Philosophy › Section K · Political philosophy › Topic K.2
Forms of government
Sorting governments into monarchies, aristocracies and democracies is the easy part. The philosophical question is which form is best, and why: because it tends to produce good results, because it treats people as equals, or both.
From describing to evaluating
The sociology topic "Forms of government" classifies governments by who rules, how they gain power and what limits them, and the American Government topic "What is government?" sets out the main types. Political philosophy takes that map and asks normative questions. Is rule by one, by a few or by many best? Should power be concentrated so that it can act decisively, or divided so that it cannot be abused? Is democracy valuable in itself, or only when it works well?
Plato's decline of regimes
In Book VIII of the Republic, Plato describes how even the best city decays through a sequence of regimes. Rule by the wise, which he called aristocracy, gives way to timocracy, rule by lovers of honour, then to oligarchy, rule by the wealthy. When the poor rise against the rich, democracy follows, prizing freedom and equality so much that, Plato claims, no authority or standard is respected. Out of that disorder a demagogue promises to protect the people and becomes a tyrant, the worst regime of all. Plato's lesson is that unchecked freedom can destroy itself; critics reply that he underrates ordinary citizens.
Aristotle's six forms
Aristotle, in the Politics, sorted constitutions by two questions. How many rule: one, a few or many? And do they rule for the common good or for their own interest? The answers give six forms. Kingship is rule by one for the common good, and its corruption is tyranny. Aristocracy is rule by the virtuous few, and its corruption is oligarchy, rule by the wealthy for themselves. Polity is rule by the many for the common good, and its corruption, in his terms, is democracy, rule by the poor majority in its own interest. As the best constitution most cities could actually achieve, Aristotle recommended polity, a mixture of oligarchic and democratic elements resting on a large middle class, which he judged the most stable.
Worked example: applying Aristotle's grid
Classify three imaginary cities. 1. City A: one hereditary ruler governs by law and spends revenue on roads, courts and famine relief. One ruler, common good: kingship. 2. City B: a council of the richest families sets taxes that fall on the poor and protect their own estates. Few rulers, own interest: oligarchy. 3. City C: an assembly of all citizens votes to seize the property of a wealthy minority and share it out. Many rulers; whether this serves the common good is disputed, and Aristotle would call it democracy in his corrupt sense. 4. Lesson: the grid judges a government by its aims as well as by its numbers, which is why it is evaluative, not just descriptive.
Monarchy and divine right
An absolute monarch answers to no other authority; a constitutional monarch reigns within limits set by law and elected bodies. Absolutism was often defended by the divine right of kings: monarchs receive authority from God and answer to God alone. Robert Filmer's Patriarcha, published in 1680, compared royal authority to a father's power over his family. A different defence of concentrated power came from Thomas Hobbes, who argued that only an undivided sovereign could prevent civil war, as the topic "Political legitimacy, the social contract, and duty" explains. John Locke wrote his First Treatise of Government largely to refute Filmer, and critics ever since have asked what protects subjects from a ruler who answers to no one.
Mixed government and divided power
The Greek historian Polybius, in the second century BCE, praised Rome's constitution for mixing monarchic, aristocratic and popular elements, so that each checked the others. Montesquieu, in The Spirit of the Laws (1748), argued that liberty requires separating legislative, executive and judicial power, since whoever holds all three can rule as a despot. The framers of the US Constitution drew on this idea; in Federalist No. 51 (1788), James Madison wrote that "ambition must be made to counteract ambition." Supporters say divided power protects liberty; critics reply that it invites deadlock and slow action in crises.
Why value democracy?
Arguments for democracy come in two kinds. Instrumental arguments say democracy tends to produce better outcomes than its rivals. The economist Amartya Sen argued that famines do not occur in functioning democracies with a free press, because leaders who face elections and criticism must respond. John Stuart Mill, in Considerations on Representative Government (1861), added that taking part in politics educates and improves citizens. Intrinsic arguments say democracy is right in itself, whatever its results, because giving each adult an equal say is the way to treat people as political equals. Many philosophers combine both kinds of argument; others, such as Richard Arneson, defend democracy only on instrumental grounds.
Doubts about democracy
Critics, from Plato onward, worry that voters lack the knowledge to judge policy. Alexis de Tocqueville, in Democracy in America (1835 and 1840), warned of a tyranny of the majority, a fear Mill shared. Jason Brennan, in Against Democracy (2016), proposed epistocracy, giving extra political power to the better informed. Defenders of democracy reply in several ways. The Condorcet jury theorem (1785) shows that if each voter is more likely right than wrong on a yes-or-no question and votes independently, the majority of a large electorate is very likely right. Others ask who would choose the experts, and warn that any test of competence would be shaped by the interests of those who set it.
Totalitarianism
In The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951), Hannah Arendt argued that Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union under Stalin were a new kind of regime, not just harsh dictatorships. An ordinary tyranny wants obedience and leaves much of private life alone. A totalitarian regime seeks total control of public and private life, driven by an ideology claiming to know the laws of history, as in Stalin's communism, or of nature and race, as in Nazism, Germany's fascist movement. It uses terror and mass movements, isolates individuals by destroying independent groups and trust, and replaces stable law with constantly changing commands.
Worked example: weighing an epistocracy
A country proposes giving two votes to citizens who pass a civics test. Assess it. 1. Instrumental case for: if better informed voters choose better policies, outcomes may improve. 2. Instrumental case against: the test's designers could favour their own allies, and groups who score lower may see their interests ignored, as the history of literacy tests in the American South warns. 3. Intrinsic objection: unequal votes treat citizens as political unequals, whatever the results. 4. Epistemic reply: by the Condorcet jury theorem, a large electorate may already be reliable if voters are independent and better than chance. 5. Conclusion: the verdict depends on whether democracy is valued for its outcomes, for equality, or for both.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading Aristotle's democracy as modern democracy: for him it was a corrupt form, rule by the poor in their own interest, while polity was the good rule of many. Second, confusing authoritarian with totalitarian rule: Arendt's totalitarianism seeks to control private life and thought, not only to silence opposition. Third, assuming divine right and Hobbes give the same defence of monarchy: one appeals to God, the other to the need for peace. Fourth, treating every defence of democracy as resting on results: intrinsic arguments appeal to equal respect.
Key takeaways
Plato traced a decline from rule by the wise to tyranny. Aristotle sorted six forms by number of rulers and whether they serve the common good, favouring a mixed polity. Absolutism appealed to divine right or, in Hobbes, to peace; Polybius, Montesquieu and Madison defended mixed and divided power. Democracy is defended instrumentally, by Sen and Mill, and intrinsically, as equal respect; critics like Brennan propose epistocracy, while the Condorcet jury theorem supports majorities. Arendt described totalitarianism as a new form seeking total control.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Rule by lovers of honour
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In Aristotle's scheme, what distinguishes kingship from tyranny?
Question 2 of 5
For Aristotle, what is "democracy"?
Question 3 of 5
Sen argued that famines do not occur in functioning democracies with a free press. What kind of argument for democracy is this?
Question 4 of 5
Why did Montesquieu argue for separating legislative, executive and judicial power?
Question 5 of 5
According to Arendt, how does a totalitarian regime differ from an ordinary tyranny?
