Philosophy › Section A · Introduction to philosophy › Topic A.2

How philosophers arrive at truth

Philosophers rarely run laboratory experiments, yet they still need evidence. This topic sets out the kinds of evidence they use, the tools they use to test ideas, and how they choose between rival views when none is perfect.

Evidence without a laboratory

The previous topic, "What is philosophy?", described philosophy as the attempt to see how everything fits together. That aim needs more than opinion: a philosophical claim must come with reasons that others can examine. The first kind of evidence is the history of philosophy itself. Questions such as what makes a life good have been argued over for more than two thousand years, in India and China as well as in Greece, and earlier answers give today's thinkers arguments to build on and mistakes to avoid.

Intuition

In everyday speech an intuition is a hunch. In philosophy it means something stronger: a judgement that seems clearly true simply on careful reflection. René Descartes described this as a conception so clear and attentive that it leaves no room for doubt. The model case is arithmetic. Think about 2 + 2 = 4 and you see that it could not be false without giving up what numbers and addition are. Moral judgements, such as that torturing someone for fun is wrong, strike many people with similar force. But intuitions differ in strength, and where thoughtful people disagree, a so-called intuition may be no more than a belief.

Common sense and experiment

A third source is common sense: basic claims from perception that seem to need no further proof. In a 1939 lecture the British philosopher G. E. Moore answered sceptics by holding up his hands. He argued that he knew he had hands, so external things exist, and that this was more certain than any premise a sceptic could offer. A fourth source is experimental philosophy, which uses survey and laboratory methods to test what ordinary people actually think. In a well-known 2003 study, Joshua Knobe found that people were much more likely to call a harmful side effect intentional than a helpful one. Results from the sciences count too.

Arguments and explanations

The most important tool is logic, the study of good reasoning. An argument is a set of statements in which some, the premises, are offered as reasons for another, the conclusion. Real writing rarely sets arguments out neatly, so the first step is reconstruction: find the conclusion, then list the premises that support it, staying faithful to what the author meant. A claim with no good reasons behind it may still be true, but believing it is not rational. Reasoning can also run backwards, from something observed to what best explains it, as a detective works back from clues to the culprit.

Coherence

A set of beliefs is coherent, or consistent, if it is possible for all of them to be true together. If they cannot all be true, they contradict each other, and at least one must be false. Suppose someone believes that every event has a cause, that free choices have no cause, and that some events are free choices. These three cannot all be true, so something has to go. Consistency has a limit: a novel can be perfectly consistent and still be fiction, so coherence cannot prove beliefs true. It can only show that a set of beliefs is not wholly true.

Conceptual analysis

Conceptual analysis breaks a complex idea into simpler parts to find out what it involves. A dictionary records how a word is used; analysis asks whether that use is clear and consistent. Following Gottlob Frege, a sentence can be split into names for objects and predicates that describe them: in "the flower is yellow", "is yellow" is the predicate. Bertrand Russell proposed analysing names as definite descriptions that pick out exactly one thing, such as "the Kevin whose desk is by the door". Enumeration lists the parts of a whole, as Aristotle treated wisdom as understanding of first principles combined with knowledge demonstrated from them.

Thought experiments

A thought experiment is an imagined case built to isolate one feature of a concept or theory. In Plato's Republic, the shepherd Gyges finds a ring that makes him invisible, and the question is whether anyone would stay just if they could never be caught. In the trolley problem, first posed by Philippa Foot in 1967 and named by Judith Jarvis Thomson, a runaway tram will kill five people unless it is switched onto a track where it will kill one. Most people think switching is permitted but pushing a man off a bridge to stop the tram is not. Explaining that difference tests moral theories.

Worked example: is it ever right to lie?

1. Define the term: to lie is to assert what you believe to be false, intending to deceive. Staying silent or keeping a secret is not lying. 2. State the claim to test: lying is always wrong. 3. Look for a counterexample: a would-be murderer asks where your friend is hiding. Most people judge that lying here is right. 4. Note a famous dissent: Immanuel Kant, in a 1797 essay, held that even this lie is wrong. 5. Ask which principle explains the case: good consequences, respect for persons, or honest character. 6. Conclude: the case does not settle ethics, but it shows that "never lie" needs either defending or qualifying.

Trade-offs and biting the bullet

Logic, evidence and analysis rarely point to a single view that passes every test. Usually rival views each have strong support and real costs, so philosophers weigh trade-offs, asking which view explains the most while giving up the least. Sometimes a thinker decides to bite the bullet: to accept an uncomfortable consequence because the view is attractive for other reasons. Someone convinced that the past fully determines the future may accept that free will is an illusion. Someone who judges actions only by their results may accept that harming one person can be right if it produces enough good.

Worked example: reaching reflective equilibrium

Reflective equilibrium, a method named by John Rawls in 1971, adjusts principles and judgements about cases against each other. 1. Start with a principle: always keep your promises. 2. Test it on a case: you promised to meet a friend for lunch, but on the way you find someone injured who needs help. 3. Your judgement about the case is firm: help the injured person. 4. Revise the principle: keep promises unless keeping one would mean failing a much more serious duty. 5. Test the revision on new cases, such as breaking a promise for a slightly better offer, which it still forbids. 6. Equilibrium is reached when principles and case judgements fit together.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, a philosophical intuition is not a gut feeling; it is a judgement that stays clear on careful reflection. Second, a consistent set of beliefs is not thereby true, though an inconsistent set must contain a falsehood. Third, a dictionary definition is where analysis starts, not where it ends. Fourth, one counterexample is enough to refute an "always" or "never" claim, but it does not prove the opposite claim. Fifth, in reflective equilibrium both principles and case judgements can be revised.

Key takeaways

Philosophical claims need evidence: the history of philosophy, intuitions, common sense, experimental philosophy and the results of other disciplines. Logic tests arguments, in which premises support a conclusion, and explanations. Coherence can show that beliefs conflict but cannot prove them true. Conceptual analysis clarifies ideas through predicates, definite descriptions, enumeration and thought experiments. Because no view is perfect, philosophers weigh trade-offs, sometimes bite the bullet, and seek reflective equilibrium between principles and judgements about cases.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Philosophical intuition

A judgement that seems clearly true on careful reflection

2 + 2 = 4 is the model case; not a hunch.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

When philosophers appeal to intuition, what do they usually mean?

Question 2 of 5

Ana believes three things: every event has a cause; free choices have no cause; some events are free choices. What can logic alone tell her?

Question 3 of 5

A friend says, "Lying is always wrong." You describe someone lying to a would-be murderer to protect a friend. What are you offering?

Question 4 of 5

Someone revises the principle "always keep promises" after deciding that helping an injured stranger matters more than a lunch date. Which method are they using?

Question 5 of 5

What did G. E. Moore try to show by holding up his hands?

← Previous topicNext topic →