Philosophy › Section K · Political philosophy › Topic K.1
Historical perspectives on government
Long before modern states, thinkers in Athens, China and Baghdad asked what government is for and who deserves to rule. Their answers, built on virtue and knowledge rather than votes, still shape debates about expertise, merit and the common good.
What is a government for?
Ask people today why we need government and many will say: to keep order and protect rights. Ancient thinkers often aimed higher. For them the main purpose of political life was to make people good and help them live well. That changes the question of who should rule: if government exists to cultivate virtue, the best rulers are the wisest and most virtuous, not necessarily the most popular. Political philosophy is the study of how societies should be governed and why. This topic looks at four early answers, from Plato, Aristotle, the Mohists and al-Farabi. The topic "Classical Greek philosophy: Socrates, Plato, Aristotle" introduced the Greek thinkers' wider ideas; here the focus is their politics.
Plato: rule by those who know
In the Republic, written in about 375 BCE, Plato's Socrates argues that cities will not be free of evils until philosophers rule or rulers become philosophers. His reasoning uses an analogy. A ship's crew squabble over who should steer, each flattering the owner, while the one person who has studied the stars and winds is mocked as useless. Steering is a skill; so is ruling, and it needs knowledge of the good. Plato's guardians would therefore be selected and educated over many years, live without private property or private families, and rule for the city rather than themselves. Strikingly for his time, the Republic allows women of the right nature to be guardians.
Plato under fire
Plato's ideal city has drawn strong criticism. Karl Popper, in The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945), called it a blueprint for totalitarian rule: it censors poetry, controls family life and accepts a "noble lie" told to keep each class content. Critics also ask who checks rulers who claim special knowledge. Defenders reply that the Republic is chiefly about the soul, using the city as a large-scale picture of a just person, and that Plato's warning against rule by the ignorant still applies. Plato himself, in the later Laws, described a second-best city governed by written law. Plato also ranked regimes, a scheme taken up in the topic "Forms of government".
Aristotle: the political animal
Aristotle, in the Politics, called the human being by nature a political animal. Only within a polis, a self-governing city, can humans fully use reason and speech to deliberate about what is just and good. The city first arises for the sake of life, he said, but it exists for the sake of living well. Because virtue is acquired by practice, good laws and education are part of a good life, not obstacles to it. A citizen, for Aristotle, is someone who shares in deliberating and judging, taking turns to rule and be ruled. Unlike Plato, he studied many actual constitutions, and besides sketching an ideal city he valued stable, mixed arrangements.
Worked example: Aristotle's argument that the city is natural
Reconstruct the argument in steps. 1. Every natural thing has a telos, an end it develops towards, as an acorn grows towards an oak. 2. Households form to meet daily needs, and villages to meet wider ones. 3. The polis is the first community that is self-sufficient, able to supply what a full human life requires. 4. The human telos is to live well, using reason, speech and virtue. 5. Since only the polis makes that possible, the polis is natural, and a person entirely outside it is "either a beast or a god". 6. Evaluate: the argument relies on a theory of natural ends that many modern thinkers reject, and it says nothing about consent.
Aristotle's exclusions
Aristotle's citizen body was narrow. He defended natural slavery, claiming some people lack the capacity to deliberate and are better off ruled by others, and he held that women's reason lacks authority. Labourers, he thought, lacked the leisure that virtue requires. Critics see these claims as rationalisations of the hierarchies of his own society, and they show that an ethics of virtue can be bent to exclude. Defenders of Aristotle's wider approach separate his core ideas, such as participation, deliberation and the common good, from his prejudices, and argue that those ideas, applied consistently, condemn the exclusions themselves.
The Mohists: order through shared standards
In China, Mozi (fifth century BCE) and his followers judged policies by whether they benefit all the world: wealth, a large population and social order. The topic "Classical Chinese philosophy" introduced their ideal of inclusive care. Their political story begins with chaos: before government, each person followed their own standard of right, and families fell into conflict. The remedy was to select the worthiest person as Son of Heaven, who in turn appointed worthy officials. Two doctrines follow. Promoting the worthy means giving office for merit and ability, not birth or connections. Identifying upward means adopting the moral standards of one's superiors, who are themselves bound by Heaven's impartial will. Mohists condemned offensive war but supported strong defence.
Al-Farabi and the virtuous city
Al-Farabi (about 870 to 950), working mainly in Baghdad and later in Syria, was called the Second Teacher after Aristotle. In The Opinions of the People of the Virtuous City he described a city whose citizens cooperate to reach true happiness, the perfection of the intellect and character, rather than wealth, honour or pleasure. Its first ruler unites theoretical wisdom with practical skill, and al-Farabi pictured this ruler as philosopher, prophet and lawgiver, a transformation of Plato's philosopher-king. He contrasted the virtuous city with, among others, cities that are ignorant of true happiness, cities that know it but act wickedly, and errant cities misled about it. Later rulers, lacking the founder's wisdom, govern by preserving the founder's laws.
Worked example: who should rule?
Compare the answers. 1. Plato: those with knowledge of the good, trained as philosopher-kings. 2. Aristotle: in the best case the virtuous, but in practice citizens who take turns ruling under law. 3. Mohists: the worthiest, chosen for merit and ability and bound by Heaven's standard. 4. Al-Farabi: a ruler joining philosophy, prophecy and lawgiving, then successors who keep that ruler's laws. 5. Common thread: rule is justified by virtue or knowledge, not by consent. 6. Shared objection: who decides who is wise, and what stops rulers abusing that claim? Later theories, discussed in "Political legitimacy, the social contract, and duty", ground authority in consent instead.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming ancient thinkers wanted government only to keep order: most also aimed to make citizens good. Second, reading Plato's philosopher-kings as hereditary monarchs: they are chosen and educated for wisdom. Third, saying Plato excluded women from rule: the Republic admits women guardians, though Aristotle's Politics does not. Fourth, treating Mohist identifying upward as obedience to anyone in power: superiors are meant to be worthy and are bound by Heaven. Fifth, describing al-Farabi as merely copying Plato: he adapted the ideal to prophecy and revealed law, and extended it from the city to whole nations.
Key takeaways
Early political philosophy tied government to virtue and the good life. Plato argued that those who know the good should rule; Popper called his ideal city totalitarian, while defenders read it as a picture of the soul. Aristotle called humans political animals, held that the polis exists for living well, and defined citizens as those who share in ruling, while excluding slaves and women. The Mohists sought order through promoting the worthy and identifying upward under Heaven. Al-Farabi's virtuous city aims at true happiness under a philosopher, prophet and lawgiver. All four ground authority in wisdom rather than consent.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The study of how societies should be governed and why
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What point is Plato's ship-of-state analogy meant to make?
Question 2 of 5
For Aristotle, why does the polis exist?
Question 3 of 5
What does the Mohist doctrine of promoting the worthy require?
Question 4 of 5
How did al-Farabi picture the first ruler of the virtuous city?
Question 5 of 5
Which objection applies to Plato, the Mohists and al-Farabi alike?
