Philosophy › Section D · Classical philosophy › Topic D.1

Writing the history of philosophy

Whenever you read Plato, Confucius or Ibn Sina, you are interpreting words written for a different world. The historiography of philosophy asks how to read such texts well, and each of its three main approaches gains something and risks something.

Why study philosophy's past?

Historiography is the study of how history is written, and the historiography of philosophy asks how we should study the philosophers of the past. It starts with two questions. Why bother? The past has intrinsic value: it is worth knowing accurately what earlier thinkers believed and why. It also has instrumental value: old texts still supply arguments, distinctions and counterexamples, and they show how today's questions took shape, so we can tell which of our assumptions were inherited rather than proven. How should we study it? Historians broadly distinguish three approaches: presentist, contextualist and hermeneutic.

The presentist approach

A presentist reads past texts for the arguments they contain and asks whether those arguments still hold up, using today's questions and today's standards. The American philosopher Richard Rorty called one version of this rational reconstruction: restating an old argument in modern terms so that it can be tested like a new one. The strength is obvious. Old philosophers become live partners in debate, and a rich body of past wisdom becomes usable. A student writing on scepticism today can borrow Descartes's dreaming argument, restate it in numbered premises and judge each premise on its merits, without first becoming an expert on seventeenth-century France.

The cost: anachronism

Reading only for arguments has a price. It can ignore how a philosopher actually communicated: the dialogue form, irony, stories and the audience being persuaded. It also judges past thinkers by standards they never shared and marks them down for not answering questions nobody had yet asked. Worst, it invites anachronism, crediting a past thinker with concepts or concerns from a later period. Calling the atoms of Democritus the atoms of modern chemistry is an example. His atoms were eternal, unchangeable and indivisible by definition; the atoms of chemistry have parts, and some of them decay.

The contextualist approach

A contextualist tries to understand a text on its own terms: what the author was doing in writing it, for which readers, inside which debates, and what its key words meant at the time. This approach is associated especially with the so-called Cambridge School of intellectual historians, including Quentin Skinner. It yields richer and more accurate readings. Thomas Hobbes published Leviathan in 1651, as the English Civil Wars were ending, and reading it as a response to that breakdown explains why he values an undivided sovereign power so highly. The risk is antiquarianism: studying the past purely for its own sake and forgetting to ask whether its ideas are true or useful now.

The hermeneutic approach

Hermeneutics is the theory of interpretation. A hermeneutic historian takes historical context seriously but admits that no interpreter can step outside their own time: our questions shape what we notice in a text. The German philosopher Hans-Georg Gadamer described understanding as a fusion of horizons, a meeting between the world of the text and the world of the reader. This approach also holds that concepts are historical, so we grasp an idea fully only by tracing how it arose. Its weakness is a tendency to tell history as a story that leads up to us, as if the past were a staircase to the present. Historians call that pattern Whig history.

Worked example: three readings of one passage

In Book I of the Politics, Aristotle argues that some people are slaves by nature. 1. Presentist reading: test the argument by today's standards. It rests on the false premise that some humans lack the capacity to govern themselves, so it fails. Gained: a clear verdict. Missed: why a careful thinker held it. 2. Contextualist reading: Athenian households and farms depended on enslaved labour, and Aristotle himself grants that many people enslaved by war are not slaves by nature, a tension many readers think he never resolves. Gained: explanation and his own doubts. 3. Hermeneutic reading: our commitment to human equality is what makes this passage leap out. Admitting that, we can ask how able minds come to justify the institutions around them. 4. Check: each reading answers a different question, and good history usually needs more than one.

Worked example: catching an anachronism

A student writes: "Heraclitus anticipated Einstein, because both taught that everything is relative and changing." 1. Find the imported idea: relativity, a twentieth-century physical theory. 2. Check the old source: Heraclitus survives only in fragments, which stress constant change, like a river whose waters keep flowing, and the unity of opposites. 3. Check the modern idea: relativity says that measurements of time and space depend on the observer's motion; it is not a claim that everything changes. 4. Verdict: the link rests on a loose resemblance between words, so the claim is anachronistic. 5. Repair: a fair claim compares Heraclitus with later philosophers who also put change and process before fixed things, and states the differences.

Whose history? The canon

A canon is the set of thinkers and works treated as essential. Many influential histories written in nineteenth-century Europe began philosophy in Greece and left out Indian, Chinese, African and much Islamic thought, along with women philosophers such as Hypatia of Alexandria, Elisabeth of Bohemia and Mary Astell. Historians now debate how much of that exclusion reflected the evidence and how much reflected prejudice. The three approaches bear on this too. A contextualist can recover voices that mattered in their own time, a presentist can show that neglected arguments still have force, and a hermeneutic historian can ask why one generation's canon looks the way it does.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating presentism as simply wrong: testing old arguments by current standards is legitimate, provided you first read them accurately. Second, confusing anachronism with disagreement: rejecting Aristotle's conclusion is not anachronistic, but crediting him with modern concepts is. Third, thinking that context excuses everything: explaining why a view was held is not the same as showing it was true. Fourth, assuming that history has a goal and that the present is its finish line. Fifth, forgetting that your own questions shape your reading, which is the central lesson of hermeneutics.

Key takeaways

The history of philosophy has intrinsic and instrumental value. Presentists read old texts for arguments and judge them by today's standards, which makes past wisdom usable but risks anachronism and narrow reading. Contextualists, such as the Cambridge School, recover what authors meant in their own settings, which gives richer readings but risks antiquarianism. Hermeneutic historians, following thinkers such as Gadamer, combine context with an honest awareness of the reader's own standpoint, but can slide into Whig history. Which thinkers count as canonical is itself a historiographical question, and good historical work often combines all three approaches.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Historiography

The study of how history is written and how it should be studied

Here: how to study past philosophers.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A historian reads Hobbes's Leviathan alongside pamphlets from the English Civil Wars to work out what Hobbes was trying to achieve in 1651. Which approach is this?

Question 2 of 5

A writer claims that Democritus discovered the atoms of modern chemistry. What error does this commit?

Question 3 of 5

Which weakness is most closely associated with the contextualist approach?

Question 4 of 5

What distinguishes the hermeneutic approach from the other two?

Question 5 of 5

A student argues that Heraclitus anticipated Einstein's theory of relativity. What is the best historical response?

← Previous topicNext topic →