comte's law of three stages runs from theological to metaphysical to positive explanation, and positivism limits knowledge to testable laws. Du Bois insisted that social theory rest on gathered evidence. Defenders such as Pinker credit the Enlightenment with modern progress; critics from Rousseau and Burke onwards question its faith in reason, its blind spots on race and positivism's self-undermining rule.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Sapere aude

Dare to know: the motto Kant gave the Enlightenment in 1784

Use your own reason, not authority.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In Comte's law of three stages, what marks the metaphysical stage?

Question 2 of 5

A doctor says a drug calms patients because it has a calming power. Which stage would Comte place this explanation in?

Question 3 of 5

How did Kant's 1784 view of progress differ from Condorcet's?

Question 4 of 5

What was the main methodological point of Du Bois's Philadelphia study?

Question 5 of 5

Which is a logical objection to Comte's positivism?

← Previous topicNext topic →