Philosophy › Section D · Classical philosophy › Topic D.2
Classical Greek philosophy: Socrates, Plato, Aristotle
In about three centuries, Greek thinkers moved from asking what the world is made of to building whole systems of knowledge, reality and the good life. Socrates, Plato and Aristotle stand at the centre, with the schools that grew up after them.
Roots and borrowings
Greek philosophy did not arise in isolation. The historian Herodotus (about 484 to 425 BCE) credited Egypt with many Greek religious ideas, and later writers told of philosophers studying there, stories that are hard to verify. Mathematics travelled: a Babylonian clay tablet known as Plimpton 322, from about 1800 BCE, records the sides of right triangles in whole numbers, fitting the relation later named after Pythagoras. How far Greek thought depended on Egypt is disputed. Martin Bernal's Black Athena argued that Greek civilisation had deep Egyptian and Phoenician roots; Mary Lefkowitz and others replied that he overstated the evidence. Most scholars accept real exchange while treating Greek philosophy as a distinct development.
The Presocratics
The earliest Greek philosophers, working from the sixth century BCE, survive only in fragments and later reports. They sought natural rather than mythological explanations. Monists traced everything to one basic stuff: Thales of Miletus to water, Anaximander to the apeiron, the boundless, and Anaximenes to air. Pluralists posited several: Empedocles named earth, air, fire and water, joined by Love and separated by Strife, and the atomists Leucippus and Democritus held that only atoms and void exist. Heraclitus stressed constant change. Parmenides argued that what is cannot come to be or pass away, so change is an illusion, and his follower Zeno defended this with paradoxes of motion.
Socrates
Socrates (about 470 to 399 BCE) wrote nothing; we know him through Plato, Xenophon and others. He questioned Athenians who claimed to know what courage, piety or justice is, and showed that their definitions clashed with their other beliefs. Unlike the Sophists, paid teachers of persuasion, he claimed only awareness of his own ignorance. Athens tried him for impiety and corrupting the young, and he was executed in 399 BCE. The topic "Socrates as a model philosopher" examines his method; here what matters is how Plato carried his questions further.
Plato and the theory of Forms
Plato (about 428 to 348 BCE) wrote dialogues, usually with Socrates as the main speaker; scholars often read the early ones as closest to the historical Socrates. Around 387 BCE Plato founded the Academy in Athens. His central doctrine is the theory of Forms: beyond the changing physical world lie Forms, perfect, unchanging and non-physical, such as Equality itself or Justice itself. Particular things have their qualities by participating in the Forms. Knowledge is of the Forms; the senses give only opinion. In effect, Plato gives Parmenides a changeless reality and Heraclitus a changing world of appearances.
Worked example: the argument from imperfection
Why believe in Forms? Here is a reconstruction of an argument from Plato's Phaedo. 1. We judge that two sticks are nearly equal, but not perfectly equal. 2. To judge that something falls short of perfect equality, we must already grasp what perfect equality is. 3. No physical pair of things is ever perfectly equal, so our grasp did not come from the senses. 4. So there is an object of thought, Equality itself, that is not a physical thing. 5. Evaluate: step 2 is plausible, but critics attack the move to step 4. We might build the idea of perfection by extending what we see, so the idea could exist in minds without a separate Form.
The cave and the just soul
In the Republic, Plato pictures prisoners chained in a cave, watching shadows on a wall and taking them for reality. One is freed, sees the fire and the objects casting the shadows, and at last climbs out into sunlight. The sun stands for the Form of the Good, which makes everything else intelligible, and education is a painful turning of the soul towards it. The Republic's just city has three classes, rulers who are philosopher-kings, soldiers and producers, each doing its own work. It mirrors a just soul in which reason rules spirit and appetite. Critics have objected, from Aristotle, who attacked its communal property and families, to Karl Popper, who called it authoritarian.
Aristotle: forms in things
Aristotle (384 to 322 BCE) studied at the Academy for about twenty years, tutored the young Alexander the Great and founded his own school, the Lyceum. He rejected Plato's separate Forms: a thing's form is the structure in that very thing, not a perfect model elsewhere. Knowledge begins with observation, and he described hundreds of animal species. He founded formal logic with the syllogism: all mammals are animals; all whales are mammals; so all whales are animals. The soul, for him, is the form of a living body, defined by what it does: nutrition in plants, perception and movement in animals, and reason in humans.
Worked example: the four causes of a clay jug
Aristotle held that full understanding answers four questions, which he called causes. 1. Material cause, what it is made of: clay, water and glaze. 2. Formal cause, its structure: the hollow body, spout and handle that make it a jug rather than a lump. 3. Efficient cause, what brought it about: the potter shaping it at the wheel, and the heat of the kiln. 4. Final cause, its end or purpose: holding and pouring liquid. 5. Extend it: for an oak, the final cause is the mature, flourishing tree, so for Aristotle nature itself works towards ends. Modern biology parts company with him here, explaining apparent purpose by evolution.
Aristotle on the good life
Every activity aims at some good, Aristotle argued, and the highest human good is eudaimonia, usually translated as flourishing: a whole life of activity in accordance with virtue, guided by reason. Virtues of character are settled habits, and each usually lies at a mean between two extremes, as courage lies between cowardice and rashness. Because humans are political animals, they flourish only within a community. The topic "Virtue ethics" develops these ideas.
After Aristotle: the later schools
Epicurus (341 to 270 BCE), an atomist, taught that the good life is pleasure understood as freedom from bodily pain and mental disturbance, found in simple living and friendship; the Roman poet Lucretius set out his system in verse. Stoicism, founded in Athens by Zeno of Citium around 300 BCE, held that virtue is the only true good and urged us to separate what is up to us from what is not; its Roman voices include Seneca, Epictetus and the emperor Marcus Aurelius. Sceptics such as Pyrrho suspended judgement, and Plato's own Academy later turned sceptical. Plotinus (about 204 to 270 CE) founded Neoplatonism, in which all reality flows from a single source, the One.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating Plato's dialogues as a reliable transcript of Socrates: they are literary works, and his own views increasingly enter them. Second, thinking Aristotle simply rejected forms; he kept them but placed them inside things. Third, reading the efficient cause as the only real cause, as modern usage does. Fourth, equating Epicurean pleasure with indulgence, when Epicurus prized calm and simplicity. Fifth, treating the Presocratics as one school, when monists, pluralists, Heraclitus and Parmenides disagreed sharply.
Key takeaways
Greek philosophy borrowed from older cultures, and how much it owed Egypt is still debated. The Presocratics sought natural explanations, from Thales's water to atoms and void, and argued over change. Socrates examined definitions; Plato placed perfect, unchanging Forms beyond the senses, pictured in the cave, and linked a just city to a just soul. Aristotle put forms inside things, founded formal logic, explained through four causes and made flourishing the human good. Epicureans, Stoics, Sceptics and Neoplatonists carried these debates into the Roman world.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The earliest Greek philosophers, from the 6th century BCE
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which Presocratic philosopher argued that what is cannot come to be or pass away, so change is an illusion?
Question 2 of 5
What was Aristotle's main disagreement with Plato's theory of Forms?
Question 3 of 5
A chair exists to give people somewhere to sit. In Aristotle's scheme, this purpose is which cause?
Question 4 of 5
In Plato's allegory of the cave, what does the sun outside the cave represent?
Question 5 of 5
What did Epicurus mean by the pleasure that makes a good life?
